Aaron Ryan

Huge film fan. Sometimes I post a review for a movie in a desperate attempt to maybe have someone follow me or something.

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 Why?

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@NonyaBidne94503 @CWilson2197 At best? Thats the explanation l. Its possible to crash while using hyperdrive. Holdo did that

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@NonyaBidne94503 @CWilson2197 I guess to me, the dialogue in ANH is enough precedent. Sure maybe a deflector shield could protect them from that, maybe not. Delving deep into that argument doesnt hold water to me in a space fantasy movie. Its a fun conversation maybe but not real criticism imo

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@JSPtheSecond @fentrocity @TheElectionof80 @SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 I feel the opposite. I feel others are adding more lore that wasnt explained in the films. To me its pretty simple 1. Han says crashing into stuff at hyperspeed would be bad and damaging.
2. Holdo crashes into stuff at hyperspeed and causes damage.

Seems like logical to me

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 Ok so what does the dialogue mean if not what im saying?

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@NonyaBidne94503 @CWilson2197 I do think you're getting lost in the science details for a space fantasy movie. Im talking purely in the films world where I think it makes enough sense to work

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@NonyaBidne94503 @CWilson2197 If you ram a car into a tank at lightspeed? You will

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 Why not? The dialogue breaks the world according to you

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 No the scene from ANH

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@JSPtheSecond @fentrocity @TheElectionof80 @SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 When Han says that it clarifies that abetting outside of hyperspace can affect anything in hyperspace. And it didnt obliterate an entire fleet, the FO was still able to come down to craft. It destroyed one ship (not fully) and a few ships behind because it was behind it.

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 So what do you think about that scene? Do you think its a terrible scene that contradicts the rest of the franchise

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@fentrocity @TheElectionof80 @SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 So you thought if a large ship crashed into another large ship, only the one at hyperspace would be damaged? The target would what? Absorb it?

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 Why isn't the exposition enough for you?

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@TheElectionof80 @SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 "If I ram something in hyperspace my ship will explode and cause damage including my ship and the one i hit"

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 ANH's exposition makes it possible

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 They were desperate. It was the only way to save the resistance. And again, it doesn't matter that it wasn't done. The script said it was possible. If you think thats such a big flaw, thats a flaw with the original films because they are the ones that set it up

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 Maybe they didnt have the ships to spare. Honestly, I don't really care. I don't need to see it happen to believe its possible. They used exposition to explain it 40 years before doing it

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 George Lucas made it possible and made all 6 movies, ask him

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 And ANH explains why its possible

[Aaron Ryan @AaronRyan02]

@SonicFront70231 @CWilson2197 Ok so if it breaks the rules, its ANH that does it. Not TLJ. Things like that are common in Fantasy, you see it in LOTR, HP, even other SW. Classic "why didnt they" is impossible to avoid.