Burnham, NEETs and the false ending of neoliberalism.
I think the government’s response to youth unemployment tells you what is wrong with Burnham’s government, suggesting we certainly will not be "ending neoliberalism" anytime soon.
The government is going to pursue the same surface-level individualising policymaking, the essence of neoliberalism, in fact.
The data shows that young people are out of work because entry-level jobs are not there. And it also shows that the trend began before the NI increases (the right's preferred false explanation). This really boils down to two quite simple things.
1. Interest rates. The Bank of England uses rate rises as its only lever against inflation. High rates are meant to cool the labour market: they deliberately and intentionally make people poorer so that workers stop demanding higher wages. And they are being used against an inflation that comes from supply (gas, electricity, war, fertiliser shortages), not from “too much money” in the economy.
2. AI. In its current form, AI is already wiping out the basic tasks that young workers used to be hired to do.
Fixing these structural factors would require brave policy decisions. So the government has moved the problem back onto the individual.
1. Blame young people themselves (anxiety, mental health, “faking disability”, refusing to take jobs)
2. Blame employers for failing to hire them, even though the rules of free market capitalism give firms little incentive to do so.
Thus the policies will follow from this false diagnosis:
1. Treat young people as cases to be managed, with “confidence building” and “job skills”.
2. Use taxpayers’ money to bribe businesses into offering short-term positions.
Not only will the structural causes of the labour market shrinkage be completely unaffected by these policies while they're being implemented, but those structural causes will strengthen. AI job losses will begin to spread upwards, with mid- and late-career workers also facing the chop.
tl;dr: we are so cooked.
I really don't know how on earth we've arrived at a place where the government is paying private corporations to temporarily employ people while councils can't afford to hire librarians.
1/ Everything that is wrong with the Milburn report.
• The report gets to the heart of the problem: "We have to stop treating youth employment principally as a problem of supply when it is also a problem of demand".
• The share of young people who are neither in employment nor in education or training (NEET) stands at 13.0% today, compared with 13.4% in 2002.
• It is not young people who have changed, but the jobs themselves.
• The report then goes on to do exactly the opposite of what that diagnosis requires.
this is the funniest goal ever because u can see Van Dijk trying his usual aura defending gimmick but didn't realise he was dealing with an absolute crackhead.
Imagine giving money to councils to create public sector jobs. Teaching young people to be tree surgeons and road maintenance engineers and landscape gardeners. Instead of paying private companies so they can stack shelves. Unimaginative and unambitious.
Nothing to see here, just Alan Milburn, who overclaimed £11,000 for his council tax, cutting benefits for under 25s and deciding £338 a month is enough for them to live off
This year the Netherlands amended their welfare reform act (The Participation Act) because it was TOO HARSH, so anyone (ahem, Milburn) advocating to adopt a similar model are setting up for failure
Also their youth unemployment rate has risen since 2021 mainly due to ill health
Hahahaahahha guess who's in charge of youth loans. Gareth Whalley.
Guess where he worked before. Man City.
Guess who with. Jason Wilcox.
Guess how he got the job. When Evans stepped down as Head of Loans, Wilcox recruited Whalley.
Laughable🤣 Sack this fraud & his minions.
The benefits bill (bar covid) has been static for over 10 years & youth unemployment is smallest slice of it. Half of it is the state pension.
#BBCLauraK
Helen Whately claims £6680 for EACH of her 3 children, every year.
We pay £20k per year for a millionaire’s kids. Now add her yearly £39k rent, energy bills, council tax
But she thinks disabled children who don’t have the privilege of millionaire parents shouldn’t have support.
Less than 700,000 job vacancies in the whole of the UK btw. And that's a figure that was already falling before the NICs increase, so you can't blame that either.
We also have a skills and infrastructure crisis, but are spending £2.5 billion giving free labour to big companies.
@patmcfaddenmp It's a false dichotomy; you also have the option to make those with over £10m pay just 2% more on every £1m over £10m
61% of under 25s on UC work/have mandatory work requirements
22% of under 25s on UC are too ill to work but 94% of them will enter poverty if you cut £ support
how "inevitable global inflation" stops at borders where corporations aren't allowed to run the show.
It kind of makes you realise why the the greedy capitalists call you communists if you want fair prices.
tape
Higher packaging taxes and National Insurance
And their personal favourite: having to pay their own staff minimum wage rises. Thoughts and prayers for the shareholders.
pricing decisions made in corporate boardrooms.
If you ask UK supermarkets why your weekly shop now costs roughly 40% more than it did in 2020, they have a very polished list of excuses ready:
Supply chain shocks
Bad weather hurting crops like cocoa and coffee
Post-Brexit red