As sweet as this scene was it didn't have the same impact as the scene in the book where he sees her in the hob with too plaits, looking like Louella and how Peeta first new her too
He did, but way too late. And that is exactly why that scene hits.
Snow is paranoid about everyone. That is his whole survival strategy. He trusts no one completely, not even his own Gamemakers. But Plutarch was different.
Plutarch played the loyal Capitol man perfectly. He was rich, he was from an old Capitol family, he threw the parties, he laughed at the right jokes, and he even gave Snow the idea for the Quarter Quell. To Snow, Plutarch was not a rebel. He was the system.
So when the force field blows up, Snow does not think "my Gamemaker betrayed me." He thinks "Katniss did this." He thinks she is the spark, she is the problem, she is the one who ruined his perfect show.
That is Plutarch's genius. He hid the rebellion inside the Games themselves. He made it look like Katniss broke the arena, when really he handed her the wire, he timed the lightning, he made sure Beetee was in the right place. Snow was watching the girl on fire, not the man in the control room.
By the time Snow realizes Plutarch was behind it, Plutarch is already gone, already in District 13, already running the rebellion on TV. That helpless look you see is Snow realizing for the first time that the betrayal did not come from the Districts. It came from inside his own house.
He was not just losing control of Katniss. He was losing control of his own people. And for a man who built his whole life on control, that is terrifying.
What separates SOTR from something as great as Catching Fire to me is that CF allowed its supporting characters to feel important. It allowed every character to breathe and have moments of calmness where we were feeling the weight of these crucial moments.
In SOTR you can actively feel they tried their very best to make it 1:1 exactly, but then in the process of postproduction snipped anything that wasn’t Haymitch-focused. It diminishes Maysilee, Wyatt, Wellie, Lou Lou, and Silka’s story and humanity. Which sometimes in return hurts Haymitch’s own story.
@libush_26@smalltownrobin I'm talking generally for the film. But the aftermath of what happened to Mags and Wiress could have been developed, it really was just a blink and you miss it moment unfortunately. I actually would have preferred they cut the new scene w plutarch and stuck to the books plots
this is such a bad take. this scene is about Maysilee’s resistance, and that’s important to Haymitch’s story because he will draw on Maysilee’s strength and her refusal to ever be silenced to keep painting their poster, he will want to become the worst Victor in history for HER! Maysilee’s arc directly impacts Haymitch’s will to fight!
#sotrspoiler movie / sunrise of the reaping
…
as someone who read the book i think these are the memorable scenes or takeaways that shouldn’t have been change or removed for the film, it made me so sad
@PhntmWhsprs Yes I love these covers! In no way am I looking forward to the film but there's no denying theses illustrations are beautiful and true to the books!
This attempt to make things more fantastical actually makes them less so. The beautiful, solemn absurdity of a lion—the great Lion, but a lion nonetheless—quietly & beautifully singing a world out of darkness is far more strange & magical than this technocosmic overcompensation.