The modern day distrust of "vibecoded apps" is literally just a new way to say "i hate lazy bad software engineers".
A codebase largely made through the use of AI can either be bad or good, depending on the experience and skill of the engineer.
Same shit, different phrasing.
it's actually perfectly okay that some people are manlier than others
toxic masculinity is the unwarranted assertion that more manliness is always better
like there's a difference between "claude make me a game like mario but cooler" and "let's rewrite our attack logic to be framerate-independent so we can uncap the fps in the testrunner so our testsuite runs 10x faster"
we are not the same
"eugenics is good" is not a belief that one comes to by weighing the evidence, how the world works, and one's belief in what is good and moral
instead, it comes from a promise that "eugenics will make the bad people go away", and is a tool to discard the unworthy
This tweet brought to you by the phrase: "this is why we need fascism and eugenics"
First thought was "you must have a faulty model of evolutionary biology if you think this behavior can be bred out"
Second thought was "oh, you have no model of how eugenics works *at all*"
This is why using AI for code is frequently a big win. Code can be art, but the only people who can appreciate said art are the people who can access and understand the code. And code is almost never written to be art in and of itself (esolangs and the like being the exception)
@noqtiscom art is more than just visuals
music is art
game design is art
writing is art
to paraphrase Yahtzee, no one says the visuals don't matter when they're good
good music and graphics won't ever make a game good, but they WILL elevate the experience - Hollow Knight is a great example
"AI Art" is an oxymoron
The purpose of using AI in a project is to quickly churn through the parts where you don't care about every fiddly detail.
Putting care into the details is what elevates a thing to being Art.
@noqtiscom they absolutely put care into the details of StS's visuals, they just aren't as skilled in that department. it's still full of human choices about how the cards should look, how the characters are differentiated from each other, the whole visual language
bad art is still art
AI Art isn't art because the AI will only have weirdly specific fixations if you ask it to, whereas a human will do it by accident
https://t.co/II67GzotBX
@whatKCthought the struggle to create something genuinely has meaning, because that difficulty causes you to prioritize, and decide what details are important vs what can remain a vague gesture
in prose, "she walked through the garden" vs "the roses were roseing, the petunias were petuniaing-"
Y'know this was a very humanocentric take. What AIs make can absolutely be art. Humans, however, cannot *use* AI and call the result art. And it is the height of arrogance to call it YOUR art. If you call yourself an "AI Artist" then you are categorically despicable.
@whatKCthought the struggle to create something genuinely has meaning, because that difficulty causes you to prioritize, and decide what details are important vs what can remain a vague gesture
in prose, "she walked through the garden" vs "the roses were roseing, the petunias were petuniaing-"
@whatKCthought key here being the WORK of art
there's an information-theory angle to it. a tree painting with ten hours of painstakingly deciding which angle the branches should go and what hue the leaves should be, will have more to say than "grok: one tree please"
Social Media ads are PARTICULARLY evil because they financially reward companies for incentivizing users to behave in a way that maximizes ad views. This means engagement farming, being polarizing, whatever it takes to get you to click more
https://t.co/wjg9i9hRXU
the problem with the modern internet is that the incentive structures reward companies that Optimize for our Attention
all companies need attention to sell goods/services, but companies that make money on ads are monetizing our attention *directly*
https://t.co/RTcnJpu8eO