🚨 NetChoice Sues New York: The Government Cannot Force Websites to Speak for the State
NEW YORK—NetChoice sued New York today to stop the state from forcing services to act as its mouthpieces. SB S4505 will force websites to put up state-scripted "warning" messages discouraging New Yorkers from using online services and promoting the government's controversial views on social media.
“The First Amendment forbids New York from forcing private speakers to serve as government mouthpieces, and that includes compelled state-scripted warnings on speech,” said @Paul_Taske, Director of the NetChoice Litigation Center. “New York has every right to share its views on social media, but it has no right to make private websites say it for them. As we told California last month, the First Amendment is not a suggestion. A federal court has already struck down Colorado’s nearly identical law, and New York’s unconstitutional mandate should meet the same fate.”
WHY NEW YORKERS SHOULD CARE:
1. Users will have to sit through state-mandated warnings every time they access social media. After the first warning upon initial access, they will have to sit through labels shown for up to 30 seconds, covering 75% of the screen that they cannot skip, every hour after three hours online, no matter how many times they've seen them.
2. An unconstitutional law protects no one, and in this case, it actively undermines the public's access to diverse perspectives and information.
3. New York is exploiting legitimate concerns about mental health to justify its attacks on speech services.
4. States cannot do by "warning label" what they are unable to do by outright ban. A federal court already blocked Colorado's nearly identical law on First Amendment grounds, and New York's should fall too.
5. California doesn't trust adults to make their own choices, or parents to make decisions for their own families. Unless a site has verified a user is over 17, everyone gets the warning.
NetChoice Opposes NYC Delivery Protection Act
NEW YORK, N.Y. — NetChoice announced today its opposition to the New York City Delivery Protection Act (Int. 0518-2026), legislation pending before the New York City Council that threatens independent delivery businesses, puts New Yorkers’ jobs at risk, and drives up delivery costs for everyday Americans throughout the city.
"New Yorkers’ budgets are already stretched thin, and the Delivery Protection Act would make life in the city even less affordable," said @abos255, Vice President of Government Affairs at NetChoice. "This bill would threaten small, local delivery businesses' ability to keep their doors open, putting hardworking New Yorkers’ jobs and economic opportunities at risk. The City Council should reject this bill and put affordability first."
The bill would require companies that operate last-mile delivery facilities to obtain a city license and directly hire their delivery workers. In practice, that would eliminate the role of the independently owned, locally operated delivery companies that employ thousands of New Yorkers and move packages to homes and businesses every day.
At a time when the cost of living is the top concern for New Yorkers, the Delivery Protection Act would add new costs to one of the most basic services residents depend on. Forcing small delivery companies out of the market means fewer providers, less competition, and higher operating costs — costs that will be passed on to consumers in the form of higher delivery prices and slower service.
NetChoice urges the New York City Council to reject Int. 0518 and to work with small business owners, delivery workers, and consumers on solutions that protect jobs and keep delivery affordable for every New Yorker.
Happy Global Entrepreneurship Week!
Every business starts with someone willing to take a risk on an idea. A new Oxford Economics study estimates that independent sellers in Amazon’s store supported $183.9 billion of U.S. GDP in 2025. Here’s to celebrating American ingenuity. https://t.co/4i1eRdOVRW
NetChoice Will Keep Fighting for Mississippians' Online Rights After Fifth Circuit Vacates Injunction
NEW ORLEANS, La.— A panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit today vacated the second preliminary injunction blocking Mississippi's HB 1126, the state's ID-for-Speech law, sending the case back to the district court on remand.
"We're disappointed in today's decision, but nothing in the ruling holds that HB 1126 is constitutional,” said @Paul_Taske, Director of the NetChoice Litigation Center. "Justice Kavanaugh has already said NetChoice is likely to win on the merits, and we are assessing all options to best preserve access to lawful speech in Mississippi. Today's ruling is about procedure and paperwork, not about whether the state can force its residents to hand over their IDs before they are allowed to access speech online.”
HB 1126 replaces parental judgment with what the state thinks is best. It puts lawful speech behind an ID check, requiring covered websites to verify the age of everyone who creates an account, adults included. Mississippians of every age would have to prove who they are before they can read, post, and connect online. To comply, websites must collect and store sensitive information like government IDs and other personal identifiers. Every new database of that information becomes a prime target for hackers and identity thieves.
Thank you, @SenRandPaul, for standing up for free speech, protecting the open internet, and helping stop KOSA.
Protecting kids online doesn’t have to come at the expense of the First Amendment rights of all Americans. We appreciate your leadership!
🚨⚖️ NetChoice Sues Indiana: Hoosiers Shouldn’t Have to Prove Who They Are to Speak Online
INDIANAPOLIS—NetChoice filed a lawsuit yesterday challenging the social media provisions of HEA 1408, an Indiana law that will require covered websites to determine the age and residency of every Hoosier who signs up for social media.
“The Constitution prevents the government from interfering with the free speech rights of families and teens, and those rights include the ability to create and receive speech on social media,” said @Paul_Taske, Director of the NetChoice Litigation Center. “But Indiana’s HEA 1408 conditions both teen and adult access to social media on complying with state-mandated digital ID requirements. These requirements are inconsistent with the constitutional guarantee of free speech. Federal courts have blocked similar laws nationwide, and Indiana’s law should fall too.”
WHY HOOSIERS SHOULD CARE:
1. Every Hoosier gets carded, not just kids. HEA 1408 requires covered websites to determine the age and Indiana residency of everyone who wants an account, then re-verify users’ ages as their time online grows, for up to 10 years.
2. Your personal data could become a target. Anyone flagged as possibly under 16, including adults, must verify their age with records like mortgage, education, or employment data within 30 days or lose their account, and the law requires no deletion of that data afterward.
3. The state overrides parents instead of empowering them. Even with a parent’s permission, Indiana locks teen accounts into state-chosen settings, switching off personalized feeds and features the government has subjectively labeled as “addictive.”
Protecting kids online is important, but Indiana cannot get there by carding users and overriding the wishes of parents. There are lawful ways to keep young people safe without sacrificing the rights and security of all Hoosiers.
The Fourth Circuit’s recent, fractured decision against @Kalshi adds to the growing circuit split on how to regulate prediction markets. SCOTUS will need to step in to protect these valuable financial tools that benefit small businesses and everyday Americans.
Learn more at ➡️ https://t.co/FPqXXin7dH
"The technology being debated in Washington is already being used in the real world—to help consumers make decisions, connect with local businesses, & give businesses new ways to reach customers. The question is not simply what AI can do today; it is about what becomes possible when more Americans have access to it." - @abos255 💡
Learn more below ⏬
NetChoice Urges Senate Commerce Committee to Reject the COLLUDE Act
WASHINGTON — NetChoice urges members of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation to oppose the COLLUDE Act (S. 69) at the committee's markup today. NetChoice supports the underlying goal of the COLLUDE Act: to prevent government officials from pressuring online service providers to censor lawful speech, which is why NetChoice enthusiastically supports the JAWBONE Act. However, the COLLUDE Act takes the wrong approach, targeting the providers rather than the officials responsible.
"NetChoice strongly supports holding government officials accountable when they use their positions to pressure private companies into censoring lawful speech. But the COLLUDE Act gets the solution backward by creating new legal exposure for the very providers facing that pressure," said @abos255, Vice President of Government Affairs at NetChoice. "Social media websites are already becoming more transparent about government pressure and giving users greater control over content moderation through tools like Community Notes. We should be encouraging more transparency and accountability, not creating new legal risks that could discourage companies from speaking out."
The COLLUDE Act raises serious First Amendment concerns by singling out social media providers based on arbitrary size and user thresholds. It imposes different legal consequences on certain providers while leaving other online services and individual users free to engage in similar content moderation decisions without facing the same liability.
Instead of holding the officials who pressure websites accountable, the COLLUDE Act penalizes the companies who were pressured. Activists of any political stripe could use these lawsuits enabled by the proposed legislation to pressure online service providers, the very outside pressure the bill claims to oppose.
We urge the Committee to reject the COLLUDE Act in its current form.
Check out when some retailers' November 2026 sales are taking place, so you can plan your list and shop around for the best price this holiday season. 🛍️
We’re hiring! NetChoice is looking for a Policy Manager who will be responsible for policy analysis, research, and communicating key principles to support NetChoice’s advocacy goals. Learn more here ⏩️ https://t.co/lx3Fs6DMSX
Over the past year, courts have handed down some of the largest decisions yet in a growing wave of lawsuits against social media. While most coverage treats these as cases about corporate accountability, their more consequential impact is on the free speech rights of Americans. https://t.co/xfpjYtCkHh
The AI data center buildout is reviving a trucking industry that struggled through nearly 4 years of weak freight markets. DAT estimates that about 20 GW of data center capacity built since 2023 has generated nearly 2 million truckloads. Moratoriums & patchwork state rules would hurt both tech & the industries that have come to rely on them. https://t.co/yT0NItJSaq