Not only negligence bc that would imply no intent. After everything we've seen, it is clear that at least among some Fed officials there has been some intent.
Overall, it's probably a mix between:
1) negligence (we can put anything here, from lack of extensive analyses, knowledge, judgements to inability to come with unbiased conclusions from the data in front of them),
2) politics (a lot of Fed members are Democrats or accepting Democratic policies, like DEI, especially among regional Fed presidents),
3) fixed ideas (some of them really think that the neutral is higher than it is right now and that the FFR should be higher than the neutral - this is because of their predetermined biases, which may have roots in personal history - e.g., if a person grew up in the 1970s and was hit especially hard with inflation issues back then, they can develop a pattern of seeing inflation problems everywhere, no matter if they exist or not, or in their professional background - if someone was professionally trained in the 1990s they would think that the "normal" neutral rates are 5%, not 2%),
4) not being able to see the forest for the trees (they read the daily news and are having a hard time separating signal from noise),
5) groupthink (false shield by thinking it's better to be wrong in a group than stand out, right or wrong), and
6) personal feelings (they are afraid of making a mistake and when you constantly fear something you will at some point end up doing exactly that - the deer-in-the-headlights syndrome).
@MBjegovic@DeItaone Love it! I appreciate your candor. Too bad FOMC in Dec is B4 the CPI release… maybe they get a preview? NY Harbor Diesel looking sickly…
I know folks on here want me to predict the exact bottom or close to it with timing....I just cant do that folks...I know I called the top and bottom of the covid crash before it happened but that was more luck than anything....If we are truly following the 1972 fractal we should be within 2-3 percent and within 2-3 days of the bottom....We may bottom now or it might be 100 points lower and in 3 days....I just dont know...NOBODY knows even though some on Twitter proclaim they can...
Let me summarize a few thoughts about the #Fed.
When he was appointed in May, Warsh was supposed to bring prosperity by supporting "strong" growth and AI, while reducing the Fed's imprint on the economy.
His record so far:
- Q3 nominal GDP growth was the 2nd weakest Q3 in 8 years.
- The Fed managed to kill the only growth engine left in the economy - AI by falsely accusing it of being "inflationary".
- 18 of his colleagues regularly give forward guidance, while he is refusing to do that.
Almost immediately after Warsh joined the Fed, it turned inexplicably hawkish. Coincidence?
They managed to hike rates in Sep when core #CPI was just 2.4% (Aug), which historically corresponds to core PCE of 2.0%. Ofc the actual core PCE was 3.0% at the time, which should have been completely disregarded. But it wasn't. The Fed doesn't understand that the 1.0-pp gap between core CPI and core PCE is statistical, not actual inflation. Goes without saying, but they can't affect statistical models, no matter what they do with rates.
They also said GDP growth was "strong." Sure, if you count a sugar rush in H1 as "strong". But what happens after a sugar rush?
Now they are preparing to hike again in Dec. Like one hike for non-economic reasons (politics, "independence", "credibility", complete mischaracterization of inflation, you name it) wasn't enough?
I am going to end with an open question:
Has the Fed created a #recession by becoming hawkish for non-economic reasons during the summer?
Last week we got a retest of the wedge and 200 day test which I marked with the black arrow...then we got a 50-61.8 retrace....My wag is the bottom comes at the Nov vix opex or turn of month December...Then we get a monster Santa rally ....I am not shorting or long....just doing a little scalping each day until we get out of this multi month gorp....
I keep hearing things like "nominal growth is off the charts, so the #Fed needs to hike."
Maybe it's time to update the picture bc nominal growth in Q3 was just +5.6%, the 2nd weakest Q3 in 8 yrs.
It should be down well below the ffr given how wrong both the mkt and the Fed were on growth.
Btw I saw this one coming. Unbelievable some ppl still think the Fed "had" to hike rates in Sep when all the data completely disproved their nonsensical claims from the get-go.
The data after the Sep meeting only supported it further, revealing what a colossal mistake they made by hiking rates. Talking about "credibility"...
https://t.co/5nLHDaWOCf
I never said printing money was growth. The Fed made many mistakes that got us here.
First, they cut rates to 0% and introduced an unprecedented QE in 2020. Ok, that wasn't a mistake itself given how severe lockdowns were at the time, but it was a huge mistake to let that run for more than just a few months (they should've tapered it mid-2020, not let it run into 2022).
Then, after making the colossal mistake of leaving QE until 2022, they made another mistake in the opposite direction. Why they hiked above 2% in 2022 is beyond comprehension. Most ppl still don't understand what a colossal mistake this was because of the large fiscal stimulus that managed to counteract that, but this will not last forever. Also, the statistical problems from BLS/BEA, which really have stone-age methodology when it comes to tracking inflation, only add fuel to the fire. Politicians use this bc most ppl don't know what inflation is and they think it's high bc prices are rising. Well, thank God pricing are rising bc the day prices stop rising and turn the other way is the day they could end up homeless. When you experience a massive increase in prices from 2020 to early 2022, then any further increases, no matter how small they are, feel massive. Perception often matters more than reality. Politicians know that and create more problems...
Come time, ppl will see the consequences of those mistakes, and things won't be pretty. On the contrary. I fear for what it may look like...
Nominal +5.6% in Q3 vs +8.5% in Q2 vs + 5.8% in Q1...
Where is that pick-up in growth that Warsh was talking about yesterday?
That's a reduction in both the GDP deflator and growth, NOT a pick-up in growth.