Every single farmer and food producer in this country, whether they export to the EU or don’t (as the vast majority do not) will nonetheless be run with rules and laws set by the European Commission.
The Conservative Party must of course care about the sovereignty, independence, and self-government of this country. That is what they have existed to do for 200 years. It can't be a second order issue.
This isn’t a trade deal, this is the UK Government handing over complete control of our food laws to the EU.
And we will have no vote, no veto, and no voice over how those regulations are imposed on us in the future.
The overwhelming majority of farmers in this country do not export goods, not just to the EU, but to anywhere, and most of their goods are sold in the UK.
The fact that they don’t export is irrelevant under this Government’s new deal. It will mean that whether you export your goods to Europe or whether you don’t, you are still going to have to follow the EU’s rules.
And for many farmers, that will mean an enormous change in the ways that they are able to grow food, how they’re able to package it, and they can do nothing about this.
Farmers are utterly perplexed as to why this Government keeps saying that this is going to be a bonus for UK farming.
If this Government is serious about helping UK farming, then they will cut the many taxes they have raised, they will cut the red tape that they have imposed on all businesses through their job-destroying Employment Rights Act, and they will listen to farmers and stop treating them as if they are an afterthought and a pawn in their ideological game.
Every time a minister or the Prime Minister stands up on television and says it’s going to lower food prices we should all be asking by how much and by when. We’ve asked them that question and they never answer it because they don't know the answer to it, they haven't got one.
Every time a minister or the Prime Minister stands up on television and says it’s going to lower food prices we should all be asking by how much and by when.
We’ve asked them that question and they never answer it because they don't know the answer to it, they haven't got one.
BREAKING:
The EU will not implement the Brexit reset deal until Andy Burnham agrees to allow European students to pay the same as their UK counterparts, @oliver_wright reports
Member states have overruled the Commission and put the whole package on ice until the tuition fees offer is resolved
The could delay the implantation of the youth mobility scheme and plans to end checks on food being exported from Britain to Europe
“The council agrees that adoption of the council decisions on signing the agreements shall not precede the conclusion of the negotiations on the supplementing agreement providing equal treatment on tuition fees,” the council said
UK-EU summit live: PM set to sign reset deal after ‘down to the wire’ talks
https://t.co/zAm0AacSGG
"When the SPS reset is announced tomorrow, we will be told, and expected to believe, that abandoning the right to make our own laws on food and agriculture constitutes some sort of benefit for this country. That puzzles me, and I admit that I am a bit confused by the Government’s negotiating strategy in this reset more generally. In my experience, most negotiations involve giving something that benefits the other side in return for something that benefits you. This negotiation has involved asking for things that benefit the EU in return for conceding things that benefit the EU. It is a novel approach to negotiations.
One must spare a thought for Maroš Šefčovič, my old sparring partner, who must have been a bit flummoxed by this. He has, after all, spent a career negotiating with people who actually wanted to get something from him. He was not in his current job between 2016 and 2018, so he will not have been familiar with British negotiators with this unique negotiating style. But he has adjusted, and was no doubt delighted to discover that the EU single market for food and agriculture could be enlarged without going through any of the inconvenience of giving Britain any say in it.
Mr Šefčovič certainly seemed pretty delighted on Monday, when he spoke at the UK-EU Parliamentary Partnership Assembly of his “intense” “dating schedule” with our negotiator, the Minister, Mr Falconer, who, for his part, said that his role had “felt like a honeymoon”, and that although they were not married,
“the relationship is indeed very close”.
If I may bring a colloquial term into your Lordships’ House, this kind of thing slightly gives me the ick.
Our relationship with the EU is not a marriage. We just went through a long and unnecessarily painful divorce, but the remainer/rejoin establishment, so well represented on the Benches opposite, are still turning up at the ex’s house and desperately trying to bestow gifts in the hope that there will one day be another chance. That is the context in which we must see this SPS deal.
Let us be clear about the problem the Government tried to solve here. British traders face costs at the border, as they do at all kinds of borders and always have. Some of those costs are imposed unnecessarily by our own Government and the others are real, but even Mr Falconer himself claims these are only some tens of millions of pounds per year. If the aim was to reduce that number, why not just reduce or subsidise those costs? Instead, Labour’s way of cutting the paperwork at the border has been to agree that Brussels should write all the paperwork everywhere else and that we should pay it to do so. Dynamic alignment sounds so much better than doing what you are told.
We already have to accept EU food rules in order to sell food in Europe. This agreement is not about that; it is about accepting the rules and transactions which have nothing to do with the European Union. Food and animal exports to the EU are under 1% of this economy. Most British food production never goes anywhere near the EU and only 6% of it goes abroad at all. For most British producers, the effect of the SPS deal will be to remove a barrier between them and a European customer they do not have anyway and to put a new cost between them and a British customer they do have. It has achieved something remarkable and truly innovative: imposing the expense and inconvenience of the EU single market without even having to sell into it.
In all this, we get no say. Of course, British diplomats can turn up and say what they think, but they are then kicked out of the room and the EU gets on with it, and, whatever is agreed, we have to put up with it. In Andy Burnham’s British Food restaurant, there is no menu; the waiter just tells you that you have to have whatever the chef decides. And if you want to leave, apparently you have to pay for that, too.
The Government tell us it is all worth it to get some growth—0.14%, to be precise—in 2040. The DBT methodology note of 22 May last year admits:
“This analysis is not a full cost-benefit analysis of an SPS agreement”.
Too right it is not, for it covers only the benefits and not the costs: the inability to import cheaper food from outside the EU and the inability to reform our own rules and promote innovation. This week, the more serious estimate we had from the Growth Commission says that, over 10 years, there will be about 1% of benefits and 3% of costs—a loss of 2% of GDP and, in 10 years’ time, some £2,400 per household. The savings from less red tape for exporters are going to be dwarfed by higher prices for everyone else.
In 2018, some of the EU’s negotiators were filmed joking that Britain had become the EU’s first colony. Unfortunately, eight years on, it seems that we have a British Government who do not think that that was a joke. The old Colonial Office used to send young men abroad to govern people who had not asked for it. The Government have reversed the arrangements—they send young negotiators abroad to ask Brussels to govern us.
Think about it for a moment. This agreement gives Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz more say over British food and agriculture than the British Prime Minister. How can that be right? Under no pressure at all, the Government have needlessly, gratuitously, unnecessarily chosen to give away this Parliament’s rights to an institution in which we are not represented. They should be ashamed of themselves."
"This agreement gives Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz more say over British food and agriculture than the British Prime Minister. How can that be right?"
The final words of my speech today in @UKHouseofLords on Labour's EU agrifood agreement.
Full text in next post.
🚨"The EU could write rules that are bad… and there's nothing we can do about it. We did this ten years ago, I wasn't even an MP just to show you how in the past this man is.
Kemi Badenoch swipes at Andy Burnham for his planned Brexit betrayal.
@KemiBadenoch | @JuliaHB1
Extraordinary.
If there's suddenly money to cut tuition fees for EU students, why not scrap real interest rates on Plan 2 student loans?
Burnham is putting foreign students ahead of our own young people.
Exclusive from @patrickkmaguire
Cabinet ministers believe the energy secretary is privately encouraging Labour MPs to oppose approval for new oil drilling
Miatta Fahnbulleh is accused by colleagues of pushing backbenchers to lobby the government against granting permission for Rosebank oilfield. Sources close to her said the claims were “categorically untrue”
In what threatens to become the biggest rebellion of his premiership so far, at least 75 Labour MPs have signed a private letter to Andy Burnham in which they argue approving Rosebank would not reduce energy bills
Fahnbulleh, a longstanding advocate of green energy policies who will be ultimately responsible for giving the green light to drilling off the Scottish coast, is suspected by ministerial colleagues of tacitly supporting the revolt as a pretext for withholding approval
She approved drilling in the Jackdaw gasfield last month but said the same rationale did not necessarily apply to Rosebank.
“One is a gasfield that caters for the domestic market, while the other is an oilfield that is mainly for export,” she said. “It is right that we judge each application in its own right, and it is absolutely critical that the decision is consistent with our climate obligations, our carbon budgets and the end destination we need to get to with the energy transition.”
Andy Burnham’s cabinet divided over Rosebank oil drilling
https://t.co/usIqSiLtjv
This is delicious: Mike Wood MP (Conservative) absolutely rips the arse off Andy Burnham and his Government (who send the gormless and sour faced @HFalconerMP to sit there and take it like a pleb) over this Friday's Brexit surrender.
Opposition Day Debate: UK-EU relations
He takes multiple interventions, from the usual suspects, which makes it even more watchable.