@CkarasuStream The pod (Tymna/Thras, Malcolm/Bruce, Rog/Ishai/Gwenom) played it out and Gwenom won after her husband "punted the game and gave her the win" according to the Tymna/Thras player I asked
Second match: I get eliminated (after making myself the threat in this pod) and now they're trying to offer a draw with the last three people
The other table beside us has been debating a draw for the better part of ten minutes
@CkarasuStream@rwbn_ I'm trying to find out if the final pod even played it or for the Tropical Island or just split the value of it (since proxies are allowed, I imagine that there is less incentive for people to want to on the physical card; I wanted it for my casual Aragorn deck)
@spdcntmeltsteel See: if that was the standard, then I think the whole format wouldn't be the subject of ridicule on here
When I've played it against students or my regular playgroup, it's so fun.
@Chiko1521 When I left around 8, it had mostly gone away
From when I got there until 6, when the worst smelly person left it was RANK.
@caro_irl would say something like "if you can afford $100 proxy Kinnan deck, you can afford deodorant"
@Chosler My casual pod with friends had this problem at the beginning.
Myself and another friend really had to hammer home that removal/interaction is a key piece to building a good deck, but everyone wants to see their stuff pop off more. Most pods never grow past learning this fact.
@maxbutrad IT'S NOT LIKE THE OTHER CRYSTAL DECKS (it's 99% the same cards, but with full arts instead)
(No hate to Crystal players, but I did hear that one today)
@thepancakington I'm not a fan of it, for sure. I can see why people like it just for the sake of pushing what should be a casual deck and seeing how hard it can go like people modifying garbage cars just to catch people by surprise with goodies under the hood.
@ctb14s@rwbn_ I love the idea of Duel Commander, but it isn't as popular and I have the strongest feeling it is because of the distinct lack of politicking
@CptDonFluffles My favorite phrase I got to say a couple different times is "I have the win, if this resolves. Beat it."
I'm there to play Magic, win or lose.
@rwbn_ Absolutely tedious. And when I've brought this up to the cEDH players here, they've just said things to the effect of "politicking fixes your win percentage".
It is, for better or worse, the nature of the format.