@Sebastian_Hols@E_line@IncidentalEcon The thing is, it's not close in terms of cost effectiveness. We posted an update and clarify that you need a consumer response close to the order of magnitude of the shutdown to change the conclusion
@E_line@afrakt Reason govt imposed shutdown is because the govt believes consumers will not change behavior sufficiently without strict regulations. If you believe our numbers are misleading you also believe the shutdown was unnecessary because consumers would have changed behavior anyway
@afrakt Bigger question is how other countries would have reacted if the US had not shutdown. If other countries, particularly Canada, had followed the US lead and stayed open the economic impact would have been less. The international trade impact would swamp consumer effect. @E_line
@hilzoy@afrakt We think how consumers would react is unknown. We acknowledge the empty Georgia malls, but note the packed beaches in Florida and California and how spring breakers (didn't) react. Also we cite busy business in Stockholm. It will depend on how consumer perceive the risk.@E_line
It remains a good idea that may take some time to figure out. "Elective" treatments have been delayed, but many "elective" treatments aren't indefinitely elective. They can be delayed but maybe not for months. Systems are already planning on how to catch back up
Measuring rurality got messier. Problems with standard measures of rurality. @UVMLarnerMed faculty @tbplante and @AndrewWilcock8 respond in the JRH. https://t.co/30XZQIGf3s
@EconTalker@IncidentalEcon@E_line The data point that seems most likely to change is the mean age of death. The concordance of rates from China, Italy & US data made us confident in that number, but the media is indicating it may run younger in the United States. But that's based more on headlines than charts.
@EconTalker@IncidentalEcon@E_line Agreed. Parts of the stimulus are true economic costs & parts are transfers; it's a reasonable starting point and also a very conservative estimate. If you take something like 50% of one month's economic production, that gives a number of about $875B -- same range. It's low.
@EconTalker@E_line@IncidentalEcon This is CEA not CBA. As we say, this is how we make decisions like this all the time. If you don't like this here -- which is completely fair -- consistency argues that it doesn't apply elsewhere either. Politicians use the Rule of Rescue -- which voters prefer too!