@SkunkbearAK49@bennyjohnson Actually, religious Jews believe that they are beholden to 613 commandments, while non-jews are beholden to only 7 and will also have a place in the world to come.
@MattPrinciple Breitbart said politics is downstream from culture—the personality/attributes you describe are downstream from the Soul. It is not alien to who you are, it is the essential you. Yes, your attributes are also affected by experiences, but they are not “you” and they can be changed
@MattPrinciple don’t you see it’s important for people to believe they have the ability to transform themselves. That idea itself can be a cause that opens up the possibility of growth (but they still do have to decide to)
@MattPrinciple that their future improving/exceeding expectations is dependent on good luck of what happens to them, what external circumstances shift their life from what it is, won’t ever achieve anything truly great. Even if I can’t get you to believe in it,
@MattPrinciple Why are animal choices so limited, and human choices so expansive? What made someone “choose” to climb mt Everest or “choose” to paint the Mona Lisa.
It’s because our choices move us and open up new choices. We have the capacity for growth.
Our future array of possibilities
@MattPrinciple not just “dumber” than humans, they are fundamentally different. My argument it that that difference is free will. What do you think it is?
@MattPrinciple And what’s their evidence for that? That is a depressing worldview, and I do not see it bear out. Beautiful artwork—in any medium— is highly individual and I cannot imagine predetermined.
The capacity to create speaks to a unique will. Again animals do not have that. They are
@MattPrinciple No, you can not overcome addiction without choice, without will power. It doesn’t just happen to you if your “just that kind of person”
An animal will starve to death before giving up an addiction. Only free will can overcome it.
@MattPrinciple Free will in the simplest form is the ability to choose “other” than the determined action that you would choose based on your genetics/past/circumstances. We can rise above (or sink below) our “destinies”
@MattPrinciple Free will is an amazing gift when used for good and can be a horrible curse when used for evil, but always it carries heavy responsibility!
@MattPrinciple and actually make a real free will decision, against the grain! Like getting over an addiction. I bet an animal has never beat an addiction unless the substance was removed by a human.
Free will is an amazing gift when used for good and can be a horrible curse when used for evil