@elonmusk If people want detailed, research based alternative resources to the guidelines that fuel the medicalisation of 'gender dysphoria' they should check out our #GenspectGenderFramework, on our site here: https://t.co/fskmGRTlzC
This is the first draft - we welcome comments!
This cartoon is based on three false assumptions.
1) Basic biology defines sex as XX and XY.
- No, biology defines sex as the phenotypes that produce either sperm or eggs. Chromosomes hold the genetic instructions for sex development, but they are not sex itself.
2) There are chromosome combinations outside of XX and XY that do not result in males or females.
- No, in humans, sex chromosome combinations outside of XX and XY are chromosomal disorders. Because of the genes within the chromosomes, such as the SRY gene in a male fetus or WNT4 and FOXL2 upregulation in a female fetus, the embryo still develops the phenotype that produces either sperm or eggs, even though they may be infertile.
This is because sex determination in mammals is binary. No matter how many Xs or Ys you add, you’ll always get either a male or a female.
3) XX and XY are not the norm.
- No, conception of a fetus involving the mammalian sex determining system of X and Y results in an XX or an XY fetus in the vast majority of conceptions, more than 99%. Anything else is a chromosomal disorder caused by genetic non-disjunction errors or translocations during meiosis.
Transactivist orgs @HRC@TrevorProject@glaad etc profit heavily by promoting this dangerous myth. There is no credible evidence that “gender-affirming care” actually prevents suicide.
Well no, it’s not. For starters, even if a patient reports suicidality, demands medicalization, then reports reduced suicidality, they can’t ever know if they could have overcome suicidality by addressing co-morbid conditions (including anti-depression/anxiety meds, or even psyche hospital stays, if warranted), by engaging in talk therapy with an empathetic therapist, or simply by getting through puberty & experiencing real-life romantic & sexual connections. Any of which would be less invasive than medical interventions solely to address suicidality & each of which is a route preferred by mental & physical health professionals for youth with every reason behind suicidality under the sun — except if the magic of “gender identity” has been invoked.
Here's the full 2017 vid of Rachel Levine (then Pennsylvania Physician General) promoting under-18 transition. Start at 22min; at 28:00, you'll hear Levine promote "accelerating" directly to cross hormones for "street youth." No parents to convince! Despite this evidence ...
Things I wouldn’t have believed could happen 20 years ago. In 2023 there’s a trans activist protest against lesbians and gay men meeting for a social evening. This new style homophobia is just as strange and bigoted as the old one. The @AllianceLGB party was lovely by the way. 👇
5 years ago, I wrote a fact-check of AAP's policy re transition in kids, showing AAP's sources did not say what AAP claimed.
AAP has no response. Not even for mainstream media.
Why oppose a formal, systematic review?
If AAP were right, the review would prove it.
Therefore...?
#tweetiatricans !
Please review my resolution, #37. You can’t comment, because I couldn’t find a member of leadership to sponsor it, but you can read it.
I have 23 FAAP coauthors, so it’s 23 and me this year! I will keep trying.
@AAPNews@AmerAcadPeds Except for my resolution, because I couldn’t get any member of leader ship to sponsor it! You can read it, it’s number 37, but you can’t comment.
I have 23 coauthors, so it’s 23 and me this year!
A grown male who could make his own decisions on his own fertility, believes children who suffer gender dysphoria, don't deserve to have those same choices about their bodies.
Children deserve better!
Doctor Mister First Female Admiral of the US Public Health Service Commissioned Corps Rachel Levine tells educators at the DOE how essential sex changes are for kids.
Is there a single reporter willing to ask @HHS_ASH Rachel Levine why--if "gender-affirming" care is so urgently needed for minors--multiple European countries have now restricted it, citing poor-quality evidence?
Why is the press corps so cowardly and so ill informed?
Ellen Page comes across as a sad and troubled woman.
She has had opportunities that so many have not had - acting esp - and yet, her troubled mindset has led her to a fiction that she is a man and eroded the lovely lesbian she once was.
Isn’t this a form of conversion therapy?
The fact you accept the destruction of children's bodies and women's rights is appalling.
Is this your hill to die on?
You've sold out. The dems have lost my vote over this.
#politicallyhomeless
Last weekend 3, yes three women’s rugby players had to be removed from a game and treated for injuries from hits sustained by a transwoman.
The referee, after repeated dangerous tackles, had to remove the trans player from the game.
The term "cisgender" was coined by a German sexologist who also stated, "The sensuality that spontaneously unfolds between a child and an adult is something wonderful."
Volkmar Sigusch first used the terms "cisgender" and "cissexual" in a 1991 publication titled Transsexuals and our Nosomorphic View.
"Speaking of cissexuals. If there are transsexuals, logically there must be cissexuals. One is not to be thought without the other at all. I have allowed myself to introduce the terms cissexualism, cissexuals, cisgender etc.," Sigusch wrote.
According to Dagmar Herzog, author of Sex after Fascism: Memory and Morality in Twentieth-Century Germany, Volkmar Sigusch and his colleague Gunter Schmidt, with whom he published research on child sexuality in the 70's, also argued that exposing children to pornography – a well-known grooming tactic of pedophiles – was completely harmless.
"Volkmar Sigusch and Gunter Schmidt argued provocatively that the representation of sex, per se, did no damage to youth or children, and that the kind of pornography in which sex was 'represented without prejudices as a pleasure-filled social activity … is exactly the kind that one could without worries give to children and adolescents,'" Herzog wrote.
In the late 60’s and early 70’s, German sexologists began to view sexual relations with children as progressive rather than abusive. So pervasive was the cultural trend towards the social liberation of pedophilia that even Germany’s Green Party advocated for the abolition of Paragraph 176 of the German Criminal Code, which criminalized sexual activity with children below the age of 14.
Dr. Joachim Häberlen of the University of Warwick, in his article, "Feeling Like a Child: Dreams and Practices of Sexuality in the West German Alternative Left during the Long 1970s", says:
"In 1970 members of the German parliament charged with reforming criminal law even listened to radical education scholar Helmut Kentler, sexologist Volkmar Sigusch, and other sociologists and psychologists, who declared that children would not suffer from sexual relations with adults and that those relations should not be punished, because they are a 'crime without a victim.'"
https://t.co/MJlr4ylF4q
https://t.co/IDN2H2VTzI
@Skeptical_Mom@TheAtlantic One of Singal's (published) interviewees, @Jennifer_star, wrote this piece discussing how her mentions of 4thWaveNow were censored. @TheAtlantic deliberately hid the fact that a group of mostly liberal parents had been talking about the issue.
https://t.co/WdUi9Z7j7w