My view of X through a Buddhist lens.
This isn't nihilism, pessimism, or blackpilling. It's simply an attempt to see things as they really are.
Impermanence is not a negative outlook. It is a fact of existence. Recognising it doesn't mean rejecting life, abandoning hope, or denying joy.
It means understanding that nothing conditioned is permanent, and that no amount of political conviction, ideology, wealth, or power, influence, Tweets, likes, shares, or follows can change that.
It's not pessimism. It's seeing clearly.
Most posts and comments on X point to one thing: dukkha.
Dukkha is an ancient Indian word describing the pervasive unsatisfactoriness and unreliability of conditioned existence.
Look at politics. Politicians rise to power, make promises, build careers, win elections, and eventually lose their positions.
Policies are reversed, governments collapse, reputations crumble, after being caught lying, stealing and cheating, and what one administration spends years building can be dismantled by the next.
The same arguments repeat. The same promises are broken and recycled.
Today's victories become tomorrow's disappointments.
Those who once held power become yesterday's old news.
This is dukkha in plain sight.
It is not simply that things go wrong. It is that nothing conditioned can provide lasting security. Everything is unstable, insecure, subject to change, destruction, decay, and eventual loss.
A politician's term comes to an end. A political movement like Hope and Change, or Woke, or MAGA loses its influence. An ideology once considered revolutionary becomes outdated.
Even those who achieve everything they set out to achieve eventually discover that nothing can be held indefinitely.
The Buddha was not denying that life contains genuine joy or that political change can make a difference. He was pointing to something more fundamental: nothing conditioned can bear the weight of our craving for permanence.
Keep this wider understanding of dukkha in mind when considering politics, power, and everything else that follow.
The craving for stability and permanent happiness is ultimately futile. Everything conditioned is subject to change, ageing, sickness, and death.
No politician can save you from this. No government, ideology, political movement, or policy can exempt you from the fundamental conditions of existence.
You can spend your life arguing on X, posting, commenting, blaming, attacking, ridiculing, undermining, sabotaging and demanding Hope and Change or to Make America Great Again. Some things may improve, others may get worse. But none of it changes the underlying reality.
No amount of political activity can make the impermanent permanent.
Everything passes. The pleasant and the unpleasant, the good and the bad, hope and change, MAGA and every political movement that promises to restore some imagined golden age.
America cannot be made great again simply by looking backwards. It was never perfect. Empires rise and fall. The Roman Empire fell. The British Empire faded. No nation, however powerful, escapes the conditions of impermanence.
The same applies to the things we cling to and the things we resist. Nothing conditioned is permanent.
This is impermanence (anicca), and it is inseparable from dukkha.
What does he expect Iran to do, send him a box of chocolates?
Civilian deaths in Iran are generally reported in the 1,200–1,700+ range in independent tallies for the main early phase, including hundreds of children.
Documented incidents include a strike on a girls’ school in Minab (reported -120–175 civilians killed, mostly children), hits on a wedding, a youth sports facility, and other non-military sites.
@writtenbylori Russell wasn't prosecuted for being a Christian. He became a Christian after facing prosecution for rape. There's a rather important distinction.
Jesus would probably be crucified all over again if he appeared today, whether in Gaza or Israel.
His teachings on compassion, forgiveness, non-violence and challenging religious and political authority would hardly make him popular with those who wield power.
Some things, it seems, haven't changed much in 2,000 years.
He didn't teach suicidal empathy like Gad Saad, put it that way.
@HarrisonHSmith Both are very interesting, but both have their blind spots and biases. Nick is still young and has some maturing to do.
Alex, by comparison, is more mature and seems to approach things with greater perspective.
As a lifelong practising Buddhist, I would say that many Jews, Hindus and Christians may attain rebirth in a heavenly realm.
But there is a fundamental problem: heaven is also impermanent. No heavenly existence lasts forever. Eventually, the conditions supporting that rebirth come to an end, and one is born again elsewhere.
From a Buddhist perspective, the goal is not simply to reach heaven. It is to attain liberation from the entire cycle of birth, death and rebirth.
The problem I see isn't his rockets. It's the belief that we are the only consciousness in the universe. From a Buddhist perspective, this is a rather limited view of existence.
In Buddhist cosmology, there are traditionally 31 planes of existence, encompassing different forms of consciousness and different realms of rebirth. Human existence is only one of them.
There are heavenly realms, realms inhabited by Brahmās, as well as lower realms of existence.
The human realm is just one part of a much larger cosmological picture. Buddhism does not place humanity at the centre of the universe or assume that human beings are the only form of conscious existence.
Of course, the 31 realms are part of traditional Buddhist cosmology, not an established scientific description of the universe.
But the underlying challenge to human exceptionalism is worth considering: why assume that our particular form of consciousness is the only one?
My take on God is probably not a popular one, particularly among followers of the Abrahamic religions. Judaism, Christianity and Islam understand God as the eternal creator of the universe. Buddhism takes a fundamentally different position.
It's not that I don't believe this God exists. I do. My position is that this being was mistaken about his own nature and, in believing himself to be the creator of the universe, misled countless people through his communications with Abraham, Moses, Jesus, Muhammad and others.
Even so, I have no problem with people worshipping this God if they feel it benefits them or helps them reach his heavenly realm. From a Buddhist perspective, however, the problem is that this realm is not permanent.
Even if you attain rebirth in a heavenly realm, you will eventually exhaust the conditions that brought you there and be reborn elsewhere.
In Buddhist cosmology, even the highest heavenly realms are impermanent. They are not liberation from the cycle of birth and death.
You may enjoy a very long existence in heaven, but you will not remain there forever. Eventually, you will find yourself back here, or in another realm of existence.
That is the fundamental distinction. Buddhism is not concerned merely with reaching heaven. It is concerned with liberation from the entire cycle of rebirth.
In Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, Abraham, Moses, Jesus, Noah, Adam and the other prophets are understood to have worshipped the same one God, traditionally identified as the God of Abraham.
The three religions differ significantly in their understanding of God's nature, revelation and relationship with humanity, but all trace their monotheistic traditions to Abraham.
From a Buddhist perspective, however, the belief in an eternal, all-powerful God who created the universe is mistaken. Early Buddhist teachings reject the idea of a supreme creator and instead explain existence through dependent origination: everything arises and ceases through causes and conditions.
The Buddhist texts go further. In the Brahmajāla Sutta (DN 1), the Buddha describes how a powerful being, known as a Brahmā, can mistakenly believe himself to be the creator of the universe because he is unaware of the conditions that preceded his existence. In Buddhist cosmology, even gods are subject to impermanence, ignorance and rebirth.
Thus, what the Abrahamic traditions understand as the one eternal creator, Buddhism would regard as a mistaken understanding of the nature of existence. From this perspective, no being, however powerful, stands outside the law of dependent origination.
In Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, Abraham, Moses, Jesus, Noah, Adam and the other prophets are understood to have worshipped the same one God, traditionally identified as the God of Abraham.
The three religions differ significantly in their understanding of God's nature, revelation and relationship with humanity, but all trace their monotheistic traditions to Abraham.
From a Buddhist perspective, however, the belief in an eternal, all-powerful God who created the universe is mistaken. Early Buddhist teachings reject the idea of a supreme creator and instead explain existence through dependent origination: everything arises and ceases through causes and conditions.
The Buddhist texts go further. In the Brahmajāla Sutta (DN 1), the Buddha describes how a powerful being, known as a Brahmā, can mistakenly believe himself to be the creator of the universe because he is unaware of the conditions that preceded his existence. In Buddhist cosmology, even gods are subject to impermanence, ignorance and rebirth.
Thus, what the Abrahamic traditions understand as the one eternal creator, Buddhism would regard as a mistaken understanding of the nature of existence. From this perspective, no being, however powerful, stands outside the law of dependent origination.
Nick seems to have several blind spots that I could easily challenge, particularly when it comes to his views on Jews.
He also appears prone to black-and-white thinking and a tendency towards splitting: dividing people into opposing camps of good and bad, rather than recognising the complexity and contradictions that exist in human beings.
It's a way of thinking that leaves little room for nuance, self-examination or independent judgement. And ironically, someone can be highly critical of other people's thinking while remaining remarkably unaware of their own.
Elon Musk: Independent Thinker or Political Loyalist?
I've always found Elon Musk an interesting figure. He presents himself as an independent thinker, sceptical of established institutions and willing to challenge conventional wisdom.
But there is a question worth asking: how independent is his thinking when it comes to people and political movements with which he is aligned?
Musk has previously spoken about the stupidity of war, the dangers of military escalation and the absurdity of sending rockets at one another rather than into space. These are sensible observations. Yet when it comes to the bombing of Iran, his public position appears considerably less clear.
I haven't seen him offer a direct and unequivocal condemnation of the military campaign, nor have I seen a clear endorsement. That distinction matters. We shouldn't attribute positions to someone without evidence. But his silence raises a legitimate question.
Is this political calculation, moral inconsistency or simply a reluctance to challenge people within his own political circle?
I suspect there may be an element of all three.
It's relatively easy to criticise the military-industrial complex in abstract terms. It's another matter entirely when doing so means challenging political allies, particularly those with whom you have established relationships and influence.
This is where I think Musk's supposed intellectual independence deserves scrutiny.
If you oppose war, you should oppose it consistently. If you believe bombing civilians is wrong, that principle shouldn't depend on which government is dropping the bombs.
And if you believe people have a right to freedom, that right doesn't disappear because their government happens to be one you dislike.
The Iranian regime is repressive. Its record speaks for itself. But opposing that regime doesn't require supporting the destruction of Iran or accepting the deaths of ordinary Iranians as some necessary price of liberation.
There is a deeper philosophical issue here.
The real test of intellectual independence isn't whether you're prepared to challenge people you disagree with. It's whether you're prepared to challenge people you agree with.
Otherwise, what you have isn't independent thinking. It's tribal loyalty masquerading as intellectual freedom.
And perhaps that's the real problem with much of contemporary politics. People claim to think independently, but their principles seem to change depending on whose side they're on.
Integrity is not demonstrated by the opinions you hold when they're convenient. It's demonstrated by the principles you're unwilling to abandon when they're not.
The problem I see right off the bat is that there is no definitive number of Gods in this world, but estimates would run into the thousands, potentially tens of thousands, if we include every recorded deity across human history.
Nick can't be that naive to seriously expect everyone in America to worship the same God he does. America is a country of many faiths, beliefs and traditions.
Religious freedom means exactly that: the freedom to worship as you choose, or not to worship at all.
His beliefs don't take precedence over everyone else's.
The problem I see is, there is no definitive number of Gods in this world, but estimates would run into the thousands, potentially tens of thousands, if we include every recorded deity across human history.
He can't seriously expect everyone in America to worship the same God he does. America is a country of many faiths, beliefs and traditions.
Religious freedom means exactly that: the freedom to worship as you choose, or not to worship at all. His beliefs don't take precedence over everyone else's.
Elon Musk, Iran and the Contradiction of War
Elon Musk has previously made some interesting observations about war. In April 2024, following Israeli strikes on Iran, he suggested that we should be sending rockets into space rather than at one another.
He also questioned the absurdity of American taxpayers effectively financing opposing sides of a conflict.
These are reasonable observations. But they raise a more important question: where does he stand on the bombing of Iran now?
I haven't seen a clear, unequivocal statement from Musk either endorsing or condemning the current military campaign.
What interests me is the contradiction.
Musk has spoken about the dangers of war, the military-industrial complex and the possibility of nuclear escalation.
Yet there is a considerable difference between making general observations about the stupidity of war and applying those principles when they become politically inconvenient.
Let's be clear about something. Opposing the Iranian regime does not mean supporting the destruction of Iran.
The Iranian government has a long record of repression, political executions and violations of human rights. None of that is in dispute. But the Iranian people are not their government.
Millions of ordinary Iranians have suffered under that regime. Why should they now have to suffer through a foreign military campaign as well?
And what exactly is the objective? Regime change? Democracy? National security? The elimination of Iran's military capabilities?
These are very different objectives, and none comes with a guarantee of success.
There is also the wider geopolitical reality. Iran is not an isolated country. Russia, China, Pakistan and other regional powers have strategic interests at stake.
Escalation carries consequences that extend well beyond the immediate battlefield. Once a conflict expands, nobody can confidently predict where it will end.
I find the underlying argument particularly troubling. We are repeatedly told that military intervention is necessary to bring freedom to people living under oppressive governments.
But how do you bring freedom to a population by bombing its cities, destroying its infrastructure and killing its civilians?
You cannot bomb a country into democracy any more than you can bomb a population into freedom.
The Iranian people have the right to determine their own future. That includes the right to remove their own government. It does not give Washington or Tel Aviv the moral authority to decide that future for them.
And this is where I would like to hear Musk speak more clearly.
If he believes war is destructive, if he understands the dangers of escalation and if he recognises the absurdity of the military-industrial complex, then surely those principles should apply to Iran as well.
Freedom cannot be selective. Neither can morality.
Otherwise, we aren't really talking about liberation. We're talking about power, dressed up in the language of freedom.
@elonmusk has spoken about Gaza, but his position has been somewhat mixed.
In November 2023, during an interview with Lex Fridman, he made an interesting observation. He questioned how many future militants Israel was creating for every Hamas member it killed.
He also argued that Israel needed to demonstrate acts of kindness towards Palestinians.
He subsequently visited Israel, met Netanyahu and expressed support for rebuilding Gaza after the destruction of Hamas.
He also helped provide Starlink connectivity to a UAE field hospital in Rafah.
But there is a distinction worth making.
Recognising that killing Palestinian children creates more hatred is one thing.
Explicitly condemning the destruction of Gaza and the killing of Palestinian civilians is another.
I haven't seen Musk make an unequivocal statement condemning the devastation inflicted on Gaza.
Here are the notable examples:
1. November 2023 – Lex Fridman interview. Musk argued that Israel should show what he called "conspicuous acts of kindness" towards Palestinians.
He warned that killing Palestinian children would create more people who hate Israel and potentially more future militants.
He said:
"For every Hamas member that you kill, how many did you create?"
2. November 2023 – Visit to Israel. Musk met Benjamin Netanyahu, visited communities attacked on October 7 and expressed support for rebuilding Gaza after the destruction of Hamas.
3. July 2024 – Starlink in Gaza. Musk helped activate Starlink internet at a UAE field hospital in Rafah, with Israeli approval. This provided communications support for medical personnel.
4. January 2026 – Trump's Gaza Peace Board. At Davos, Musk mocked the name, joking that perhaps it should be called the Board of "Piece" rather than Peace, referring to territorial ambitions elsewhere.
5. October 2026 – Comments on Israel. In an interview with Walter Isaacson, Musk praised Israel's security approach and discussed the threats it faces.