Jennifer Coffindaffer

Wife/Proud Mama Retired FBI Agent
@NewsNation -
Law & Justice Contributor
Expert Witness: Eagle Security

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

Nancy Guthrie

The evidence shows a kidnapping for ransom plot gone south.

But who is behind the plot that likely resulted in 84 YO Nancy's death?

If we examine similar historical cases, here are the likely propositions (no special order):

*Wrench Attack - A sophisticated crime group researched Nancy and the wealth of her daughter Savannah. With a plethora of photos of Nancy, her home, even her bedroom, Nancy was a ripe target for an easy abduction. And the closeness of Savannah & Annie to Nancy made the prospect of getting paid a likely prospect in the group's mind. The problem was Nancy died at Porch Guy's hands. Abductors sent 2 ransom demands after Nancy's death hoping for pay dirt (In many other cases ransom is paid with no proof (photo) of life (e.g. Annie Hearin kidnapping case) Wrench plots involve the requests for crypto keys to unlock accounts. Over 2 Billion in crypto has been paid for ransom from 2023-2025. It's big business. (e.g. Augustin B. pseudonym case)

*A family member plotted her murder, staged it as a kidnapping for money/didn't want her around. Her immediate family has been cleared, but could some other relative have planned this? I am not barking up this tree, but present it as many people believe this. (e.g. Hazel Abel case)

*A handyman/family friend, organized and methodical plotted the kidnapping. Remember the case of Heddy Braun. A ransom demand was not even made in that case until 2 days later (Nancy's case 1 day). $3 million demanded. (Nancy's case $6 million). Braun miraculously survived the abduction & was rescued about 4 days later. She was found shackled in subzero temperatures in a trailer.

*Revenge plot. Someone angry at Nancy/a Guthrie family member perpetrated this crime to cause absolute misery to this family. That means, the torture of abducting Nancy with 0 regard for her life. They wanted to strip of the family of money (thus ransom demand), cause severe emotional distress, and inflict damage on their reputations by publicly going forth with the demands knowing the ransom demand would not be paid causing much public scrutiny (which has happened). They also set up the kidnap to frame, in a sense, Tomasso & Annie's by choosing to kidnap her after a family dinner and with Tomasso last to see her hoping the public would make the leap to blame them. This would be someone completely obsessed with torturing the Guthrie family; Someone who would risk it all to murder their matriarch - like the Annie Hearin case.

Which one makes the most sense?

Where is Nancy. It has been 112 days.

#NancyGuthrie
#NancyGuthrieKidnapping

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

Senator Lyndsey Graham

When you have a Senator who dies unexpectedly even when an ME determines natural causes, you dot the Is and cross those Ts in an abundance of caution.
https://t.co/ak5h3ufzMc

#LyndseyGraham

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@Charlois62 💯

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

Nolan Wells

Al Sharpton loves to use the smell metaphor when he talks about racism. He does it with cases he has spoken about. Nothing new here.

He says he smells racism. He says he is an air freshener. He says his smell works before his brain.

Just think of the good Al could do if he chose to unite instead of divide.

There is 0 evidence that Nolan's friend killed him. 0.

They should not have separated.

They should have stuck together.

But to insinuate that Nolan was killed because he was black makes no sense whatsoever.

#NolanWells

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

16 kids case - Ohio

A gag order is now in place.

Gary Siders, Jr. doesn't want his secrets discussed by those in the know.

In an egregious case like this, makes sense.

#GarySiders
#16kids

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@EFGoldson Makes sense if he was swimming. He would not have the phone.

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

Nolan Wells

He was out having a good time with friends on Horn Island on the 4th.

Everything was going great until his friends returned to the mainland without their friend. He was found drowned.

Lots of questions, but as we originally discussed, you can't leave your wingman when you are partying especially when teens, water, and booze is involved.

Tragic.

@AttorneyCrump

#NolanWells
#Mississippi

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

The Sider 16 kids recovered in Ohio

So...

The judge has ordered a mental evaluation for Gary Siders Sr.

Obviously, anyone who does this to children has issues, but, did he know right from wrong? That's the issue.

Also, at what point over the last several years did he lose it?

I see the chatter.

Excuses for treating children like this, well, they may be explanations but not justification.

These children had No chance.

My empathy is with the 16 children, some of whom can't speak, are feral, were kept in human feces, and lord knows what else...

Gary Sr. heard their cries and saw their pain and did nothing.

Tired of the poor me.

He knew right from wrong or he would not have condoned & participated in hiding them.

*Please look where they were kept. No excuse. None.

#Ohio
#16kids

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

Follow-up on the East St. Louis family Annihilator

She was only 15 when she and her boyfriend allegedly went on a shooting spree to annihilate her family.

I guess she just hated everyone who likely loved her.

Her boyfriend, #JaymeirDavis, has been charged with 5 counts of murder.

The Victim's photos are below.

#Familyannihilator
#SaintLouis

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

A 15 and 16 YO are in custody after being charged with murdering 5 family members and wounding 2 others in an East St. Louis housing project, a park, and a home. They knew exactly where they would be. They hunted them down and killed them, allegedly.

"The victims were identified as Quentin L. Thompson, 21; Devin D. May, 24; Shania W. Thompson, 25; Cherie L. May, 49; and Patricia A. May, 74. According to police, one of the suspects is related to at least one of the victims."

Family Annihilators at such a young age.

May justice be served for these victims.

#StLouis

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@Amandahhh17 Agree, but we don't know where the video actually came from. I do see your point. LE said some video being circulated was AI.

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

16 Kids

There is a video circulating that shows the purported inside of the Sider's house.

It looks like the prosecutor plans to prosecute whoever crossed the police tape and took those videos.

He would not authentic the video circulating.

Other than the photos below, I do not know if the video is accurate or not.

Will wait for official word.

I think we get the idea from these photos.

#16kids
#Ohio

https://t.co/oDDSJj3itC

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@TrueCrimePod Such a great point.

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@nikthehat @Trumpsters45 Exactly.

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

Michigan

Please use your platforms to help find the birth mother who discarded her full term baby in a porta potty at a Michigan music festival. The baby was found alongside the placenta and umbilical chord.

The FBI has joined the investigation to determine who committed this heinous crime.

A cleaning crew found the infant.

The FBI is offering a $15K reward.

#electricforest
#Michigan

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@Cyncynabun Lol. So right.

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@RamonaTuck46930 Have they had the top investigators from the beginning, or did they lose valuable time? The first 48 is real...

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

Nancy Guthrie

Sheriff Nanos reacted to apparent inaccurate reporting by Reuters that the ransom notes received by the media early in the early stages of Nancy's investigation are fakes according to Reuter's "source".

The FBI said not true and now Nano's says not true. (See below)

Those initial 2 notes, 1 ransom and 1 apology note, are under investigation.

FBI "officials" aren't leaking information on an active case. If they are, they won't be FBI officials for long.

Just ask Terry J. Albury and several others.

In this case we have seen sources motivated by hatred and politics. Some have even disgraced their oath in their decision to leak information on an active investigation.

What would be the motivation for an FBI official to leak?

I don't see it.

What I do see is motivation by Reuters (and others) to make a big splash with this news...

And they did.

#NancyGuthrie
#NancyGuthtiekidnapping

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@BlancaXsis No. The baby was found dead after being born alive :(

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

@KimberA777 Horrendous way to treat that little dog.

[Jennifer Coffindaffer @CoffindafferFBI]

The lowest of of low of humanity like to abuse animals.

It is one of our biggest advocacy causes on this platform.

This building was condemned and someone left this poor animal chained for Lord knows how long.

One of our amazing gals in blue rescued the dog.

You can see the abuse in the dog's eyes.

So glad he was rescued.

Good morning, True Crimers.

P.S. He reminds me a little of my Simba.

#DogLovers
#Animalcruelty