The fatwa on political donations failed to address the core problem and ventured into a grey area. There are clear categories of zakat recipients that are much more effective in achieving the objectives they aim at.
@joebradford I feel they're putting the cart before the horse. First step was to build a public repo of translated classic books. An embarrassingly high volume of foundational text is still unavailable in english to this day. At least, not to my knowledge.
@omar_dddg hahah - so wait - does this app actually source books from a good variety of sources, including modernists? also a lot of islamic books aren't translated. I assumed it was feeding from islamqa and ignored it smh
Let's stop pretending bitcoin will solve the economy for justice. People hoarded in the gold standard, they hoard now. Zakat is the solution, because it pegs the weaker to the stronger. That's why it's a pillar of islam.
The reason people flee muslim countries swimming, is because the West is closer to islam than muslim countries. Islam isn't about repeating words or admonishing others, it's about being just.
@sajidumar@IsmailKamdar And why dismissing ibn Hazm at all if he provided evidence from the Sunnah that music is permitted (Risala fi al-Ghina' pp 160-3). The concept of Ijma that you rely on is disputed and used applied opportunistically by arbitrarily dismissing certain scholars (read Saeed)
Algeria, Egypt, Pakistan, Lebanon... all have some of the worst inflation levels on the planet. So why is it that muslim countries all share that issue, despite having vastly different economical models?
Link Below
So their savings were robbed by inflation, and as a result, many of these countries are heavily reliant on social welfare for their stability. The fact that islamic finance snake oil merchants claim the moral high grounds on this, is some audacity.
Muslim countries where islamic finance is prevalent have the worst inflation on the planet. islamic finance is by design a thin layer on top of the normal banking system. It cannot change the fact that fiat money can be printed into oblivion.
If anything, it has made it even more unfair and exploitative for the people: while folks in Europe or the US have had access to inflation adjusted retirement plans, those in muslim countries have not.
@sajidumar@IsmailKamdar Existence of a national anthem in every muslim country, including those applying Shariyah law, is evidence there is no Ijma on this today. Informal jurists not operating in legitimate legal frameworks seem to be compensating their lack of authority by overstating their claims.
@sajidumar@IsmailKamdar Existence of a national anthem in every muslim country, including those applying Shariyah law, is evidence there is no Ijma on this today. Informal jurists not operating in legitimate legal frameworks seem to be compensating their lack of authority by overstating their claims.
@sajidumar@IsmailKamdar Then why do every muslim on the planet have a national anthem. Are they all astray?.. It reminds me of the prohibition of pictures while the picture of the rulers were printed on every bank note in use. If everyone makes up a fatwa - then it's anarchy.
@sajidumar@IsmailKamdar Then why do every muslim on the planet have a national anthem. Are they all astray?.. It reminds me of the prohibition of pictures while the picture of the rulers were printed on every bank note in use. If everyone makes up a fatwa - then it's anarchy.
@SafdarAlam "islamic" finance is 5tr? that's massive. Even that I'd be interested to see how it breaks down. I'm pretty sure no one serious ever evaluated the social cost of this cash burn