@mirthassembly I was never particularly concerned with code generation broadly, but because it is not "deterministic" there is increased room for fault.
Also to be clear, I understand how and why it is useful. My judgements of training data use and cultural impact are separate from that.
@CommanderRedEXE For the record, I did look it up.
There are no legal codes.
At best there are SOME legal cases that have set the precedent that for fair use "it depends" and training data being theft is still unresolved.
Nothing about generative AI broadly has been codified.
@CommanderRedEXE@jfwong Sorry, I know it's Twitter but you do know speaking like this doesn't incentivize me to respect your perspective and makes me less inclined to think AI is valid, right?
Sorry Jimmy, I'll leave this thread lol.
@mirthassembly But is the pattern not the part people want to automate? The "boilerplate" as it were. Is it not designed to auto complete based on existing coding standards and fill in the blanks?
What is the pattern "you" the user are establishing at that point?
@CommanderRedEXE@jfwong We also do not have a hard call on fair use, because the nature of genAI use and how/why it was trained varies. I read the report.
To be clear, I think genAI code assistance is fair use but code generation is not.
I'm just morally opposed to it b/c of other factors.
@CommanderRedEXE@jfwong Why would I ask the most biased AI a question about the validity of AI use?
Microsoft executives called it theft. The DoD called it theft. The LAION dataset was made with active knowledge it was a legal gray area.
The output CAN be novel, the input was not.
@kdreagle@jfwong Is it a targeted model and dataset or is it tooling designed to bias the output of a much larger much less ethical model?
Also, I think the research involved, methods of implementation, and acknowledgement of sources (like libraries) made stack overflow less theft than is said.
@CommanderRedEXE@Cobalt_WinVis@PokerfaceCactus@ProxAlertGame Is the output better or just faster? Do the people who review it actually review it or have ai review it for them? How much care was put into making it expandable for future projects?
Something being done that quickly with very little oversight leaves a lot of room for error.
@CommanderRedEXE@Cobalt_WinVis@PokerfaceCactus@ProxAlertGame Is it traded on the best coders in their respective fields... Or is it trained on all code available online at all levels of quality and then selectively weighted toward both the most likely output and the training done by a potentially biased corporation?
@jfwong I'd like to agree with you here, but generative AI for code development is still theft and still stripping away the creative/problem-solving process.
Smart auto complete and code formatting was a thing well before Claude, AI in coding does not need to be generative model based.
So @duolingo are you going to bring back community discussion, remove ai translations and text to speech, and reduce the length of animations used to artificially inflate app usage duration at the cost of learning time?
Or are you just gonna whine when I don't need you?
@LoinkLoink@Oxytoxy365 So you agree that they shut down b/c the games were bad (or mid relative to their budget).
Again, I've not heard of a single studio that closed b/c of "wokeness", only poor sales from middling reviews. I'm bi and didn't get concord either, it wasn't the queerness that was bad.
@LoinkLoink@Oxytoxy365 The reality is correlation ≠ causation. There are a ton of games you play that are written and arted by queer folk and minorities, but you don't necessarily associate the story/visuals with the creators unless it's not to "your taste".
@LoinkLoink@Oxytoxy365 ok, so what about baldurs gate, cyberpunk, apex legends, overwatch...
Like the other fella said, Concord didn't die because it was woke.
It died because it was an over funded scope creep multimedia project trying to penetrate a saturated market (hero fps)
@LoinkLoink@Oxytoxy365 What activists?
The one group that got lolcow'd but in actuality mostly provides contracted labor and legal/culture consulting? A thing completely normal in gamedev?
You don't have to like those games, doesn't make stuff like that bad for the industry.
@LoinkLoink@Oxytoxy365 There are a ton of reasons game studios perform poorly.
Mismanagement, design by committee (aka shareholders/executives trying to make creative decisions), scope creep, market saturation, not being profitable "enough", etc.
Inclusivity has never been a reason, afaik.
@RageInTheMist@zaiphirion That's... Not how that works.
Making jokes about "stealing people's code" from a space literally meant for exchanging solutions and teaching people how to improve isn't the pro-AI dunk you seem to think it is.