A Modest Proposal for Safe Sexual Relations
It is a melancholy object to those who walk through our great nations, to see the streets crowded with adults engaged in relationships of every kind, formed without paperwork, supervision or a single countersignature. These people are neither safe nor, more importantly, provably safe. I have therefore devoted several minutes to the question and arrived at a solution so reasonable that I am astonished no committee has yet commissioned it.
First, the age of consent shall be raised to twenty-five. The objection that this criminalises most of the young is a feature, not a flaw: a population in which nobody may do anything cannot do anything wrong. Should twenty-five prove too lenient, we may revise it upwards at leisure, there being no evidence that the human brain, once reaching its full development at around forty, does not then begin to decline.
Second, Christian morality shall be reinstated. Those who spent sixty years dismantling it will welcome its return, once it has been rebranded as “a values-based framework for relational wellbeing.” Nobody need be troubled by the fact that its former defenders object to the new management. The Church of Rome will be consulted by letter.
Third, fame shall be capped at six months. Power imbalances arise chiefly from admiration, and admiration, like milk, should carry a date stamp. Citizens will receive a plain card stating the day on which they cease to be interesting. This will also solve the problem of the reality-television judges, along with several other problems that nobody was asking us to solve.
Fourth, every intimate encounter shall be attended by an Independent Witness, a trained health and safety professional equipped with a clipboard, a lanyard, and a laminated form with tick boxes for enthusiasm. Some will say that this removes the romance. These people are failing to appreciate that nothing is more romantic than a signed statement. And since the Witness is himself a person with feelings, a power over others, and presumably some sense of when to leave, he must be witnessed in turn. I propose a pyramid. At its base, the people. At its summit, an exhausted civil servant.
Fifth, and most crucial, full-spectrum surveillance. If we are to have a complete account of the facts, we must have all the facts, in high resolution, stored indefinitely. I am assured by the relevant department that the archive will be perfectly secure, having been designed by the same people who maintain every other database, we have not build data centres for nought. In the event of a dispute, the footage will be produced, and both parties, now fully informed, will be mortified. Anything that remains unresolved can be referred to the previous paragraph.
I foresee only a few objections. The population will fall, but a nation that cannot be accused of anything has an enviably low crime rate. Some will complain of lost privacy, but privacy has always been the chief hiding place of the dishonest, and the dishonest are, by definition, everyone who has ever been alone with another person. A few cynics will ask who watches the Witnesses, the watchers of the watchers, and the keepers of the archive. To them I say: surely we can trust someone.
I have no personal interest in this scheme. I am old enough to be exempt, unobserved enough to be unmonitored, and sensible enough, I hope, to know that every simple solution to a difficult problem is a more complicated problem wearing a hat.
Be honest with your readers, you are calling for retribution, and there is no need to dress it up. You concede that Bouchaker will never be free again, so the argument that execution is “self-defence” collapses by your own admission, and what remains is the claim that he deserves to die. That is a defensible position in the philosophy of punishment, but it is not the same as setting “the value of human life,” and it is not what you have presented.
Telling us that hanging him would “increase” the worth of a child’s life, or that it would not be vengeance although “vengeance would be justified,” is a way of making the case for killing sound nobler than the plain statement that he simply earned it. Retribution at least has the virtue of honesty, so make that case openly and let readers weigh it as it is. But do not invoke Catholic readers while doing so, because the Church’s own Catechism teaches that the death penalty is inadmissible in every case, however grave the crime, precisely because it attacks the dignity of the person.
That is not mercy overriding justice, as you put it. It is the Church’s judgment about what justice permits a state to do.
A Modest Proposal for Safe Sexual Relations
It is a melancholy object to those who walk through our great nations, to see the streets crowded with adults engaged in relationships of every kind, formed without paperwork, supervision or a single countersignature. These people are neither safe nor, more importantly, provably safe. I have therefore devoted several minutes to the question and arrived at a solution so reasonable that I am astonished no committee has yet commissioned it.
First, the age of consent shall be raised to twenty-five. The objection that this criminalises most of the young is a feature, not a flaw: a population in which nobody may do anything cannot do anything wrong. Should twenty-five prove too lenient, we may revise it upwards at leisure, there being no evidence that the human brain, once reaching its full development at around forty, does not then begin to decline.
Second, Christian morality shall be reinstated. Those who spent sixty years dismantling it will welcome its return, once it has been rebranded as “a values-based framework for relational wellbeing.” Nobody need be troubled by the fact that its former defenders object to the new management. The Church of Rome will be consulted by letter.
Third, fame shall be capped at six months. Power imbalances arise chiefly from admiration, and admiration, like milk, should carry a date stamp. Citizens will receive a plain card stating the day on which they cease to be interesting. This will also solve the problem of the reality-television judges, along with several other problems that nobody was asking us to solve.
Fourth, every intimate encounter shall be attended by an Independent Witness, a trained health and safety professional equipped with a clipboard, a lanyard, and a laminated form with tick boxes for enthusiasm. Some will say that this removes the romance. These people are failing to appreciate that nothing is more romantic than a signed statement. And since the Witness is himself a person with feelings, a power over others, and presumably some sense of when to leave, he must be witnessed in turn. I propose a pyramid. At its base, the people. At its summit, an exhausted civil servant.
Fifth, and most crucial, full-spectrum surveillance. If we are to have a complete account of the facts, we must have all the facts, in high resolution, stored indefinitely. I am assured by the relevant department that the archive will be perfectly secure, having been designed by the same people who maintain every other database, we have not build data centres for nought. In the event of a dispute, the footage will be produced, and both parties, now fully informed, will be mortified. Anything that remains unresolved can be referred to the previous paragraph.
I foresee only a few objections. The population will fall, but a nation that cannot be accused of anything has an enviably low crime rate. Some will complain of lost privacy, but privacy has always been the chief hiding place of the dishonest, and the dishonest are, by definition, everyone who has ever been alone with another person. A few cynics will ask who watches the Witnesses, the watchers of the watchers, and the keepers of the archive. To them I say: surely we can trust someone.
I have no personal interest in this scheme. I am old enough to be exempt, unobserved enough to be unmonitored, and sensible enough, I hope, to know that every simple solution to a difficult problem is a more complicated problem wearing a hat.
@caulmick The Irish Constitution (Article 40.6.1°) and Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights both protect the right to protest but allow it to be limited for public order and safety, so the State can probably justify keeping protesters out of the summit venue itself.
The email in full
"Hello. I am Mikhail Andropov, one of the leaders of the group responsible for the bomb threats against airplanes in Europe over the past week.
"European authorities have once again shown that they are incompetent fools who are incapable of doing anything to stop us.
"We experimented with multithreading, and we succeeded in causing widespread panic, as well as forcing European authorities to spend a fortune on all these procedures.
"But this is only the beginning. What happened this week is just a small part of what awaits Europe in the near future.
"Right now, we're preparing a new wave of attacks. Right now, we're recruiting residents of your countries who are actively cooperating with us. We've also gained access to compromised devices, servers, and accounts belonging to residents of Europe, as well as those outside its borders-which will allow us to use this against you.
"Very soon, we will be blowing up your airplanes, cruise ships, subway stations, and trains. In the meantime, I recommend taking a vacation by plane while you still have the chance.
"We want the whole world to know about us, which is why one of our operatives has planted an explosive device in your building. It will detonate in 45 minutes. The clock is ticking."
https://t.co/fTwYgqc4QP
@Maxmt1095906@TomClonan If the President refers it to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court upholds the bill, the President must sign it into law, and under Article 34.3.3 it can never be challenged in the courts again on constitutional grounds for as long as it stays in force.
@danielthemate So... you think that is an effective strategy from the Russians to deter Europe and Ireland from bolstering up defence and support for Ukraine?
Calling these incidents an act of terrorism as an established fact is premature.
Under Section 4 of Ireland's Criminal Justice (Terrorist Offences) Act 2005, terrorist activity requires a qualifying criminal offence or threat, accompanied by a specific intention: seriously intimidating a population, unduly compelling a government or international organisation, or seriously destabilising or destroying fundamental structures of a state or international organisation.
The fact that bomb threats have caused "widespread" disruption, fear and evacuations does not, by itself, establish that legal threshold.
As of today, the authorities have NOT established who is responsible, whether the incidents are connected, or what the perpetrators' actual intentions are, if you have information to the contrary please inform us here, or the authorities.
The Government has described the incidents as serious threats and "suggested" a coordinated campaign of disruption. That is not the same as a formal determination that they constitute terrorism.
They may ultimately prove to be terrorist acts, but until the necessary evidence of the offence and intention is established, describing them as definitively terrorism is an assertion rather than an established fact.
Can you be so kind as to inform us who IS responsible for these acts, and what evidence you have to support your claim?
Our EU leader should have an Emergency summit to discuss, AI's effects on the labour market, democratic processes, protection of minors, and cybersecurity; and how AI should be governed globally... Oh wait... they planned that meeting in advance for the 12th and 13th, good foresight!