Jonathan Newell is the one who advertised Jane Doe as “free pussy” to his entire fraternity, so YES he knew how the other men got into the room and why they were there. He knew she was in and out of consciousness. Matthew Ingalls tells the men they can “walk in and whip it out”.
Those claiming what happened to Jane Doe was consensual are conveniently ignoring this text exchange where Jane Doe says she was uncomfortable with the many men she didn’t know who came into the room and Jonathan claims he was not able to stop them: but HE invited the entire frat
I do think Karthik has some questionable morals/notions especially about his line with people knowing the truth, but telling a child who will 100% either be exiled or murdered if people find out who she is to hide is not comparable to Mother Gothel and Rapunzel 😭
I’ve said it bef, but one of the things I love about ATLA is that they treat genocide and it’s consequences with the proper weight those topics deserve even in a fantasy world.
We will forever as a audience feel the grief of that absence of the air nomads into the future.