Musterbrief an Wahlkreisabgeordnete von CDU/CSU und SPD zur möglichen Abschaffung der Haltefrist bei Bitcoin:
Betreff: Geplante Abschaffung der Haltefrist nach § 23 EStG – Bitte um Ihre Position
Sehr geehrte/r Frau/Herr [Name],
ich wende mich an Sie als Bürger/in Ihres Wahlkreises [Wahlkreis/Ort]. Anlass ist der mögliche Regierungsentwurf, mit dem die einjährige Haltefrist für private Veräußerungsgeschäfte nach § 23 EStG für Kryptowerte abgeschafft werden soll. Ich bitte Sie, diesem Vorhaben nicht zuzustimmen, und möchte Ihnen kurz begründen, warum.
1. Es geht um Vertrauensschutz.
Bereits am 20. Juni 2013 hat die Bundesregierung auf eine parlamentarische Anfrage hin klargestellt, dass Bitcoin als privates Wirtschaftsgut behandelt wird und Veräußerungen unter § 23 EStG fallen – mit einjähriger Haltefrist, wie beim Verkauf von Edelmetallen. Das Bundesfinanzministerium hat diese Einordnung 2022 in einem umfassenden Schreiben bestätigt. Millionen Bürger haben auf dieser Grundlage über mehr als ein Jahrzehnt ihre Vermögensplanung ausgerichtet. Wer diese Systematik nun kippt, beschädigt das Vertrauen in die Verlässlichkeit unseres Steuerrechts – weit über das Thema Kryptowerte hinaus.
2. Es gibt ein verfassungsrechtliches Problem.
Der allgemeine Gleichheitssatz (Art. 3 Abs. 1 GG) verbietet die Ungleichbehandlung wesentlich gleicher Sachverhalte. Bitcoin ist steuersystematisch wie Gold ein privates Wirtschaftsgut – keine Kapitalanlage im Sinne des § 20 EStG, denn es gibt keinen Emittenten, keinen Zins und keine Forderung. Das Bundesverfassungsgericht hat in seiner Entscheidung zur Pendlerpauschale (2008) klargestellt: Wer eine steuerrechtliche Grundentscheidung trifft, muss sie folgerichtig durchhalten. Ausnahmen bedürfen eines besonderen sachlichen Grundes – der rein fiskalische Zweck der Einnahmenerhöhung genügt ausdrücklich nicht. Eine gezielte Herauslösung von Kryptowerten aus der Systematik des § 23 EStG, während Gold, Kunst und Oldtimer dort verbleiben, wäre genau eine solche nicht folgerichtige Ausnahme.
3. Die praktischen Folgen träfen den Standort.
Geschätzt 7 bis 10 Millionen Menschen in Deutschland halten Bitcoin und andere Kryptowerte – quer durch alle Alters- und Einkommensgruppen, viele davon in Ihrem Wahlkreis. Die Abschaffung der Haltefrist würde nicht die großen Vermögen treffen, die längst über Kapitalgesellschaften oder im Ausland strukturiert sind, sondern private Sparer, die langfristig und rechtstreu vorgesorgt haben. Zugleich würde Deutschland einen Standortvorteil aufgeben, den andere Länder gezielt aufbauen.
Meine Bitte an Sie:
Setzen Sie sich in Ihrer Fraktion dafür ein, dass die Haltefrist des § 23 EStG für Kryptowerte erhalten bleibt. Ich würde mich über eine kurze Rückmeldung freuen, wie Sie zu diesem Vorhaben stehen und wie Sie im weiteren Gesetzgebungsverfahren abzustimmen beabsichtigen.
Mit freundlichen Grüßen
[Vor- und Nachname]
[Straße, Hausnummer]
[PLZ, Ort – im Wahlkreis]
[ggf. E-Mail/Telefon]
🚨Join our Summer Giveaway for your CHANCE TO WIN one of 18 training packages with a total value of $4,000!💸
x1: Annual Elite Package
x1: PADS on PADS
x1: Knockout Tournament Mastery
x2: From The Ground Up MTT
x3: Elite memberships
x10: Essential memberships
Find the link 👇
@Trendemen@SatonioSorare Sorry to see that bro! Maby stupid question but how could this happen? Dont look like an obv scam more like a misstake from you...
I think it’s good that Sorare is supporting content creators, but what I don’t understand is why he doesn’t use his main account to promote Sorare, where he has 1.2 million followers: https://t.co/FS0buhmF1i.
Instead, he created a new one with 800 followers? It’s reaching people who are already playing Sorare and isn’t attracting any new users, but maybe I’m missing something.
Hey #sorare ,
Have you really learned nothing?
You manage to make a few people happy with a training update and a Club Shop Grand Finale, while everyone else is fucked up again. Good trade, right? GG, another masterpiece. 😆
You seriously ask why?
Its ok to open a store where you dont even know what you want to give or sell, the big announced fitness packs maybe? Anyway, its also ok if you make mistakes or simply realize that you want to go in a different direction.
But whats not OK is to give your Players another reason to be pissed from nothing. OG Players collected and spend XXX,000 of your pointless coins for training teams, only to realize that theyre now worthless and everyone gets the same number of teams? And only the few who got training teams from August 16th will get their coins back? What about the others? Everyone else goes away empty-handed, HUGE GRAND FINALE! 💪
I would have preferred to get for example a hoodie for 50,000 and even advertise for you by wearing it outside, but now I have to hope to get one of those 50 pairs of socks on the last day at 17:00 sharp. If I dont get them, I think i have just keep my socks, they will remind kind of @Sorare too. #gofkyoursocks 😅
Bad jokes aside, to be really honest? I would have preferred it if you had simply taken the store out.
I personally really dont need anything for free, dont want any free coins, no hoodies, no fkin socks.
Actually, Im still waiting for 6 month for my Sorare NBA plastic water bottle, but who cares.
The only thing I want is that you dont disappoint your biggest fans and supporters again and again and without pissing them off over some bullshit.
I dont think that should be to much to ask? Or?
Best Regards,
MGM
Hey @Sorare please very simple and no big Deal
Change Coins -> Essence and Reward the user which helped grow this site. We have now all realised that you have no real plan with the coins. Save us and yourselves. Thank you
Hey #Sorare Community,
its me, Gocka 2.0 😅
bad jokes aside, however… i am writing this 💌 because i still love the game, still believe in it and still want it to be better than ever before.
But first… is it necessary and sustainable to push managers with old cards against the wall like this?
Hell noo, i think there is a bigger inbalance between Inseason and Classic then expected and needed. Especially these internationals for Classic are trash. Outside of Collection Bonus, 80% of the cards have or will have no value/utility anyway. This should be also adjusted at least a bit asap, but thats not even the point here.
Broken Gameplay (Division/Reward System)
I personally think that a lot of the trouble were having is also related to the broken Division/Rewards System. Before that, @Sorare (also Youtubers and other Managers) should read first and understand it. I have to assume that at least some of them ive watched or discussed with simply didnt. (Have to say at this point: Ive seen some very good and objective videos also as those by @NepentheZ and @McBrideAce , so big probs for that!!! 👍
So what’s the Gameplay issue? Example Limited La Liga Classic:
See the picture down below of the Real Madrid Stack 492.6 Points (all with full 15% XP, except Carvajal 12.5%)
Rewards we get with 492.6 Points in:
Div 1 = Box with Essence or 20% Level Ups.
Div 2 = T3 Card + Box
DIv 3 = Podium 3th & T1 Card + Box
Div 4 = Podium 1st & T1 Card + Box
Div 5 = Podium 2nd & T1 Card + Box
So, what Division would you choose? Winning A Box or Winning 1st Place and a T1 is a really big Gap between isnt it? Yes, Barca won in the GW 7:0, but had exactly the same problem with my PL Division - ManCity Stack with 446 Points. This can be found almost everywhere in the actual Division System as well. What makes it even worse is then looking in the direction of Inseason. That in Div 5 Inseason Managers with 247 points geting a better Box than players with 492.6 points in Classic because 50% get rewarded is mental to me.
Im still laughing, even the jokes not funny at all.😂
Problems like this we have for over 6 months now. I really thought Sorare would notice it in the transition phase and do something for the start that works.
Why is it a problem?
Especially in Division 1, but also in Div 2, there is a much higher concentration of "Top Teams with high %" and Sorare have to give out more rewards there. Just look at the median of each Division.
If you still ask you why? Simply because its logically much harder to achieve a good place there & almost always more expensive.
For example youre a Coach in the first division Bundesliga, does it make any sense that coaches from the 4th or 5th regional leagues earn more than you for worse performances against worse teams?
One League Competitions has made it even more difficult, cause less variance in Team Building etc. Even me, who plays Stacks, saying to run Stacks is boring and not very skill-based. Unfortunately, its still the simplest and probably best +ev for rewards… so we play it right. Is it fun? Not really, will we play it also in Div 2-5 if needed? Of ccourse🤣
Personally, I have no interest in being relegated on purpose, and then have to guess or calculate which division I put my best team in for a better reward. The idea of giving the weaker Teams a chance in the lower divisions is also not given and failed big.
In my opinion possible Solutions:
Capped Divisions, for Example:
Div 5 = All new ones
Div 4 = Cap 220
Div 3 = Cap 240
Div 2 = Cap 270 = More and better Rewards
Div 1 = Keep the Cash für Podium or distribute it to Top 10, also more and better Rewards. (Could take out some % of the Rewards from lower Divisions 3-5).
Second option and still better then nothing:
Additionally Essence Treshold for Div 1, for example:
Over 460 Points 5-10 Essence
Over 420 Points 2-4 Essence
Of course, the numbers can be pulled up or down.
This would cost Sorare 0 $ more, but more fun, more skill, and even give some more value to the lower L15 Players to grind up the capped Divisions. Find some Cards to trade for, so that the teams fit into the cap.
In the long run, it also doesnt makes sense to let auctions and Insta buys compete "unfairly" against the 2nd market, Why? Trading a Card 20 times with the same price with 5% fee over the year gives Sorare the same turnover like 1 auction, that im almost forced to hold forever, right? But thats also another big Topic, I prefer not to go into that here.
All i want to say here: Everybody should want to play Division 1. Then Stars will be Stars and Managers will be Managers. @ni2las ✌️😄
I really think this could fix at least some of the gameplay/fun/reward/skill issues and have alot of positive impact.
If anyone has made it this far😅what do you think?
@Sorare@ni2las@andrewmlaird@Soraredata@Yowzaa_@CaniSports@SorareJosalde@EnPaulPosition@NoTimeW3 @a_GrizZi @BJK_Fan_1903@Briefi81@elyesorare@MikeOfPompey@Jobznt23@paul78767602@SorareMonkey@soraresupport