@djhenshall I can give you 67M reasons for not breaking up our country. You would need to explain why it is necessary to unilaterally wash our hands of the reciprocal responsibilities we currently have for 61M of those reasons.
@SteveAshman2 Itโs in her gift to make a case to the UK Govt for such but nothing else. That case has has to be sufficiently compelling with evidence that (1) a consistent, unarguable majority of us want a referendum and (2) the proposal is demonstrably in the interests of UK citizens.
Can't help think that Sturgeon has lost her touch and misreads the room. With everything else happening in the world just now, this kind of needless uncertainty is absolutely the last thing ordinary people need. Dividing people when we should be looking out for each other.
@KeithRSteele Quite a good presenter but pretty empty when it comes to thinking about actual policy. Overall I think sheโs just pretty dull and overrated simply because of the colleagues you have to compare her to in Holyrood. Sheโs leaving a pitiful legacy though, wonder if she realises?
@KeithRSteele The more Iโve thought about it this week, the more I think her actions are a desperate, final throw of the dice. It is probably sinking in that her career has been for nothing.
@JamesMacEachern You might as well say the same for Edinburgh and Glasgow. Its just a choice of who you want to see as your own and who you want to pool and share responsibility/ opportunity with. Your preference is narrower than the one we have been born into and you want to reduce. I donโt.
@JamesMacEachern โScotlandโ doesnโt have interests. Neither does the UK in the sense I mean. Individuals have interests and those vary from house to house, street to street, town to town across Scotland or anywhere else for that matter. You presume your interests are the same as everyone else.
@JamesMacEachern Your version of Scotland perhaps, I certainly donโt support that. Mine is a much broader, cooperative, friendly and open one where the people here are generous, responsible and see the 67M in Great Britain as our own.
@Journojulz Yet we want back into the EU so we can get cheap labour again, keep trade wages down and discourage our own from entering respectable and rewarding careers. Also, I donโt buy that govt decides bit. Society should look after their own without expecting the state to do it.
@KeithWBooth We did that. It was unpleasant. It left us more divided in Scotland than ever before and it was unnecessary (in manyโs view). Can you understand we donโt want to go through unnecessary unpleasantness when poll after poll shows the appetites remain broadly as before?
@Journojulz The UK is more than just whichever persons sit in the House of Commons. Itโs about how the 67M of us rub along individually, collectively and a society full of clubs, groups, families, friends & colleagues together across Great Britain. The politicians of the day are by the by.
@proscot4indy Given the SNP have said leaving the UK was vital, every year for over 80 now, regardless of who formed the UK govt, your argument doesnโt hold. Looking at that context, itโs impossible to avoid a conclusion that Anglophobia drives many of your fellow supporters (maybe not you).