YOU COULD HAVE JUST ASKED...
An open letter to New Zealand's mainstream media
Dear New Zealand Media,
Well, haven't you been busy!
Our Vote Smart 2026 campaign has generated quite the flurry of media attention over the past couple of weeks. Articles, interviews, television reports, political commentary. We've even made the lead item on the 6pm news. You've interviewed politicians, speculated about who's paying for it all, and devoted plenty of airtime and column inches to what our campaign might mean for Saturday's election.
And yet, amongst all this breathless reporting, something rather obvious seems to have escaped you. You've barely bothered to speak to the people who actually came up with the campaign.
You know, the women running it. Which is funny because, you know, women are all the rage these days...
That would be Claire and me. Hello! We're right here. 👋
Had you bothered to pick up the phone or flick us an email, we'd have happily answered your questions. Instead, we've watched an increasingly tangled narrative about billionaire funding, Electoral Commission complaints and police investigations.
It's rather like watching someone make aeroplane noises while spoon-feeding the public a great big mouthful of mashed-up information, hoping nobody notices what's actually in it.
So, since you haven't shown much interest in asking, allow me to explain a few things.
Vote Smart 2026 ( https://t.co/bsvD0iATPk ) is our campaign. Claire and I conceived it in August, developed the strategy, assembled the team and went looking for funding. A couple of dozen larger donors have contributed $1,000 or more, alongside many other generous supporters.
Yes, Mr Harry Mowbray is one of those donors. His contribution arrived on 18 October, when our campaign was already well underway. Whilst we’re grateful for his donation, it represents approximately 2% of our budget, roughly the cost of one of our 20 full-page newspaper advertisements. He didn't conceive, organise or direct our campaign, and his separate Split Your Vote initiative is exactly that. Separate.
We've spent nearly six years building our own organisations and community networks. More than 16,000 people have contributed financially to our work over that time, and we have over 100 local groups throughout New Zealand.
We didn't need a billionaire to tell us what to think, say, or do.
Now, here's something you might find interesting.
For years, you've had a remarkably narrow vocabulary when describing us. Far-right. Anti-vax. Anti-mandate. Anti-government. Anti-mainstream media.
You've become so accustomed to telling the public what we're supposedly against that you've rarely shown any curiosity about what we're actually FOR.
We believe people should be free to speak their minds, make their own medical decisions, raise their children according to their values, and enjoy the rights and freedoms generations before us fought to protect.
We want decent schools, public services that work, sensible government spending and politicians who make decisions based on evidence and common sense. We value our Kiwi culture, our traditions, property rights and the freedom to disagree without being treated as the enemy.
Surely none of that should be particularly controversial?
Yet somehow, you've managed to spend six years describing us without ever really explaining us.
Perhaps that's why this campaign has caught so many of you off guard. Two women you've spent years dismissing have helped organise 30+ billboards, a million flyers delivered nationwide, 20 full-page newspaper advertisements, a substantial digital campaign, a website, several explainer videos and interactive educational tools, all with the help of a remarkable community of ordinary New Zealanders.
And you've been so busy looking for the mysterious puppet master that you've missed the people standing right in front of you.
Which brings me to the most obvious question of all, and one remarkably few of you have bothered to ask.
Why are we doing this?
To understand our determination, you need to remember the Covid years. We certainly do.
We remember the people who lost their jobs under government mandates, the families torn apart, friendships destroyed and businesses lost. Ordinary Kiwis who felt coerced into medical decisions and people still living with the consequences.
We remember the division, vilification and cruelty directed at those who questioned government policy. And we remember the critical role the mainstream media played in ALL OF IT.
While people were losing their livelihoods, you were often more interested in labelling and ridiculing them than listening to their stories.
And when it was all over, where was the reckoning? The difficult questions? The accountability?
Chris Hipkins and other senior figures from that Labour government have continued their political careers without acknowledging the harm caused. And much of the media has carried on as though nothing happened.
Perhaps you think New Zealanders have moved on.
We haven't. Nor have many of the people whose lives were turned upside down.
That's a large part of why we're fighting so hard.
And before you assume we're cheerleaders for National, we're thoroughly unimpressed with plenty of its decisions too. Our campaign reflects our dissatisfaction with both major parties and our belief that New Zealanders deserve to understand how their votes work under MMP.
You can question our strategy and scrutinise our advertising. Please do. But at least understand what we're doing before telling the country what you think we're up to.
And while we're talking about trust, have you wondered why public confidence in mainstream news has been declining for years? Why independent media has grown? Why RCR exists in the first place?
When important context is omitted, when labels replace genuine inquiry, and when people aren't given a fair opportunity to explain themselves, trust inevitably suffers. You can blame social media and misinformation all you like, but perhaps it's time to examine your own contribution to the problem.
We saw an enormous gap between the questions ordinary New Zealanders were asking and those the established media seemed willing to pursue. So we built something of our own.
Whatever happens on Saturday, we're not disappearing. We've spent six years building our own media platforms, establishing nationwide networks, and learning just what ordinary people can achieve when they stop waiting for someone else to do something. We intend to keep asking uncomfortable questions, challenging those in power, and holding people accountable for decisions that affect our lives and our children's futures.
The thing is, I suspect some of you regard us as a rather unpredictable wild card. A grenade sitting on the table, its pin almost entirely extracted. You don't quite know what to make of us, what we might do next, or how much influence we might have. And perhaps that makes you uncomfortable. I would be, if I were you.
But here's a thought. How about you try talking to us?
You might discover two Kiwi mums who love their country, care deeply about their children's future, and have families and lives they'd quite like to get back to occasionally.
We also have long memories, and we've learned that being dismissed and underestimated can be a remarkably powerful motivator.
There's an old saying about a woman scorned.
Well, I wouldn't underestimate two of them. 😉
Yours sincerely,
Alia Bland
Co-founder, VFF and RCR Media
An Open Letter to the University of Sydney @Sydney_Uni@mscott
Regarding the appointment of Jacinda Ardern as Professor of Practice
Dear Professor Scott,
I read with absolute disgust that the University of Sydney has appointed Jacinda Ardern as Professor of Practice, where she will apparently be sharing her wisdom on empathetic leadership, social cohesion and civic trust.
You cannot be serious.
You are quoted as saying:
"Dame Jacinda led New Zealand through events of profound consequence and her leadership demonstrated that empathy and resolve do not compete with one another; each can strengthen the other."
Appointing Jacinda Ardern to teach social cohesion is rather like appointing Jeffrey Dahmer to teach a course on wellbeing, or Jimmy Savile to run the local daycare centre. The sheer absurdity would almost be funny if the consequences of her leadership weren't so hideously tragic.
My name is Alia Bland. I am a co-founder of Voices for Freedom, an organisation established in New Zealand in 2020. For years, we stood alongside tens of thousands of ordinary Kiwis whose lives were torn apart by the policies of Ardern's government.
While the international media fawned over her kindness and compassion, we were dealing with the wreckage.
At the height of the COVID response, we were receiving upwards of 1,000 emails a day. Desperate people reaching out because they had lost their jobs, their incomes, their homes and, in many cases, their will to live.
People nearing retirement were forced to sell family homes they had spent decades paying off. Some are still living in caravans five years later.
Marriages collapsed. Families fractured. Lifelong friendships were destroyed. People who had served their communities for decades were suddenly treated like lepers because they declined a medical procedure.
Some of the people who came to us had spent their entire lives believing New Zealand was a decent, fair-minded country. Watching that belief crumble, and seeing what it did to them, was heartbreaking.
I cannot adequately describe the anguish in those emails. The desperation of parents wondering how they would feed and house their families. The humiliation of hardworking people being marched out of professions they loved. The despair of people who had done everything society asked of them, only to discover that their own government considered them disposable.
And presiding over it all was Jacinda Ardern, smiling for the cameras and telling the world how kind New Zealand was.
Kind? For whom?
Her government deliberately created a two-class society. Ardern herself acknowledged it publicly. New Zealanders were excluded from workplaces, businesses, events and ordinary social life. People were coerced into accepting a medical intervention under threat of losing their livelihoods.
And those who suffered adverse reactions to the COVID vaccines faced another nightmare. We fought for vaccine-injured New Zealanders whose lives had been devastated by serious physical harm, while many struggled to have their injuries acknowledged or receive adequate support.
The government's public assurances about vaccine safety deserve particular scrutiny. Officials knew about the myocarditis risk, including among young people. We have examined the records. Yet people raising legitimate questions about those risks were routinely dismissed and vilified.
The damage went far beyond lost incomes and broken relationships. An enormous number of New Zealanders lost faith in the very institutions they had trusted their entire lives. Government, health authorities, education, police and the media. That trust has not magically returned because Ardern has moved on to more prestigious surroundings.
While her government was busy marginalising people, we were building a nationwide support network to help them survive.
Voices for Freedom grew to more than 100,000 people on our mailing list, many representing entire families. More than 45,000 people signed up to our local groups across the country, which are still operational today in 2026. We established industry groups to help people fight for their careers, provided support through employment disputes and legal challenges, organised practical assistance and hand-delivered millions of flyers to households throughout New Zealand.
We did this while facing censorship, public vilification and government surveillance. Official records obtained since have confirmed that our activities and communications were being monitored and reported on.
Our volunteers gave everything they could to help people who had been abandoned by the institutions meant to protect them.
And now the University of Sydney wants to hold up the woman responsible for overseeing this period as a shining example of empathy and social cohesion?
It is sickening.
Professor Scott, did anyone at your university bother to speak with the people whose lives were destroyed under Ardern's leadership before celebrating her appointment?
Have you spoken to the former nurses, teachers and police officers who lost their careers? The families who lost their homes? The people still suffering from vaccine injuries? The parents whose children no longer speak to them?
Or did you simply swallow the carefully cultivated international image of Saint Jacinda, the compassionate leader who saved New Zealand?
I wonder whether you have considered why this internationally celebrated former prime minister now lives in Australia rather than the country she once led. The depth of hostility towards her among many New Zealanders should give you pause.
Because I can assure you, there is another side to that story. And there are hundreds of thousands of New Zealanders who live with the consequences.
I have no objection to universities studying Ardern's leadership. In fact, I would encourage it. There is an enormous amount to learn from what happened in New Zealand between 2021 and 2023. Like, what not to do...
But presenting her as someone uniquely qualified to teach empathy, social cohesion and civic trust, without acknowledging the extraordinary human suffering that occurred under her leadership, is an insult to the people who paid the price.
We were there, Professor Scott. We saw what happened. We picked up the pieces. We are still picking them up.
Some of those people will never recover what they lost.
And the woman who presided over it all gets a professorship in empathy.
What an absolute disgrace.
Yours sincerely,
Alia Bland
Co-founder, Voices for Freedom
New Zealand
Over the past week, Health Minister @SimeonBrownMP has proudly celebrated the rollout of a new service allowing midwives to administer multiple vaccines during pregnancy, including COVID-19, influenza, and Tdap.
He says it will make vaccination “easier for families” and help ensure mothers and babies are protected.
After this was floated last year, I asked a straightforward question under the Official Information Act:
What evidence shows it is safe to give these three vaccines together, at the same appointment, to pregnant women?
The answer I received should give New Zealanders pause.
WHAT HEALTH NZ RELIED ON...
They pointed to a 2021 advisory memo and vaccine data sheets. Think about that – 2021 is the BEST they can do.
That memo openly states:
“There are limited clinical trial, observational, or laboratory data on the safety… of coadministration of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine and other vaccines.”
Limited.
Not extensive.
Not robust.
Limited.
Sounds greeeeaaaat.
The memo also acknowledges that trials were still underway and data were not yet available when the recommendation was made.
Instead, the guidance leaned heavily on “immunological principles” and overseas advisory positions.
Translated plainly, that means theoretical reasoning rather than direct evidence of combination safety.
IN EVERYDAY TERMS...
If a doctor prescribes multiple medications, they check interaction data first.
If you buy a baby car seat, it must pass crash testing as a complete product. Ensuring individual parts are safe isn’t enough.
Products designed for babies and pregnant women typically undergo more rigorous safety scrutiny for obvious reasons.
Yet a policy now allows multiple injections during pregnancy, while direct safety evidence for that combination is acknowledged as limited.
ANOTHER LAYER DESERVING ATTENTION...
New Zealand’s own Ministry of Health has previously acknowledged that adverse reaction monitoring systems capture only a portion of real-world reactions.
A Ministry Prescriber Update noted:
“It is estimated that only 5% of all reactions are reported.”
Five percent.
Passive reporting systems depend on patients and clinicians recognising reactions and formally submitting them.
Underreporting is widely documented internationally in pharmacovigilance research.
When officials say that no safety concerns have been identified, that reassurance sits inside those reporting limitations and alongside limited trial data. Most pregnant women would reasonably assume a much higher level of certainty exists.
WIDER ETHICAL TENSIONS
For decades, pregnant women have frequently been excluded from clinical trials because of vulnerability concerns.
Later, those same women are encouraged to accept medical interventions where much of the safety understanding comes from real-world exposure rather than controlled research settings.
I’d bet good money that the comments section of this post will shortly fill with “antivaxxer” slurs and accusations of causing harm.
I stand behind what I am saying here.
This is a recognised debate in modern medical ethics.
It leads to a very uncomfortable question:
Are we protecting pregnant women from research risks, or are we quietly transferring those risks into everyday clinical use without the safeguards that come with formal trials?
INFORMED DECISION-MAKING
Real informed consent exists only when people are given honest information about the benefits, risks, and the limits of what is known.
That includes acknowledging where evidence is strong and where it is still developing.
Pregnant women are being asked to make decisions that affect not just themselves, but their unborn children. That deserves the highest safety standards we can possibly meet. They certainly do not deserve assumptions, convenience, or messaging designed to plaster over uncertainty.
And there is another piece of this conversation that rarely gets airtime.
If a product causes harm, responsibility should sit with the companies that manufacture it. That is how consumer protection normally works. It is how we treat almost every other product placed on the market, especially those intended for vulnerable groups.
When liability is removed from manufacturers, the balance of risk shifts. The public and consumers carry more of that risk, often without realising it.
Women deserve the ability to make fully informed decisions, backed by transparent evidence and products that carry genuine accountability if things go wrong.
Minister Brown is asking pregnant women to place extraordinary trust in government reassurance.
That trust should be earned through rigorous evidence, open disclosure, and accountability when things go wrong.
Right now, women are being encouraged to accept multiple injections during pregnancy while official supporting documents openly acknowledge limited direct safety evidence for that combination. If the Minister is comfortable promoting this policy, he should also be comfortable answering the questions that come with it – clearly and publicly.
Pregnancy is one of the most vulnerable and consequential periods in a woman’s life. Decisions made during those months can shape a child’s health for decades, and the weight of those decisions sits squarely with the woman and her family.
If a product later proves to have been introduced without adequate safety testing, it is parents who live with the outcome every single day. Politicians are not there in the middle of the night. Officials are not the ones carrying the emotional, physical, and financial consequences. Families are.
Confidence and messaging cannot replace honesty, transparency, and clear evidence. Those are the standards people expect when decisions affect their unborn children.
It's an election year. That makes the timing of this push deeply uncomfortable.
Pregnant women should never be dragged into political theatre or used to create the appearance of decisive leadership. When interventions affecting unborn children are promoted while official documents acknowledge gaps in direct safety evidence, we are left questioning whose interests are really being served.
Mothers and babies are not campaign material. Full stop.
Decisions affecting pregnancy require an abundance of caution, honesty, and restraint – qualities that have a habit of disappearing when politics starts driving healthcare messaging.
Mothers are being asked to trust the system.
Trust is earned through evidence and honesty, not political storytelling.
@shouldveknown11 I got horrific migraines when my thyroid was dying. They would last for 3/4 days. Very few since been on thyroid hormone replacement. Maybe get a thyroid panel blood test too ?
🔥🧵 THREAD: THE FALL OF SCHWAB
Why was Klaus Schwab, the godfather of globalism, pushed out of the World Economic Forum after 55 years in charge?
His own staff blew the whistle.
Here’s what they exposed—and why it shatters the Great Reset 👇
1/18
🚨 NEVER FORGET WHAT JACINDA ARDERN DID TO NEW ZEALAND 🚨
Behind the soft tone and polished speeches was one of the most authoritarian crackdowns in modern Western history.
🇳🇿 Under Ardern’s rule:
🛑 Citizens were locked in their homes
🛑 Families were separated by checkpoints
🛑 The unvaccinated were segregated from society
🛑 Protesters — peaceful, brave, and ordinary Kiwis — were beaten, smeared, and silenced
And all of it was wrapped in the language of “kindness.”
But there was nothing kind about medical apartheid.
Nothing kind about crushing dissent.
Nothing kind about turning a democracy into a testing ground for tyranny.
💥 The truth is coming out — and history will not be kind to the Ardern government.
There must be a reckoning.
Because what happened in New Zealand was not just a national tragedy —
It was a blueprint for global control.
📢 We must demand justice.
📢 We must expose the lies.
📢 And we must make sure this NEVER happens again — anywhere.
The world watched New Zealand fall.
Now it must watch it rise — and hold those responsible to account.
THE TRUE BACK STORY TO THIS VIDEO - APPROVAL OF PFIZER MRNA IN NZ.... LONG BUT VERY IMPORTANT READ...
This presentation was filmed the day after Comirnaty Pfizer mRNA injection was granted PROVISIONAL CONSENT in NZ.
The purpose of the video was to announce this consent to the NZ public - and stress the thoroughness of the assessment and SAFETY AND EFFICACY of the product.
Note the highly unusual demeanour of the Group Manager of Medsafe (the authorising drug regulator), Chris James.
His body language is uncomfortable, avoidant and disengaged, with downcast eyes, body blocking with interlaced hands, and frequent deep breaths and swallowing.
FIRST LISTEN IN FULL TO THE 6 MINUTE VIDEO
As these two men assured NZ of the safety and efficacy of the product....THIS is the backstory to the granting of approval:
Medsafe’s clinical assessment found (Pg95):
“The duration of the vaccine protection has not been established beyond two months.”
“At this stage, there is limited evidence of protection against severe disease.”
“There is no long term safety follow-up information.”
“Vaccine prevention of asymptomatic infection and disease transmission has not been established.”
"The benefit risk balance of Comirnaty (COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine) is not clear.
"At this stage, there is evidence only for short-term protection, and LONGER TERM SAFETY DATA ARE LACKING."
Medsafe concluded:
THE BENEFIT/RISK BALANCE OF THE VACCINE WAS NOT CLEAR BECAUSE OF DATA LIMITATIONS (Pg96)
On that basis Medsafe concluded,
“Due to the unresolved concerns and additional quality, safety and efficacy data to be provided at the time of completion of the evaluation,
MEDSAFE IS UNABLE TO RECOMMEND THAT THIS PRODUCT BE GRANTED CONSENT
Medsafe then passed the product application to another drug advisory committee (MAAC)
SEVEN DAYS BEFORE THIS VIDEO Chris James wrote to Pfizer Australia saying:
"Having reviewed the information supplied in your initial application and in your further responses, I AM NOT SATISFIED THAT I SHOULD GIVE MY CONSENT TO THE DISTRIBUTION OF THIS PRODUCT." (Pg119)
MAAC then met on 2 February to consider the application.
The minutes do not record MAAC making ANY INDEPENDENT EVALUATION OF THE BENEFIT/RISK ASSESSMENT.
At this meeting MAAC decided to recommend the Provisional Approval of the Pfizer mRNA vaccine, and they stated (referring to lack of data for elderly, frail, immunocompromised, Maori and Pasifika):
"HOWEVER, THE CLINICAL PICTURE ON EFFICACY AND SAFETY WILL BECOME CLEARER OVER TIME AS MORE PEOPLE RECEIVE THE VACCINE". (pg128)
At the same meeting MAAC noted:
“The data on long terminal half-life of the LIPID NANOPARTICLES was considered unusual but UNLIKELY TO BE A SAFETY CONCERN, AS ONLY TWO DOSES ARE INTENDED TO BE ADMINISTERED". (Pg127)
They also noted:
"The need for more information on potential SAFETY SIGNALS such as reactogenicity, anaphylaxis, vaccine-associated enhanced disease and facial paralysis" (pg129)
In this video the Director General of Health, and the (downcast) Group Manager of the drug regulator Medsafe, knew ALL THIS.... As they performed for the camera and stressed the safety and efficacy of the Pfizer mRNA
(link to minutes in comments)
@TanyaUnkovichMP @winstonpeters@dbseymour@chrisluxonmp@SimeonBrownMP