Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Severe outage on @MCA21HQ portal—unable to load the website on any browser! Taxpayers & professionals are stuck with looming due dates while public funds go into a glitchy system. Provide a stable portal or extend filing deadlines immediately! @PMOIndia @nsitharaman

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Crores of taxpayers’ money spent,yet the@MCA21HQ portal won’t even open on Chrome, Edge, or Firefox! Unacceptable tech failure right amidst peak filing season. We demand an immediate extension of due dates & a functional portal!@FinMinIndia @PIB_MCA @nsitharaman @narendramodi

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Disastrous experience with the MCA portal! Despite heavy public funding, @MCA21HQ is completely down & unreachable across all browsers. How are professionals supposed to meet compliance deadlines? Fix the glitches & extend the due date immediately! @FinMinIndia @PMOIndia

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

For over 13 years, the taxpayer has been pursuing the matter through representations and follow-ups. Why should taxpayers continue to spend time and resources correcting a mismatch that appears to have arisen during processing?

@IncomeTaxIndia @FinMinIndia @CBDT

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

A taxpayer's ITR for AY 2012-13 was processed without granting TDS credit, despite the TDS being reflected in Form 26AS. More than 13 years later, the issue remains unresolved. Why should taxpayers have to wait this long for a genuine credit?

@IncomeTaxIndia @FinMinIndia @CBDT

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

@IncomeTaxIndia @nsitharaman @FinMinIndia Thank you so much. The issue is resolved.

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Real case. A client paid a tax demand back in 2008. It was raised again in AY 2024-25. We communicated with the ITO, submitted proof, got it resolved. And now? Same demand is BACK in AY 2025-26. Refund on hold. Again. 🧵
@IncomeTaxIndia @nsitharaman @FinMinIndia

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

@IncomeTaxIndia @nsitharaman @FinMinIndia Thank you. We hope the issue is resolved.

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

@IncomeTaxIndia @nsitharaman @FinMinIndia The Ticket number FO_202605123259598 that we had raised was closed without providing any proper solution, instead asking us to redo the work.

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

If stakeholders cannot rely on guidance from the official MCA helpdesk, then who takes responsibility for incorrect guidance? Why should we suffer and redo the entire process despite acting in good faith? We request accountability and solution. @MCA21India @FinMinIndia @PMOIndia

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

When we contacted the helpdesk again to clarify the issue, they refused to acknowledge that incorrect guidance had been provided. Instead of resolving the issue, we are now being asked to redo the entire process. @MCA21India @FinMinIndia

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

We relied on guidance provided by the MCA helpdesk while completing an official compliance process. Based on their instructions, we proceeded accordingly. Later, we were informed that the guidance given to us was incorrect. @MCA21India @GoI_MeitY

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Even after submitting clarifications, the GST application was rejected. This kind of inconsistent documentation requirement across departments is harassment and directly obstructs Ease of Doing Business in India. Why can’t MCA, GST & state authorities streamline verification?

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

The officer further demanded Maharashtra PT details, even though these were already applied through AGILE-PRO and were still pending approval with the authorities. Additional proofs were also asked which MCA never required. Why businesses are forced into repetitive compliance?

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

We incorporated a company through MCA on 27 Mar 2026 and applied for GST through AGILE-PRO with all required details/documents. Yet on 27 Apr 2026, the GST officer sought clarifications for documents already furnished through MCA. Why duplication? @MCA21India @mahagst

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Genuine question 👇

Is MCA turning into a compliance watchdog
or a cash extraction mechanism for minor lapses?
Where do we draw the line between discipline and over-penalisation?@MCA21India

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Even more interesting —
The default was across multiple years, but there was no allegation of fraud, diversion, or public harm.
Just a missing DIN under signatures.

Should every technical lapse invite such harsh penalties?@MCA21India @nsitharaman @narendramodi

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Recent MCA action: A company was penalised simply for not mentioning DIN in financial statements.
Penalty? ₹3 lakh on the company + ₹1 lakh per director in default.
Is this compliance… or overreach? 🤔
#MCA #CorporateLaw #India

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

Even after providing all the details, there is still no resolution. Requesting you to please look into this matter urgently and relieve the assessee.

[Income Tax India @IncomeTaxIndia]

@BnS_CA5 @nsitharaman @FinMinIndia Dear @BnS_CA5,

Please let us know the subject line (masking personal details, if any) & the timestamp of your email.

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

This is happening in the Maharashtra jurisdiction. As a newly incorporated company, such avoidable queries cause unnecessary delays in obtaining GSTIN & starting business operations. Kindly look into this. @MahaGST_official @maha_gst @CMOMaharashtra

[Borkar and Shenoy Chartered Accountants @BnS_CA5]

We incorporated a Private Limited Company & applied for GST Registration via the AGILE Pro form during incorporation itself. All documents submitted at the time of filing. GST Dept has now raised queries asking for details ALREADY provided. @Atulawatesgst @maharevenue