Joe

Film guy. Numbers only lie. I test my evals by betting on football sides & break down film on YouTube. Money Where the Film Is.

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

I'm ready to come out and share my truth.

Tyler Shough is awesome. This guy is a bona fide first-overall pick. He would have been my QB2 in 2024, behind only Drake Maye.

Yeah, he's old. Don't care. his development isn't maxed out. He's played less than Ward or Sanders.

QB1

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@Brockenheimer Because you shot me! 😅

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@TFG_Football Fair. But kyler was also a disaster throwing downfield last year.

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@Owen_Bard_Clips Right.
But I did watch every snap. And I graded them all. And I post the notes and charts I make from watching all that film.

And I just gave you a link to a playlist of 8 videos where I break down every fucking snap of 8 different games on all 22.

So. Try again.

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

The most accurate evaluation of caleb williams.
And exactly what I said pre-draft.

Caleb is a taller Kyler Murray with worse accuracy issues.

[Ben Devine @Chicago_NFL]

On his podcast, @markschlereth flat out says “Caleb Williams is not a good quarterback.” Then comps him right now to Kyler Murray. 😳 Thoughts?
#DaBears

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@LeMansVictory @RapidResponse47 My laptop will be fixed and returned to me by HP on July 10th. Then the pods begin.

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

If you eliminate all of the routine throws - screens, flats, checkdowns, etc - 2025's Kyler Murray was almost exactly average in terms of accuracy.

[VikingzFanPage @vikingzfanpage]

Kyler Murray had the highest accurate throw rate in 2025:

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@Brockenheimer Why are you mad that I am lazy

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

We're number 1 you're not even top 3 or 5

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

If only Marv had a real QB.
Kyler Murray suffocated Marvin Harrison Jr.'s production to death but Vikings fans think he will save them 🤣

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@Owen_Bard_Clips So like these 8 videos breaking down every snap of 8bdifferent games..?
https://t.co/b12xB5JJiO

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@MrMichaels312 If you want to simply count individual wins and losses, switch to tennis

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@getfree31 Well his NFL tape has been pretty awful, but I still have hope he can beckme what I saw at USC.

Which was still a lot worse than his reputation indicated, but pretty good.

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@CHITOWNALLLDAY Pca was trash for about 400 days
Now he's god
What does that have to do with Caleb Williams?

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

People forget just how all-time Tyreek Hill was

[Kalshi Sports @KalshiSports]

What's the best WR performance of the last decade?

Jaxon Smith-Njigba looks to repeat as the Receiving Yards leader in 2026, and Kalshi traders are giving him a 19% chance to do so.

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@BearsBarroomHQ @SleeperNFL @SleeperBears @bearszn It's super easy to figure out intended routes and how they're intended to be run.
I show my work, too.

Caleb Williams Breakdowns: https://t.co/Mt1bIXLY3r

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@vikingzfanpage Now eliminate screens

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

@PattonAnalytics Caleb Williams is a lot like Kyler Murray?
Now where have I heard that before...

[Steven Patton @PattonAnalytics]

"[Caleb Williams] is Kyler Murray with more hype"

[Joe @JoeA_NFL]

That's right
And this is why I always say the Arizona Cardinals don't actually exist. No one has ever seen them play.

[NFL Rumors @nflrums]

🚨🚨 #Cardinals' Trey McBride says "there's no Arizona fans in Arizona."

"Living in Arizona, you know, no one’s from Arizona. Everyone has moved in from another state, so they’re all fans of their own team. It’s a tough deal."