@swierk@stevenstrogatz I am curious, do you see any chance that this could all lead to collapse instead of progress? Of course, this is not guaranteed, but I am tired of people optimistically ushering in the "inevitable" as if it will clearly lead to progress.
@swierk@stevenstrogatz The problem with your automatic transmission driving example is in that case someone knows how it works and can vouch for the reliability. In the AI case, the LLM may be the only one who can vouch for the validity. Then it will be a matter of trust...
@swierk@stevenstrogatz The problem with your statement is your are not thinking carefully about what it means to solve a math problem. As in consider the epistemological problem.
overheard from friends talking about AI in China, and it’s very alarming
- AI short films went massive in China market because of how good the video models are now
- the first wave of people who mastered using AI to generate short films and comics made quite some money because they could produce a lot more content than traditional workflows
- but within just a few months, everybody and their mom could make equally good short films because all the expertise could be written in a markdown file
- when everyone’s more productive, no one actually has an advantage and it’s a race to the bottom. very quickly it became impossible to make money, and everyone’s busier than they were without AI
- the only one making money now is companies like bytedance who owns user demand and distribution. they sell ads to creators who pay to get traffic, and eventually ad spend became 80% of those creators’ operating expense, while AI tokens is less than 5%
so what are the problems here?
1. there’s no moat if you are creating anything with AI
if a human is really good at something, and it’s hard to find more humans who can do the same, they can leverage the scarcity of their skill to get paid very well
but if AI is good at something, it will be infinitely replicated, so there’s no scarcity hence you can’t really expect a sustainable business by creating anything with AI
2. more creators created more content people actually liked. that’s a good thing
but the economical benefit of that all got absorbed by the distribution platforms
there’s a famous chinese poem 遍身罗绮者,不是养蚕人 - it basically says people who dress well aren’t the people making dresses. that’s exactly what’s happening here
if our society doesn’t figure out a better way to distribute wealth, AI will help billionaires become trillionaires while average people become more exhausted than ever
@bramcohen@almogdepaz The difference is you made real money while debugging and probably make loads of money now. We chose our job, knowing we would get paid less, because we loved it. You will accept less money for something you love but not for something ugly. For ugly you need to get paid.
@AlexKontorovich You realize that the things you say are really important are a lot harder to judge now. How do you propose we judge such important things? It used to be that the paper itself could tell you whether the authors understood the results.
Software companies, two years down the line:
We are an artisanal software company. Every line of code is written by humans, by hand, with love and lots of care.
@AriDavidPaul@ryan_c414 If AI replaces 2%ish of jobs, then your argument makes sense. If AI replaces more like 30% of jobs, then your argument does not work. This is what the debate is about and no one really knows the answer.
@AriDavidPaul Seriously, what was the purpose of this tweet? Intentionally manipulating people or are you ignorant enough to think AI companies are curing a type of cancer each week?!
@jdoliner The point is about what should be reasonable to trust. Of course, if you read the AI cancer cure as trustworthy, then the point seems insane. The point is for you to think about what additionally you should want to ensure that the new cancer drug is actually trustworthy.