@whtesde GI is pseudoscience. No one has even been able to give a non-circular definition for it, and as someone who has actually read the relevant papers it is very clear you’re just pulling argument from authority & have no clue yourself.
You can believe whatever you want, as my OP pointed out the problem is forcing your beliefs onto the rest of us.
Affirmation approach won via smear campaigns & cancellations (e.g. Ken Zucker), it’s always been based on AGPs’ desires, not evidence.
@CameronStuart89@BadWritingTakes Believing someone is a woman is not a violation of human rights. It is also not a violation of human rights to give children medical treatment according to established medical protocols.
@whtesde Literally no one has a gender identity.
It is not supported by neuroscience.
You’re arguing that a group who are defined by lying about their sex can be trusted to recognise & acknowledge their AGP. As you likely already know, few do.
@whtesde No one has a gender identity.
Are you actually conflating discussion of AGP with going up to random AGPs and telling them they have it? Or just trying to censor all discussion of AGP from the public square?
Interesting watching all the liberals who accepted dubious anon allegations against politically harmless (if romantically inept) men like Aziz Ansari, who are now attacking @lyndseyfifield’s credibility about her experience with a man who has Nazi tattoos running for Senate.
Let me categorically Debunk this utter rot. @sainsburys.
I am a poultry Breeder. The hens that lay white eggs (Amberline/White Star) DO NOT have a lower carbon footprint.
Yes they eat a bit less and produce roughly the same amount of eggs as the Brown egg layers (Bovan/Lowman/ISA Brown) but they live shorter lives, are prone to dying suddenly when startled, a flighty and nervous and because they live shorter productive lives (12 -18mnths) vs brown 18/24mnths (both commercial farmed), you have to incubate more which is increased (Electricity/gas costs) and their eggs are not the same quality.
I breed and keep 20+ different breeds, including: ISA Brown hens and White Stars. All my hens are 100% free range, Not a single barn kept bird, I have ISA browns that are 5yrs old and still laying beautiful Brown eggs, I have not seen a White star live beyond 3yrs and certainly none have laid eggs past 18-24mnths.
White stars Lay themselves to death. They are slender birds and because they dont eat a lot, it drains their personal vitality to keep up laying the eggs you want to sell because of the nonsensical lie that they are "More Carbon Neutral"
You want to know about eggs, come talk to someone like me, Don't rely on some hairbrained imagination of a buyer who's trying to squeeze the profit margin for a few extra pennies at our expense and to the poor hens detriment.
With respect Jamie, this isn’t true.
In the 1980’s many towns had a single gay bar. These often gave sanctuary to transexuals and the odd transvestite (because we were being kind and understood they’d get battered elsewhere). None of these men claimed to *be* women, and if they’d claimed to actually be lesbians, they’d have been laughed out the door. At the same time, trans orgs (eg the Beaumont Society) banned gay men from membership. The conflict has always existed.
*Trans people* did nothing in the fight for gay rights. Really, nothing.
When OUR history is co-opted by those who write us out of it, we should call it what it is - a parasitic movement.
Ushering in “gender identity ideology” has irrevocably harmed innumerable children who would otherwise grow up to be gay.
LGB and T organisations came together because LGB had won the argument and the T wanted to hide behind that. And they bought the money in.
Good luck if you want to start trying to reason with trans ideologues. We’ve tried for years. They have no compromise position.
It was always a forced marriage that many didn’t want. And, frankly, it’s now gone beyond abusive. We need out.
the “is it safe to be a woman in public” thing is as much or more a class thing as it is a temperament thing. If your experience in life is that people are safe and orderly most of the time and the men and women in your life will protect you from harm, that is a different life…
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal Elevating the feelings of narcissistic abusers above both the healthy bodies & minds of kids & the privacy, dignity & safety of women is genuinely evil.
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal Forcing people to pretend men are women is something only an “asshole” lacking in “basic courtesy” would do.
The actual victims are GNC kids being groomed & transitioned, and women who no longer have single sex DV shelters, prisons, etc. (1/2)
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal No one’s authentic self involves lying about their sex, cosmetic surgery, or supraphysiological doses of hormones.
None of the “brain sex” claims survive controls for sexual orientation.
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal You also haven’t addressed the core problem: trans wants to force everyone to affirm falsehoods, this cannot be done without totalitarian measures.
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal Force teaming is an abuse tactic. Stop force teaming LGB & GNC people with trans. Trans harms both those groups.
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal Also, as you claim to be a libertarian: trans is an inherently totalitarian movement that relies on coercing all society into affirming falsehoods with devastating consequences for women & children.
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal No one is punishing people for existing, if you can’t make your argument without lying that says a lot about it.
As someone who actually bothered reading the articles cited by trans activists, it does not show what you’re claiming at all.
@BruceRayCarr1@verybadintel@jessesingal You just proved my point. It’s all about upholding the ideology, and any research that threatens it must be stopped.