High Technology Attorney, Entrepreneur, and Computer Technologist; Lead counsel in large tech cases; Helped build Web 2 & 3 services that lots of people use.
I spoke yesterday to the Digital Entertainment Group or DEG about NFT legal strategy - here is the video below - I step through numerous weighty legal-tech issues for any NFT project beginning at about the seven minute mark. I hope you find it helpful.
https://t.co/UfH9wyB8H3
In my view, it is unwise calling it Mike when a popular open-source project has the same non-descriptive name. Using free AI legal as lead gen for lawyer upsells is inevitable - how the nuances like privilege, context, and jurisdiction are handled are important. Many contracts require knowing a lot about the client to avoid unintended consequences.
Can’t tell if this is good or bad - if the AI agents are only insured for “20% work” that doesn’t involve a lawyer license then the 5M policy is not “malpractice insurance” for agents rather it’s “anything but malpractice insurance” for agents? Kindly clarify as this is important to the AI legal community. Congrats on innovating.
@NeelGuha The elephant in the room for ai legal is the LAM - Lawyer Analysis Metric - or the minimum level of lawyer AI supervision that passes muster. It is the rate limiting step. AI can take a minute or two to draft a brief or contract but lawyer review can be hours.
Legal AI needs a Lawyer Analysis Metric (LAM): how much human review counts as sufficient supervision of AI for a given task. Review every citation? Wise, but it erases AI’s time savings. Review nothing? Sanctions. How about the LAM for a given contract review redlined by AI? We’re regulating this line without ever measuring it. It will vary by task. As AI improves, LAM should fall — if liability and ethics rules let it.
We are building https://t.co/r90IKy0Z9f and doing a lot of research using AI methods. We analyzed the top websites in the US and 46 of 98 currently have terms where you let them use your posts, chat, or data to train or improve its AI.
We are building https://t.co/r90IKy0Z9f and doing a lot of research using AI methods. We analyzed the top websites in the US and 81 of 96 currently prohibit agents and bots to browse or shop the sites.
@scottastevenson iPad Pro with keyboard and cell/wifi. It’s always on in airport and hotel with no wifi needed and it’s thin for tray table with huge battery life.
We are developing the next phase of the evolution of AI legal. Real Time Law. It is very powerful, requires a ton of compute and storage, and it will lead to the need for more lawyers. We are protecting agentic commerce and a lot more. Can’t fully discuss it yet so for now we made an ambiguous landing page with action figures. We are looking for strategic partners. https://t.co/oaFPRLDlvU
Yes we are working on this today. Agent to agent agreements are nuanced especially when deterministic code and rules are designed by licensed lawyers for the parties that use the agents and matters get elevated to lawyer in the loop when things deviate. No more redlines. We are using a lot of what we learned in the smart contract tech space.
Many AI apps combine probabilistic and deterministic processes. For litigation brief analysis, a simple example, the text of a brief is parsed deterministically to discern regex patterns for lookup of citations. The citations are fetched and cases looked up. The case text is analyzed probabilistically.
AI legal is broken right now. One person’s access to justice is another person’s access to bring dubious claims in volume and another person’s unauthorized practice of law. New rules on not (over) delegating lawyering to AI but one is left to guess where that line is drawn. Duty of AI supervision line is unclear and only reviewing output is illogical if you can’t tell what evidence in millions of records or legal arguments the AI quietly omitted. Insurers are important here. Is this ultimately leading to the need for AI legal safe harbors?
Yep, it would be bizarre if consumers couldn’t use AI legal apps to protect themselves in agentic transactions - AI scanning of terms of sale or privacy policy for legal red flags in real time are important for consumer protection. It is the rare consumer who could justify the time and expense of having a lawyer do it. Calling it the UPL could be net detrimental.
Which begs the questions is the current AI legal platform functionality enough to carry out this compliance layer, what productivity and cost benefit is AI if a lawyer still has read and analyze absolutely everything, and will we ever allow for detachment so AI can do some legal work cause some mistakes but permit it because the good outweighs the bad?