One of the biggest comedians in America was selling out arenas, then found out he had a few hundred grand to his name. His business manager had drained $12 million and hid cash in pasta sauce jars. It was his own brother. When the FBI came in, the brother left him a voicemail:
He played the victim.
The comedian is Dane Cook. His half-brother Darryl McCauley ran his money for years, with power of attorney and full access to everything. From 2004 to 2008 Darryl and his wife Erika pulled cash out of his accounts and sent Dane forged bank statements.
“If you’re in the business of betrayal, use love.”
Three days after Darryl went missing, Dane went to the bank and saw he’d been wiped out. Then his phone lit up.
“What have you done, Dane? What have you done to me?”
Dane realized his brother wasn’t calling to fix anything. He saved the message. It now opens his documentary, Funny Money: The Dane Cook Story.
In the video below Dane tells what he saw in his brother’s face in court, and the deal he offered him to finally talk.
Darryl pleaded guilty and got six years, plus an order to pay back $12 million. Erika got two and a half years. Dane says a paperwork mistake kept her inside an extra year.
At sentencing Dane read his victim impact letter, then stopped and stared at his brother from five feet away.
“If you sat a great white shark next to him in a chair, it would have had more empathy on its face than my brother.”
For the doc Dane offered to tear up the $12 million if Darryl would just sit across from him. Darryl said yes, then backed out.
“I’ll do it for, and I quote, family healing. And then a week later he said, nah.”
About $1.6 million has been found. Around $3 million is still out there. Dane still has a writ of execution he’s never used.
Some say Dane is still too soft, offering to wipe out $12 million just to get his brother in a chair. Others say a brother who robbed him blind and still won’t face him doesn’t deserve a single cent of forgiveness.
Should Dane forgive the brother who robbed him blind, or fire up the writ and send the sheriffs?
A caregiver moved in rent-free with a 65-year-old man in a wheelchair who had no family. Her boyfriend took his bank card and wanted his disability money for drugs. On Christmas Day, high on meth, he demanded the PIN one last time. The old man still refused to give it up to him:
So they tied him up, taped his face and stuffed him under his own bed.
Her name is Alicia Keator. In 2017 she moved into John Fernandez’s apartment in Baytown, Texas. He lived on a small Social Security check, couldn’t pay for home care and needed someone to look after him day and night. She says she did it for free.
Her boyfriend Marcus Gilbert had just got out after 13 years in prison. He took John’s ATM card but still needed the PIN. On Christmas Eve he locked himself in the bedroom with John and pushed. John curled up on the bed, crying.
“That number was going to go with him to his death.”
On Christmas morning John begged her not to let Gilbert hurt him. That day Gilbert threw him on the floor, kicked him in the head, cut the cord off his electric chair and tied his feet and hands. He taped John’s mouth and eyes, pushed him under the bed and locked the door. She told police Gilbert told her to do nothing and watch.
Half an hour later they heard John fighting the tape, trying to breathe and get out. Gilbert hit her and told her to help tape his hands and feet. She helped.
They packed up and left. Later she called a neighbor to ask if anyone had seen John, knowing he was dead in the apartment. His body was found on January 2.
Both pleaded guilty to murder. Gilbert got 60 years. This so-called caregiver got 25, mostly because she talked. Asked if her sentence was fair, she said no, just not the way you’d expect.
“More years is what I felt I deserved.”
Some say she was a terrified woman who couldn’t stop Gilbert without dying herself. Others say she moved in for a free roof, watched a man die for a PIN number and then made a phone call to cover it.
She moved in to keep him alive and ended up holding the tape. Is 25 years enough, or should she have gotten the same 60 as Gilbert?
On Christmas Eve a New Jersey family man left his wife and kids to go collect a debt. By his own account he killed the guy who owed him, then drove home and spent the rest of Christmas Eve putting together toys for the children. He later told HBO he’d killed over 100 people:
The detectives who checked his stories say most of them never happened.
His name is Richard Kuklinski. Neighbors knew him as a businessman with a nice house, a wife named Barbara and three kids. Cops called him the Iceman because he froze one victim’s body to fool the coroner about when he died.
He grew up in the Jersey City projects with a father who beat him for no reason and a mother who went at him with a broom.
“She didn’t just use a hand. She would hit me with a broomstick or something like that.”
As a grown man he collected debts and took contract hits, and got rich doing it. Asked how killing feels, he says it doesn’t bother him one way or the other. Asked what he charged, he gets offended.
“If I hit somebody, I wouldn’t hit it for peanuts.”
At home it was the perfect picture. His wife says so herself.
“We were perfect. My children were never in trouble. We were perfect. We were the all-American family.”
That’s the family he left by the tree on Christmas Eve. The man owed him money and kept giving him the runaround.
“He had the attitude that nobody could hurt him. I think he was wrong.”
While he was putting the toys together, the TV news called it a mob hit.
In 1986 an undercover agent posing as a mobster got him on tape planning to poison a man with cyanide. He was arrested that December. In 1988 this cold-blooded freak got life for four murders, and later another 30 years for killing a New York police detective.
He claimed 100 to 200 victims. A member of the task force that caught him said not one of the extra murders he bragged about was true.
At the end of the tapes the Iceman cries. Not for anyone he killed.
“I’ve never felt sorry for anything I’ve done other than hurting my family.”
Some say he was the coldest killer America ever had. Others say he was a five-time murderer who padded his number for the cameras.
Toys under the tree and blood on his hands. Which one was the real him?
A romance novelist once posted an essay called How to Murder Your Husband. Seven years later her husband, a chef, was shot twice in his Portland school’s kitchen before class. She had about $1.4 million in life insurance on him and a ghost-gun kit she bought online:
She told the jury it was all research for a novel.
Her name is Nancy Crampton Brophy, 67, from Portland. Daniel Brophy, 63, taught at the Oregon Culinary Institute. On June 2, 2018 students walked in and found him on the kitchen floor.
Prosecutors said the couple was drowning in money trouble. She stood to collect the insurance and the house. A camera caught her minivan near the school that morning. On the stand she said she didn’t remember being there.
She told the court her thing for ghost guns started with a New York Times article. Each chapter of her next book, she said, would add a new piece of the gun. She bought a Glock at a Portland gun show and swore Dan was fine with it.
Then she cried for him.
“It’s like you’ve lost an arm, you know? Like you’re just not as good as you were when you were with him.”
She also asked a detective for a letter clearing her name. The gun barrel she bought on eBay was never found.
In May 2022 the jury convicted this greedy scumbag of second-degree murder. At sentencing a woman from his school described the moment she reached him.
“His eyes were green and they were utterly heartbroken, utterly heartbroken, because he knew. He knew because he’d seen who did this.”
His son Nathaniel spoke next. He says she plotted it on Christmas Eve, sitting with Dan’s parents and grandkids.
“You executed my father in an act of cold-blooded, premeditated murder.”
Then he said it straight.
“You are a monster.”
The judge gave her life, with a shot at parole after 25 years.
Her lawyers said it was all circumstantial: no witness, no confession, no barrel. The jury said guilty anyway.
She wrote the manual and then lived it. Confession or the dumbest coincidence in Oregon?
RU
Russ Faria found his wife Betsy stabbed 55 times and got life for it. The jury never heard that four days earlier she had signed her $150,000 life insurance over to a friend, the last person to see her alive. Russ walked free. Then that friend shot a man dead in her home.
Betsy Faria was dying. Breast cancer had spread to her liver. She lived with Russ in Troy, Missouri, and her friend Pam Hupp drove her to chemotherapy.
Hupp drove her home from a session on December 27, 2011. That evening Russ walked in and called 911. A steak knife was still sticking out of Betsy’s neck.
Four friends said he had been with them all evening. Police found not a drop of blood on him. Nobody cared. In November 2013 he was convicted and got life plus 30 years.
The jury was kept in the dark about the library. Betsy and Hupp had gone to a public library, where a librarian witnessed Betsy sign a change of beneficiary form. Court records say Hupp promised to share the money with Betsy’s daughters and later told investigators it was hers alone.
In the video below a reporter asks Russ in prison whether he killed his wife.
“No, no, I didn’t. I loved her.”
A judge ordered a new trial. In November 2015 he was acquitted and walked out after almost four years inside.
“My legs melted underneath me.”
He is asked about Hupp.
“She’s been interviewed 13 times by the authorities and lawyers and I believe she’s given 13 different stories.”
Nine months later, on August 16, 2016, Hupp called 911 about a burglar and pumped five bullets into a man in her house. He was Louis Gumpenberger, 33, disabled since a car crash. Prosecutors said she lured him by posing as a Dateline producer. On his body police found $900 and a note that made it look like Russ had hired him to kidnap and kill her. The bills were traced to her home.
In 2019 she took an Alford plea and got life without parole. In July 2021 she was charged with murdering Betsy. She denies it. Her trial is set for January 24, 2028, before a judge with no jury.
Her lawyers say testing found male DNA on the knife handle that is not Russ’s. Russ says the insurance policy tells him enough.
Almost 15 years after the stabbing, no one stands convicted of killing Betsy Faria.
Should the first jury have heard about the insurance?
Dalia Dippolito came home from the gym to police tape and a cop telling her that her husband had been shot dead. She screamed and sobbed on camera. All of it was staged. The “hitman” she had paid to kill him was an undercover cop. Her husband was alive and waiting at the station.
She was 26, a former escort. Mike Dippolito was an ex-con on probation for fraud who met her when he hired her in October 2008. Four months later they were married. Six months after that she wanted him dead.
Mike says the money started vanishing within weeks. Then drugs turned up planted in his truck, meant to send him back to prison. It didn’t work.
So she asked a lover to find her a killer. He went to the police.
On hidden camera she handed over $1,200 for a gun. She told an undercover detective playing the hitman she was “5,000 percent sure”. The price for her husband was $7,000.
In August 2009 Boynton Beach police faked the murder scene, with a crew from the TV show COPS filming.
In the video below you watch her get the news, then try to sell detectives a list of suspects.
The sergeant says it flat.
“I’m sorry to tell you, ma’am. He’s been killed.”
Years later she told ABC what that moment feels like.
“I don’t wish this on anybody.”
At the station she plays the widow and points at Mike’s old enemies.
“He’s got all these sketchy characters from his past.”
The detectives walk out and leave the camera running. She keeps crying to an empty room.
Then they brought Mike to the door.
Her defense was that she’d been acting for a reality show. The first trial ended in 20 years, later overturned. The second hung. The third needed 90 minutes. In 2017 she got 16 years. She had a baby on house arrest between trials.
Her lawyers say cops hungry for TV fame scripted the whole thing. The judge said theater has no place in police work, and that those detectives saved Mike’s life.
She cried over a husband who was standing behind the door.
Set up for television, or a cold plan caught on tape?
Mark Winger shot the psycho who was smashing his wife’s head in with a hammer. Cops called him a hero. Case closed before the late news. Six years later his wife’s best friend walked into the station and said she’d been sleeping with him. And the “psycho” had been invited.
In 1995 Mark was a nuclear engineer for the state of Illinois. His wife Donnah was an operating room tech. After years of trying they had just adopted a baby girl.
Six days before the killing, a shuttle van driver named Roger Harrington scared the hell out of Donnah on the ride home from the airport. He raved about car bombs and flying above the trees. Mark called the van company and blew up.
Then Mark called 911. He said he was on the treadmill, heard a thud, grabbed his gun and found a stranger smashing Donnah with a hammer. He put a bullet in the man’s head. Both died in hospital. Harrington’s family got branded as the people who raised a monster.
It all fell apart later. A note in Harrington’s car had Mark’s name, address and 4:30 p.m. Three forgotten Polaroids showed the body lying the wrong way round. And Mark had married the nanny he hired five months after the murder.
In 2002 a jury convicted him of both murders. Life without parole.
In the video below Winger talks from prison, and you hear what he wrote next.
From his cell he still swears he was the victim.
“Everybody knows I had a wonderful marriage with Donnah.”
He has no answer for the note.
“I can’t offer you any answers to why Roger Harrington had 4:30 written on a note.”
In 2005 an inmate came forward. Mark had handed him 19 pages of instructions: kidnap the best friend, make her record that she lied, then kill her. He even planned for leftover cash.
“If there’s any money left over, kill Ira Dresser also.”
Ira was Donnah’s stepfather. Another 35 years.
Some say the cops who swallowed his story in one night gave him six free years. Others say the best friend sat on her secret for three and a half years while Harrington’s mother was called a killer’s mom.
He killed two people to get rid of one wife. From prison he tried to order two more.
Who’s more to blame for those six years, the cops or the friend who kept quiet?
His family owned the prosecutor’s office for 86 years. Alex Murdaugh robbed his clients blind, even the sons of his dead housekeeper. Then his wife and son were blown away with a rifle and shotgun. He got a man to shoot him for insurance money. His murder verdict just got tossed.
He was the golden boy of Hampton County, South Carolina. Rich lawyer, family firm, son and grandson of the men who’d decided who went to prison there since 1920.
And he was a thief. On the stand he admitted he stole about $3.7 million from clients in 2019 alone. In March 2021 he swiped $792,000 in fees from one case and burned through it in about two months. Part of it went to oxycodone.
His housekeeper Gloria Satterfield worked for the family for over 20 years. She died after a fall at his house. He sent her grieving sons to his buddy as their lawyer, then pocketed the entire $4.3 million insurance payout meant for them.
June 7, 2021. His wife Maggie and son Paul were found shot to death by the dog kennels on the family hunting land. Three months later Alex turned up on a back road with a bullet graze to the head. He later admitted he’d gotten a man to shoot him so his other son could cash a $10 million life insurance policy.
In the video below the prosecutor makes him face the people he robbed.
These were real people, and he had to say it out loud. “They’re all good people. They’re all people that I care about. And a lot of them, people that I love.”
He admits he looked them in the eye and they trusted him. “Good people, fine people. Upstanding people, they trusted me.”
Then he robbed them. “And I did wrong by them.”
He’s doing 27 years state and 40 years federal for the money. In 2023 a jury convicted him of killing Maggie and Paul and he got two life sentences. In May 2026 the South Carolina Supreme Court threw that out 5 to 0 because a court clerk had been leaning on the jury. He gets a brand new murder trial.
Some will say a man who stole from a dead woman’s kids is capable of anything. Others will say that’s exactly why he deserves a clean trial.
He admits he robbed people he says he loved. He swears he didn’t kill his wife and son.
Do you believe him?