Hi there! Like many of you out there, I have a huge backlog of video games. It often feels like I collect games more than I play them! Well, it's about time I did something about it.
I made a list of 100 games in my backlog that I am committed to complete. Starting now, I am...
@aitaikimochi I just did my playthrough in this order:
Forest Temple
Water Temple
Spirit Temple
Fire Temple
Shadow Temple
Water Temple does not need hammer. Spirit Temple does not need hammer but does need Longshot. No temples need hover boots outside of the Shadow Temple.
On this day in 1955 at 10:04 PM, lightning struck the Hill Valley clocktower!⚡That one night is so climactic, it appears in all three #BacktotheFuture films, gets foreshadowed across the trilogy, and still inspires pop culture homages today. #BTTF#DidYouKnowThat
https://t.co/XlNs85wCu4
Ocarina of Time should NOT be nominated for game of the year.
Don't get me wrong, the remake is fucking spectacular (I've played for 26 hours since Thursday). It's visually stunning, the quality-of-life improvements remove some of the shite bits, and the core design holds up nearly 30 years later. It’s remarkable how seminal Ocarina of Time was, and you can still see its DNA all over modern releases. But you don’t need another navel-gazing millennial spouting off about that (I've said enough already).
But Game of the Year should reward creation, not curation. To me, the question here isn't “is this great?” – because Ocarina of Time is – more than great, even. Here, Nintendo has given a proven masterpiece (one largely designed in the years leading up to 1998) a lush new coat of paint. The things most people are applauding here, myself included, are the design, the structure, the pacing, and the legacy of a 28-year-old achievement. The visuals are just the new cherry on a perfected cake recipe. One way I think about remakes is how much new creative authorship is involved. My head cannon here has three tiers:
1. Ports and remasters (e.g. Black Ops on PS5 and Rare Replay): There’s basically nothing new design-wise, and nobody’s arguing these for GOTY (sanely, anyway).
2. Mainly graphical updates (e.g. Demon's Souls and Ocarina of Time): These remakes have gorgeous new art and quality-of-life improvements, but the bones – the actual game design – are mostly the same.
3. Ground-up reimaginings (e.g. FF7 Rebirth and RE2) These ones completely rebuild the game’s design, visuals, and layout, to the point that they’re closer to reinterpretations than remakes. They’re basically new games.
While the lines between these tiers can blur, I reckon the ground-up reimaginings have the best argument for being a GOTY contender. @thegameawards has already landed on that same conclusion, as RE2, RE4, and FF7 Remake and Rebirth have been nominated for the main award in the past.
The obvious pushback is that remakes like OoT take enormous skill and effort, and they introduce a classic to a new generation. This is all true, and I seriously can’t wait to share Ocarina of Time with my young nephews when I head back to Wales this Christmas. But that doesn’t mean they should win the main GOTY category. Right now, a gorgeous remake either takes up a spot in the main category or gets nothing. A dedicated award would honour the craft of making a banger remake without taking a spot away from an original title.
Going beyond my awards-season pedantry here, I spend a lot of time in the newsletter yapping about how the industry leans harder on proven IP, catalogue, and the safe nostalgia play every year. New stuff is riskier and more expensive. And Game of the Year is one of the few big-stage places where original, swing-for-the-fences work can get rewarded in front of the masses. I don’t think it’s fair for remakes, however stunning and nostalgia-inducing, to hoover up those nominations.
But yes. Ocarina of Time was a BANGER in 1998, remains a BANGER in 2026, looks phenomenal on Switch 2, and is helping shape the next generation of Nintendo designers as they move on to original projects (while also introducing newer players to the wonders of OoT).
Celebrate all of that. But it’s worth celebrating it in its own category, alongside the likes of Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced, Halo: Campaign Evolved, and Star Fox, I reckon.
@superhys So we'll written! This exactly echoes how I feel. I would love to see a "best remake/remaster category", but The Game Awards should celebrate the best NEW game. It won't stop Ocarina of Time from being my favorite game of 2026.
@Nintendeal Zero chance of a Majora's Mask remake next year, but I wouldn't rule out paid DLC for OoT Master Quest.
The amiibo are being released to coincide with the movie. Same as the Mario Galaxy amiibo. I wouldn't be surprised if they even released in the same day as the movie.
@MetroidMike64 It seems silly, but I was actually blown away when I went in a house and there was no loading animation or screen transition. It just happened. Little things like that are going to make an impact on me throughout the whole playthrough.
@MetroidMike64 I guess if you turn the volume all the way down, close your eyes, and mash A every time you get to a vision crystal, you could avoid being spoiled, but the game is basically out to spoil you on all the mainline FF games.