But “not all cultures have the same contemporary capacity for constitutional self-government” is only one of the basic assumptions of your argument
The racist part is when you go on to say stuff like, “And we therefore must keep them away, for the sake of our own survival”
This is, indeed, a mask off moment. Here a newly minted academic declares without a hint of self doubt that a proposition obvious to almost everyone not too long ago, and obvious to many now—that not all cultures have the same contemporary capacity for constitutional self-government—is bigoted and racist. It is arguments like this and the cavalier confidence with which they are freely asserted in the halls of academia that make everything Trump wants to do to the universities seem so eminently justified.
Here is the link to this tragically anti-intellectual post falsely attacking me as a bigot and racist for having asserted an obvious truth: https://t.co/lYDgQMdppJ
Nothing about the claim that people are being “imported” is “reasonable and almost certainly true”
And the biggest impediment to immigrants’ assimilation is the idea that, by their very presence, they are an existential threat to American society and deserve our suspicion
AMK is off the rails. Accusing another academic of racism for a holding a reasonable and almost certainly true position about the importance of assimilation in connection with immigration is beyond the pale of ordinary discourse.
Fortunately for us, America is still only 250 years into developing its own political identity, and we have been successfully assimilating immigrants the entire time. Hell, we assimilate people like clockwork even in their home countries
A bad historian, doing bad futurism
In case I need to break it down, I said:
1. It can take 1,000 years to develop habits of thought and culture that make liberal democracy and constitutional government possible.
2. You can’t import millions of people without assimilation *today* and expect them to share those important habits.
Somehow AMK interprets me as saying, the English wanted assimilation in 1215???
The full clip makes it clearer (AMK has it), but what I’m saying is obvious even from this oddly spliced clip.
To whatever extent this is correct, as far as “literal threats to Our Democracy” go, the federal government’s struggles to enforce immigration laws (retroactively and en masse, I would note) are at most secondary to the federal government’s open disdain for due process
If the national government can’t enforce the national laws that define who is or isn’t part of the demos, that seems like a rather literal threat to Our Democracy.
“Totalitarianism in power invariably replaces all first-rate talents, regardless of their sympathies, with those crackpots and fools whose lack of intelligence and creativity is still the best guarantee of their loyalty.” - Hannah Arendt in “The Origins of Totalitarianism”
"If you don't want your tax dollars to help the poor, then stop saying you want a country based on Christian values, because you don't.”
- Jimmy Carter
We have a tendency to think in terms of doing and not in terms of being. We think that when we are not doing anything, we are wasting our time. But that is not true. Our time is first of all for us to be. To be what? To be alive, to be peaceful, to be joyful, to be loving.