YouTube just demonetized my channel for "Eating Disorder content."
My channel is about paid survey sites.
I have had it for almost 10 years. I review survey sites and other ways to earn a bit of extra money online, with a focus on free methods and realistic advice. The channel has 2,000+ videos and 550,000 subscribers, and not one video, not one, has ever been about eating disorders. Or dieting. Or weight. Or anything within a hundred kilometers of the topic.
I thought it had to be a mix-up, and that maybe they reviewed the wrong channel. So I asked.
They confirmed it was my channel, so I asked them to show me where this eating disorder content is. Their answer: they cannot point to any specific video or moment. But the decision is final and cannot be reviewed again.
Read that again. My income was removed for content that nobody can locate, under a policy that has nothing to do with my channel, and there is no way to appeal it.
The best part? The rejection email helpfully included links to mental health resources and a helpline finder. Clearly, this is just an automated template reply, and no human being has looked at my channel at any point in this process. A human would have noticed within 10 seconds that I review side income methods.
And here is what makes it worse: this is not the first time. In January, YouTube's automated system wrongly flagged my channel and removed videos. Back then, their own Policy team reviewed the case, confirmed the removals were a mistake, and reinstated my videos. I have that in writing. They even promised that any future flags on my channel would be thoroughly reviewed by a human before action was taken, but five months later, this happens.
I have spent 10 years on this platform telling people the truth about survey sites and other free earning methods, including warning them about scams. I have done everything right, and I have helped thousands and thousands of people earn a bit of extra money online and avoid scams.
@TeamYouTube@nealmohan I am asking for the one thing every creator should be able to count on: that a human looks at a channel before its income is removed. Open my channel, look for five minutes, and tell me where the eating disorder content is. If you cannot find it, please reverse the decision.
Hard-working and honest creators deserve to at least have a real human look at their channel.