So let me get this straight...
- Fortunes Weave isn't a GOTY contender (sad but okay)
- Fortunes Weave isn't a soundtrack contender but Mixtape is (huh?)
- Fortunes Weave isn't qualified to be a strategy contender but Pokopia and Slay The Spire 2 are...?
I think what leaves a bad taste in my mouth about GTA VI being nominated for GotY before it's even out is the messages it sends:
To regular gamers: Your experiences are no longer necessary to determine what's worthy of recognition.
To smaller devs: You're competing against franchises whose status and financial weight can earn nominations before release, actual quality be damned.
To publishers: You can get prestigious acclaim before customers have even touched your product.
To critics: Your judgment is being presented as authoritative before the public can meaningfully evaluate it.
"GTA 6 isn't a perfect game. The story is mid, missions are the same outdated shit they've been doing for decades, combat is boring af and the map could be better. 10/10 perfect score"
Nothing weird here, just good old ethical game journalism