@sic8686@dontbegaydude@whatifukys You see these types of comments only reside here on X not in serious discourses, when you don't understand Anachronism. You still cannot dispute what I said, all you said it's bad and cope, that doesn't hold up, sorry next.
@sic8686@dontbegaydude@whatifukys No, anyone who studies and understand how to apply moral principles to past eras have fair conclusions. Your conclusion is based on ignorance, which I don't blame you but you need to accept that your opinion is only shared by X users and not in academic circles.
@sic8686@dontbegaydude@whatifukys You didn't really dispute anything I said, you just told me it looks bad which isn't an argument, you opinion is not shared in academia which is why your stance on what is morally acceptable isn't considered outside the sphere of X comments.
@sic8686@dontbegaydude@whatifukys This isn't contentious in academia or between moral/ethical scholars, the markers for marriage were accelerated in 7th century, just like in the future we may extend lifespan by another 100 years and 18 would not meet the markers for marriage since decelerated maturity.
@Stickmann09 Then give me a historical account not a hypothetical, you keep saying counterparts im not concerned about the counterparts. You have to prove to me that they could not afford the jizyah, is there an example in history where they could not afford it and were persecuted for it.
@Stickmann09 Yes to burden them, them being financially unable, next question is whether or not the financially unable were instructed to pay jizyah, this question you cannot escape.
@Stickmann09 We're not talking counterparts we're talking technicalities, and those technicalities are if they are financially able or not. Prove to me that the financially unable had to pay jizyah saar.
@Stickmann09 Remember u said jizyah was to burden the financially unable, find me example of financially unable at the time of the prophet and the salaf that were extracted jizyah. Like why is it taking you so long? This should be at the forefront of your head!