It’s long overdue but to assist with future deals here’s a vouch thread. If we’ve ever done business together, thanks in advance for your support as well as our past and future dealings! #psacard#topps#panini#hobby#collecting
🚨Boston Card Hunter SUED for defamation.
The outspoken hobby watchdog likely has had his bite taken away for good.
The lawsuit filed against him in Indiana by a small creator is one of the FEW hobby lawsuits that has some merit.
Here is what happened:
This spring, Boston Card Hunter told his audience that a custom card artist from Indiana had called his house and threatened to kill his family.
A serious allegation.
By June, Boston Card Hunter admitted in writing that he had no evidence for it.
Read that again. In writing, Boston Card Hunter says he didn't have any basis to say that on camera.
The artist, who has about 1,000 followers on Instagram, was unsatisfied with any half-hearted apology via email and kept going at Boston Card Hunter throughout the summer, tagging him in posts, making memes, etc.
Most of those posts garnered only a small audience.
But in September, apparently sick of the criticism, Boston Card Hunter had his lawyer send a cease and desist letter to the guy.
➡️ That was a HUGE mistake.
Less than a week later, Boston Card Hunter was hit with a defamation lawsuit.
And now the two sides are talking through lawyers — and the one thing both of them seem to agree on is that the accusation should never have been made by Boston Card Hunter.
➡️ Why this is a bad spot for Boston Card Hunter
We are not self proclaimed hobby lawyers. But you do not need to be one to see the shape of this.
Accusing someone of a crime is the easiest kind of defamation to prove.
Boston Card Hunter tagged the artist in a video titled "Someone Threatened Me & My Family."
In the video he spoke for more than two minutes about who he believed made the calls — and put a specific small artist's Instagram handle on screen while he did it.
But months later Boston Card Hunter said in writing he had "no evidence" connecting the artist to the calls.
Yikes.
In addition, because Boston Card Hunter went after such a small creator it really hurts him in this case.
The guy suing Boston Card Hunter has fewer than 750 followers on X.
He will likely argue he is a private figure, and a court will probably agree.
That matters because a private figure only has to show the speaker was careless — not that he knowingly lied.
That's really, really bad for Boston Card Hunter.
➡️ But there is more.
Burlington, Massachusetts police logs show at least three entries tied to Boston Card Hunter's address in April alone — two where he reported receiving threats himself, and one where another hobbyist reported him for harassment.
According to one written complaint, Boston Card Hunter called a collector unprompted over the collector's criticism of Fanatics, talked for 19 minutes, and described himself as "the Ray Donovan of Fanatics."
The collector filed a harassment report with Burlington police in April.
➡️ What happens next
Boston Card Hunter was served the week of October 5. Under Indiana rules he has about 20 days to respond, which puts the deadline in the last week of October.
No matter what happens, it will cost Boston Card Hunter money and will likely change his tune for the foreseeable future.
Just last week, Boston Card Hunter posted three times mentioning how his tone and content will now shift.
While he claims it's to not make "boring and repetitive" videos… the truth is probably something different.
In the cease and desist letter, Boston Card Hunter's lawyer wrote: "As a direct and proximate result of your interference, Mr. Andrews has suffered demonstrable economic harm, including a significant reduction in the frequency of his livestream programming and associated lost revenue."
Sports Card Radio has sent written questions to Boston Card Hunter's attorney.
Any response will be published in full. Nothing in the lawsuit has been proven in court.
Tiger SOLD 🔥 on eBay $3,500
Don’t sleep on the reach of eBay! Twice this week we’ve moved a big card and set the highest comp!
You have to be consistent with all channels… X, IG, eBay, and card shows for us 🙏
@2CapsCards_2