Tafwid for the Ahlulbayt (a) is only in terms of religion and not in creation or sustenance - It is Allah who is the creator of all & provides sustenance to all:
Imam al-Redha (a) was asked, “What do you think about turning over the affairs (tafwid)?”
Imam (a) answered, “The
Another interesting narration on eid prayer:
Imam al-Sadiq (a) says:
“If there are five or more people with the Imam (a) who is present in the city, then it is on them to gather for Friday prayer and the two Eid prayers.”
[Mustadrak al-wasail, Vol.6]
Now interestingly...
Prayer for eid:
Imam al-Sadiq (a) was asked about a man who does not attend the Eid prayer. Should he pray it in his house (furada)?
Imam (a) said: “Yes, and there is no (eid) prayer except with a just Imam (the Prophet or the 12 Imams).”
[Source: Mustadrak al-wasail, Vol.6]
Why do you think your beloved sistani and other maraji rule that friday prayer is completely wajib only with an infallible Imam?
Anyways here's Shaykh al-Tusi stating that, “It is the ijma of Shi'as that friday prayer can only be held with an infallible Imam or his permission.”
Another interesting narration on eid prayer:
Imam al-Sadiq (a) says:
“If there are five or more people with the Imam (a) who is present in the city, then it is on them to gather for Friday prayer and the two Eid prayers.”
[Mustadrak al-wasail, Vol.6]
Now interestingly...
an Infallible Imam (a) which also aligns with the Ahadith which specifically mention the requirement of Just Imam (the prophet & the 12 Imams)
https://t.co/b3r8PhZ62U
Prayer for eid:
Imam al-Sadiq (a) was asked about a man who does not attend the Eid prayer. Should he pray it in his house (furada)?
Imam (a) said: “Yes, and there is no (eid) prayer except with a just Imam (the Prophet or the 12 Imams).”
[Source: Mustadrak al-wasail, Vol.6]
@sayyid_sasuke@shia_aliakbar Our muhadithins beleived with ijma that Friday prayer couldn't be held without the Infallible Imam.
https://t.co/2dhEwEWlvN
Why do you think your beloved sistani and other maraji rule that friday prayer is completely wajib only with an infallible Imam?
Anyways here's Shaykh al-Tusi stating that, “It is the ijma of Shi'as that friday prayer can only be held with an infallible Imam or his permission.”
Prayer for eid:
Imam al-Sadiq (a) was asked about a man who does not attend the Eid prayer. Should he pray it in his house (furada)?
Imam (a) said: “Yes, and there is no (eid) prayer except with a just Imam (the Prophet or the 12 Imams).”
[Source: Mustadrak al-wasail, Vol.6]
@sayyid_sasuke@shia_aliakbar Hurr al-Amali’s understanding is quite weak on this issue. Allahyari’s opinion regarding this is the same as our classical Muhadithin.
Salat al-Eidain:
عن أبي جعفر عليه السلام قال: لا صلاة يوم الفطر والأضحى إلا مع إمام عادل.
Imam al-Baqir (a) said:
“There is neither Salat on the Day of al-Fitar nor on al-Adha except in the presence of a Just Imam (a).”
[Source: Man la yahdr al-faqih, Vol.1, Pg.506]
❌ The prohibition by our master Ali (peace be upon him) to his sons that none of them should rise before al-Mahdi (a), and that whoever among them rises before him will only be doomed:
Amir al-Mominin (a) delivered a sermon in Kufa, saying:
“O people, remain settled upon the
One final hadith narrated by our master Amir al-Mominin (a) on his deathbed 🧵
Asbagh Ibn Nubata entered upon Amir al-Mominin (a) after our master was struck and said, “May I be your ransom, I know fully well that you are proceeding to Paradise. I weep because I will terribly
Those who believe the aim of Imam al-Hussain (a) was to save islam by rising up against yazid, what do you say:
1- Why Imam al-Hussain (a) didn't rise up at the time when muawiya actually started taking bayyah for yazid?
❌ The prohibition by our master Ali (peace be upon him) to his sons that none of them should rise before al-Mahdi (a), and that whoever among them rises before him will only be doomed:
Amir al-Mominin (a) delivered a sermon in Kufa, saying:
“O people, remain settled upon the
@3bdal7ujjah@Allahyarilive No i never said it didn't exist. Rather i said it's from the books of historians which contradicts the hadith of Imam al-Sadiq (a), so it's weak.
@3bdal7ujjah No it's not. Allah imposing strong men on the enemies who shed the blood of Aal Muhammad (s) is not the same as Allah commanding us to rise up to avenge bloodshed of Aal Muhammad (s) [probably refers to al-mukhtar & his group, God knows]