@FrancisXRocca@holysmoke@Pontifex The scholar Paul Kengor has written extensively on this topic and demolishes a number of myths in doing so.
https://t.co/0WwnGLVFxa
One of the most beautiful lines in Rashi's commentary on the Giving of the Torah is that the Israelites camped at the foot of Mount Sinai, as one person and with one heart (כאיש אחד בלב אחד). Shavuot, like Pesach, is a festival that celebrates and aspires to highlight Jewish unity, mutual responsibility, shared history, experience and vision.
I've spent much of my life, and certainly the past number of years, focused on creating and strengthening shared Jewish literacy and national morale.
That is why it's hard to openly acknowledge the fact that Jewish unity can also be a false god. Just being born a Jew, even an educated Jew, does not give you a pass for any an all actions. If you aid and abet, facilitate or validate, support or refuse to oppose (directly or indirectly) the mass murder of other Jews at the hands of our enemies, then you have forfeited the right to be considered part of the nation.
Judaism acknowledged that need by providing for excommunication of Jews who endanger their brethren. It is a weapon that should be wielded with caution, and warily. Even if not invoked, it reminds us that Jews can be traitors to their people and their faith.
For the information of Peter Beinart, Jewish Voice for Peace, INN, and their choir in the academy and media.
Now that @academic_la has made his debut in Kristoff's column in the @nytimes, here is how distinguished Prof. D. Orbach and respected journalist @amit_segal describes him.