On New Yearβs Eve 1975 an 18-year-old babysitter knelt by the family Christmas tree and struck a match. Mom, dad and four kids aged 4 to 7 choked to death on the smoke. She got out a window and played the lucky survivor. Fifty years later sheβs still locked up, and she wants out:
She says it was never meant to kill anyone.
Her name is Sarah βCindyβ White. She was the live-in babysitter for Charles and Carol Roberson and their four kids, Michael, 7, Dale, 6, Gary, 5, and Rita, 4. That night she sat by the tree in her footy pajamas with a matchbook.
βIf I set a small fire, want to smoke it up to where everybody gets out, I can leave.β
She says Charles abused her and threatened to kill her family if she ran. The state said they were lovers and she lit it because she felt jilted. The only evidence for her story is her own word.
The fire shot up the walls. The whole family died in the smoke. She ended up on the ground outside and says she canβt remember how she got out that window.
Then she told everyone it was a Christmas tree fire. Investigators found accelerant. She was convicted of murder in 1977 and kept lying for about ten more years.
βI struck that match and I set that fire. But it wasnβt to kill anybody.β
In the video below she walks through that night and answers whether sheβd set herself free.
Sheβs Indianaβs longest-serving female inmate. Asked what sentence anyone else should get for that fire, she didnβt blink.
βNot on death row because thatβs too easy.β
Sheβs filed at least 10 appeals and clemency bids since 1978, the first one a couple of years into her sentence. Carol Robersonβs son, Tracy Pace, lost his mother and four half-siblings in that fire. Heβs told reporters he thinks sheβs paid her debt.
βA part of me wants to say yes and a part of me wants to say no because I donβt deserve it.β
Some say a damaged 18-year-old has done 50 years and should get to die outside. Others say six people, four of them little kids, choked in their beds while she climbed out and lied for a decade.
After 50 years for six lives, should Cindy White die in prison or go home?
A church volunteer who ran a daycare and wrote uplifting letters to inmates agreed to write to a man she saw on a jail video screen. In 2017 she spent eight days on the road with him while he killed four women in Florida and Alabama. One was shot right in front of her baby son:
Mary says she was his hostage. A jury says sheβs a murderer.
Her name is Mary Rice. Divorced, four kids, two of them now dead. She ran the daycare at St. Maryβs Episcopal and helped with its prison letter ministry. On a jail visit with a friend, a man named Billy Boyette popped up on the screen and asked if sheβd write to him.
She wrote him once. Then her brother, who was in prison himself, told her to stop. Boyette had a violent past. She says she quit writing and never made contact.
On January 31, 2017, Boyette shot Alicia Greer, 30, and Jacqueline Moore, 39, at a motel in Milton, Florida. On February 3 he shot Peggy Broz, 51, at her home in Lillian, Alabama, and took her car. On February 6 he and Rice showed up at Kayla Crockerβs home in Beulah. Rice tied Kaylaβs hands.
βWhenever I tied it, I told her I was sorry and I said Iβm tying this real loose.β
Kayla, 28, was shot in front of her 18-month-old son and died. Rice says she wasnβt in the room.
βI did hear a gunshot go off. I was at the car. I was not there.β
Police tracked the stolen car to a motel in West Point, Georgia. Rice walked out and surrendered. Boyette shot himself inside. At trial prosecutors showed video of her buying ammunition during the spree.
In September 2018 a jury convicted her of first-degree murder for Kaylaβs death and of being an accessory after the fact. Life, plus 30 years. She still says she spent all eight days drugged and terrified.
βIβm sorry I couldnβt save βem. I tried to save as many people as I could on this eight day nightmare that I was on.β
Some say she was a captive who did what she had to do to stay alive. Others say a hostage doesnβt go shopping for bullets.
She tied the rope on Kaylaβs wrists and says it was loose. Victim or accomplice?
A mother stood up in court after her two kids were dug up in her new husbandβs backyard and told the judge nobody was murdered. She said she had died once and come back, and that her dead children visit her from heaven. Theyβre happy and very busy now, she said:
The judge gave her life without parole.
Her name is Lori Vallow Daybell. Five marriages, a grown son, a daughter Tylee and an adopted son JJ.
She fell for Chad Daybell, a doomsday author who believed the people around them could turn into βzombies.β
In July 2019 her brother shot dead her husband Charles in her Arizona home and called it self-defense.
In September Tylee, 16, and JJ, 7, stopped being seen. In October Chadβs wife Tammy was found dead in her bed. About two weeks later Lori married Chad on a beach in Hawaii.
Police asked where the kids were. She lied. In June 2020 they dug up both children on Chadβs property in Idaho.
The charges included grand theft for collecting the kidsβ Social Security money after they were already dead. In 2023 a jury found her guilty on every count, including conspiracy to murder Tammy. At sentencing this monster quoted the Bible and then told everyone what really happened.
βJesus Christ knows that no one was murdered in this case. Accidental deaths happen. Suicides happen.β
Then she described heaven.
βI know for a fact that my children are happy and busy in the spirit world.β
In the same breath she brought up Tammy, the woman whose husband she married two weeks after the funeral.
βBecause of my communications with my friend Tammy Daybell, I know that she is so very happy and extremely busy.β
Chad got the death penalty in 2024. In 2025 Arizona gave her two more life sentences, for Charles and for a shot fired at her nieceβs ex-husband.
Some say sheβs insane and belongs in a hospital, not a cell. Others say she did it for money and a new man and found God as cover.
She buried her kids in a backyard and says theyβre busy in heaven. Insane or evil?
A 28-year-old photographer looked into a TV camera and swore no jury would ever convict her. Her ex had been shot in the face, stabbed 27 times and had his throat cut in his own shower. Cops had her palm print in his blood and a camera full of photos from that day:
She said two masked strangers did it and she ran.
Her name is Jodi Arias. The man was Travis Alexander, 30, a motivational speaker in Mesa, Arizona. They dated for five months. She says it ended when she caught him cheating.
In June 2008 friends found him dead in his shower. Police found the camera in his washing machine. Investigators pulled deleted shots off it: the two of them that afternoon, then Travis bleeding on the bathroom floor.
Inside Edition sat down with her in jail.
βI absolutely did not kill Travis Alexander. I had nothing to do with his murder.β
Then she pitched the masked strangers.
βIβm not proud that I just left my friend there to be slaughtered at the hands of two other people.β
The reporter tells her she looks guilty. She doesnβt blink.
βNo jury is going to convict me. Because Iβm innocent, and you can mark my words on that one.β
In 2013 a jury convicted this lying killer of first-degree murder. By trial the masked strangers were gone. Her new story was self-defense: she said he came at her first. The trial ran on live TV for four months and the whole country watched her lie.
Two juries couldnβt agree on death. In April 2015 she stood in prison stripes and apologized to his family.
βI am very sorry for the enormous pain that Iβve caused the people that loved Travis.β
His three sisters begged the judge for no mercy. She got natural life with no chance of parole.
Some say she earned the needle. Others say rotting in a cell for the rest of her life is worse.
Which one would she be more scared of?