@Ben46296294@thenewsdrill They're Australians of Indian origin. Ethnicity and nationality aren't the same thing. My point was about people of Indian descent succeeding in Australia, not denying their Australian nationality
@ArthurFleckDNW@ChatoPage@thenewsdrill@grok ISRO, Chandrayaan-3, the Mars Orbiter Mission, the world's largest digital payments system (UPI), a pharmaceutical industry supplying medicines globally, and one of the largest vaccine manufacturers. "Hasn't done shit" isn't a serious argument.
@RochM3i@thenewsdrill I mentioned economic success because it directly contradicts the stereotype that Indians don't contribute. If your response is a racial insult instead of addressing the point, you've proved mine
@ArthurFleckDNW@ChatoPage@thenewsdrill@grok So your evidence is "trust me"? Many Indian immigrants earn accredited degrees, work in regulated professions, and pay taxes. Generalizations aren't facts
@ArthurFleckDNW@ChatoPage@thenewsdrill@grok That's a different argument. I never claimed India is "better" than the West. I said one 1960s photo doesn't prove Indians haven't contributed to science or innovation. Stick to the point.
@ArthurFleckDNW@ChatoPage@thenewsdrill@grok By that logic, one photo without you means you've never existed. A snapshot isn't historical proof. Judge countries by decades of achievements, not one frame.
@ChatoPage@ArthurFleckDNW@thenewsdrill@grok "Most Indians" according to what source? Indian immigrants have some of the highest education and income levels in many Western countries. Facts beat stereotypes.
@ArthurFleckDNW@ChatoPage@thenewsdrill@grok Your 1960s photo doesn't prove your point. Today India has ISRO, UPI, a world-leading pharmaceutical industry, and exports skilled engineers and doctors globally. Brain drain exists, but talent migrating doesn't erase innovation at home.
@ArthurFleckDNW@NavCom24@madmkts@DudeMrwise48881@jaswinderS57490 Japan had a decades-long head start on industrialization and today has about 124 million people. India has over 1.4 billion people, enormous linguistic and regional diversity, and emerged from colonial rule in 1947. Comparing them as if they're the same is simplistic.
@ArthurFleckDNW@ChatoPage@thenewsdrill@grok Funny. You complain about immigrants while enjoying the benefits they bring. If your argument is 'stay in your country,' then don't rely on the doctors, engineers, researchers, and workers from those same countries. Respect is earned by individuals, not denied by nationality.
@ArthurFleckDNW@NavCom24@madmkts@DudeMrwise48881@jaswinderS57490 Calling 1.4+ billion people unintelligent ignores reality. Indians are among the world's largest groups of engineers, doctors, scientists, CEOs, and startup founders. Stereotypes aren't facts.
@ChatoPage@ArthurFleckDNW@thenewsdrill@grok Criticize criminals all you want. Just don't pretend every Indian immigrant fits that description. That's the difference between criticism and xenophobia.