If a person is afraid of dogs, they have the right to quickly try to get away — especially in the tight quarters of an elevator. It is not a justification for the dog running toward them, barking ferociously, and knocking into them. If the owner does not have control, that person is liable.
A dog owner is responsible for the dog’s behavior. Ferocious barking alone in a confined space is reason enough not to bring the dog — elevators offer nowhere to retreat, which is exactly why service and therapy dogs are specially trained and screened for calm dispositions. This dog is not that. A muzzle does not stop a large dog from knocking someone down.
People fear dogs for legitimate reasons: previous bites, childhood trauma, religious upbringing, or the danger itself. The CDC recorded eighty-one U.S. deaths from being bitten or struck by dogs in twenty twenty-one. Someone confronting a charging dog does not owe its owner a demonstration of composure. Retreat is a foreseeable response, especially in tight quarters.
The law recognizes that serious dog injuries do not require teeth. In Farrior versus Payton, women fell escaping a charging German shepherd without being bitten or touched; the court held the evidence warranted jury consideration. In Missouri in twenty twenty-one, a man settled for one hundred forty thousand dollars after retreating from a neighbor’s dog and breaking his hip without contact. A Stockton case settled for two hundred twenty-five thousand after a chained dog lunged, a man stepped backward, fell, and fractured his hip. In Pauszek versus Waylett, twenty nineteen, prior lunging and notice supported allowing a fright-induced fall claim to proceed. In Gloucester in twenty twenty-four, an escaped one-hundred-twenty-pound dog knocked down an elderly pedestrian, fracturing her hip and femur; the settlement was five hundred thousand dollars. An office-building parking garage case settled for one million after an unleashed dog caused a woman to strike her head on a brick wall.
Those settlements imposed financial consequences. Accuracy also requires acknowledging McGrellis versus Bromwell, twenty twenty: the owners won because foreseeability was not established. Responsibility must be proved, not assumed.
Criminal consequences exist too. California Penal Code section three ninety-nine addresses serious injuries caused by known mischievous animals allowed loose or kept without ordinary care. Maine’s twenty nineteen law makes leaving a qualifying dog assault without fulfilling aid and identification duties a crime.
Apply the personal test: if an uncontrolled dog charged your terrified parent, child, or spouse in an elevator and knocked them down, would you laugh — or look for a very good lawyer? The person’s religion is irrelevant to negligence. Mocking their fear does not excuse the owner’s failure to control the dog.
If you cannot control your dog, do not bring it where people are trapped with it.
@garyblack00 Agreed on premium risk, Gary. But the key is what our stake is worth versus staying separate, not the announcement-day premium alone. No Tesla–SpaceX ratio is announced. What ownership split and downside protections would make it attractive to you?
Ed Elson: inflated shares can make a premium misleading. But non-voting merger shares are your scenario, not announced terms. An S-4 must disclose material changes in shareholder rights. Would you reassess after seeing the actual ratio, rights and downside cases?
Scott Galloway: 'rescue' isn't the only model. ARK’s Winton projects Tesla holders ~1.6x better off by 2031 and ~5x by 2036 versus no merger, at Oct 21 price ratios. SpaceX also gains in his model. Conditional forecasts, not proof. Which assumptions fail your test?
Steve Eisman: complexity is real, but Tesla already supplies SpaceX Megapacks ($626m in Jan–Sep sales). China exposure exists today; combining firms shares that risk, not erases it. Why reject a deal before weighing quantified synergies against added complexity?
Ten reasons for SpaceX to merge with Tesla.
One AI research team instead of two, sharing compute, data, and breakthroughs in real time. Two. One chip roadmap — the same silicon powering cars, robots, and spacecraft. Three. One energy grid feeding factories on Earth and compute in orbit. Four. One launch cadence serving one constellation serving one autonomous fleet. Five. One balance sheet funding the hardest engineering problems without duplicate overhead. Six. One supply chain for batteries, solar, and advanced materials across every platform. Seven. One cybersecurity and encryption standard protecting vehicles, satellites, and ground systems together. Eight. One talent pool — engineers moving freely between terrestrial and space projects. Nine. One regulatory strategy navigating air, space, and ground rules as a single voice. Ten. One long-term mission — making life multiplanetary with a self-sustaining industrial base behind it.
Petition link: https://t.co/ujxFTSCsVS
Most of the world does not have this tax. Petitioning is the practical move if you want to avoid it, because the merger is likely to pass once enough people vote. Signing gives you a real shot at the deferral.
스페이스X가 테슬라와 합병해야 할 열 가지 이유.
하나. 두 팀이 아닌 하나의 AI 연구팀 — 컴퓨팅, 데이터, 혁신을 실시간으로 공유. 둘. 하나의 칩 로드맵 — 자동차, 로봇, 우주선을 움직이는 동일한 실리콘. 셋. 지구 공장과 궤도 컴퓨팅을 모두 공급하는 하나의 에너지 그리드. 넷. 하나의 자율주행 함대를 서비스하는 하나의 성좌를 담당하는 하나의 발사 주기. 다섯. 중복 비용 없이 가장 어려운 엔지니어링 문제를 자금 조달하는 하나의 대차대조표. 여섯. 모든 플랫폼에 걸쳐 배터리, 태양광, 첨단 소재를 위한 하나의 공급망. 일곱. 차량, 위성, 지상 시스템을 함께 보호하는 하나의 사이버보안 및 암호화 표준. 여덟. 하나의 인재 풀 — 지상과 우주 프로젝트 간 자유롭게 이동하는 엔지니어. 아홉. 항공, 우주, 지상 규칙을 하나의 목소리로 조율하는 하나의 규제 전략. 열. 하나의 장기 미션 — 자급자족하는 산업 기반을 갖춘 다행성 삶의 실현.
청원 링크: https://t.co/ujxFTSCsVS
대부분의 세계는 이 세금을 부과하지 않습니다. 사람들이 투표하면 합병이 통과될 가능성이 높기 때문에, 과세를 피하고 싶다면 청원하는 것이 현실적인 방법입니다. 서명하면 과세 이연에 대한 실질적인 기회를 얻을 수 있습니다.
한국 주주님들께: 테슬라-스페이스X 합병 시 주식 교환만으로 미실현 이익에 22% 양도소득세가 부과될 수 있습니다. 미국이나 다른 나라와 달리 한국만 이 제도가 없어서, 주식을 실제로 팔지 않았는데도 세금을 내야 하는 불공평한 상황입니다. 국회 국민동의청원에서 조세특례제한법 개정을 요구하고 있으니, 한국 투자자 여러분의 동의와 서명이 필요합니다. 링크는 https colon slash slash petitions dot assembly dot go dot kr slash proceed slash onGoingAll slash 5CE947CCAE0B43A2E064B49691C6967B 입니다. 동의 기한은 다음 달 21일까지입니다. To Korean shareholders: if Tesla and SpaceX merge, a simple share swap could trigger a 22 percent capital gains tax on unrealized gains. Unlike the US and most other countries, Korea has no deferral for overseas stock reorganizations, so you’d owe tax on shares you never sold. The National Assembly e-petition is asking to amend the Special Tax Treatment Control Act to fix this. Your agreement and signature are needed. The link is https colon slash slash petitions dot assembly dot go dot kr slash proceed slash onGoingAll slash 5CE947CCAE0B43A2E064B49691C6967B. The agreement window closes November twenty-first.
We all need to be united on this. The merger is going to happen — discouraging shareholders who won’t be taxed doesn’t protect anyone. Getting on the petition for the tax exception is the constructive move, and it’s the best way for both companies to thrive without punishing long-term holders.
한국 주주님들께: 테슬라-스페이스X 합병 시 주식 교환만으로 미실현 이익에 22% 양도소득세가 부과될 수 있습니다. 미국이나 다른 나라와 달리 한국만 이 제도가 없어서, 주식을 실제로 팔지 않았는데도 세금을 내야 하는 불공평한 상황입니다. 국��� 국민동의청원에서 조세특례제한법 개정을 요구하고 있으니, 한국 투자자 여러분의 동의와 서명이 필요합니다. 링크는 https colon slash slash petitions dot assembly dot go dot kr slash proceed slash onGoingAll slash 5CE947CCAE0B43A2E064B49691C6967B 입니다. 동의 기한은 다음 달 21일까지입니다. To Korean shareholders: if Tesla and SpaceX merge, a simple share swap could trigger a 22 percent capital gains tax on unrealized gains. Unlike the US and most other countries, Korea has no deferral for overseas stock reorganizations, so you’d owe tax on shares you never sold. The National Assembly e-petition is asking to amend the Special Tax Treatment Control Act to fix this. Your agreement and signature are needed. The link is https colon slash slash petitions dot assembly dot go dot kr slash proceed slash onGoingAll slash 5CE947CCAE0B43A2E064B49691C6967B. The agreement window closes November twenty-first.
We all need to be united on this. The merger is going to happen — discouraging shareholders who won’t be taxed doesn’t protect anyone. Getting on the petition for the tax exception is the constructive move, and it’s the best way for both companies to thrive without punishing long-term holders.
@StarLight_Tsla 별빛 means “starlight” in Korean. South Korean shareholders would eat a capital gains hit that American holders wouldn’t, so of course an account based there wants the merger delayed or derailed. That’s not analysis, that’s self-interest dressed up as shareholder wisdom.
1/ Where "engineers would laugh at Musk" comes from: Alex Gibney, director of the four-hour HBO documentary "Musk," promoting his film on CBS's The Takeout (Oct 1). Before the quote, consider the source.
2/ Gibney is not a neutral observer. He's built a career making films that take down powerful people.
3/ His own words on Musk: a "bullsh*tter" who "serially inflated his role." He says Musk's companies succeed "despite him, not because of him." He calls him "the greatest stock pumper."
4/ This is an open feud. Musk has called Gibney a crackpot and a bitter old man, and calls the film a hit piece. Musk's lawyer, Alex Spiro, has threatened a defamation suit.
5/ The film's most disputed claim is Ashley St. Clair's account of a Musk text about "10,000 lasers in space" before the 2024 election, implying Starlink rigged the vote. PolitiFact, https://t.co/7k1g6Yla6n, and election officials debunked that in 2024. Starlink wasn't connected to vote counting, and "lasers in space" describes how Starlink satellites link to each other. Gibney's defense is that the film only "raises questions."
6/ Spiro says the production refused to fact-check with Musk's team. Gibney says Musk declined to be interviewed.
7/ The record: Musk has been SpaceX's chief engineer since 2002, and Ars Technica calls him SpaceX's "chief executive officer and lead designer." SpaceX deliberately has essentially no rocket patents. Musk told Wired in 2012 that publishing them would be "farcical, because the Chinese would just use them as a recipe book." His record is flight hardware, not a patent file.
8/ Falcon 1: Musk was its chief engineer, "by default," he says, because "nobody good would join." In his words, "I messed up the first three launches." The fourth, in 2008, made Falcon 1 the first privately developed liquid-fueled rocket to reach orbit. He learned the field from textbooks lent by early SpaceX executive Jim Cantrell, who says Musk "would quote passages verbatim."
9/ He has explained the hardware in public detail. In 2012, he described the friction-stir-welded airframe, which cut the ratio of material bought to material flown from 10–20 down to about 1.1. In 2017, it was the single-piece cast titanium grid fins that "can be reused indefinitely with no touch ups." In 2018, it was Block 5's stronger Octaweb engine mount and titanium heat shield.
10/ Now Gibney's full answer: "He hires great engineers. As one person in the film who helped start SpaceX with him says, he's a good engineer, but he was never a trained engineer. And I talked to people at Tesla or SpaceX who, when I said, 'Is he a great engineer,' they would sometimes laugh out loud.
11/ But that said, he knows enough about engineering to be able to talk to engineers in the language that they can understand. So I wouldn't underestimate him in that regard. But to think that he's an inventor is wrong. He's an investor, and a stock pumper, who made a fortune."
12/ The "people at Tesla or SpaceX" who "would sometimes laugh out loud" are anonymous. Even this critic admits Musk is "a good engineer" who speaks engineers' language. The record shows a great one: specific technical calls Musk made that were overruled at first and later proven right, documented by the engineers themselves.
13/ Merlin 1D, around 2011: Musk pushed the face-shutoff injector over Tom Mueller's objection. Mueller: "Now we have the lowest-cost, most reliable engines in the world. And it was basically because of that decision."
14/ Starship, 2018: he switched from carbon fiber ($135/kg, 35% scrap) to 301 stainless steel. Musk: "It took me quite a bit of effort to convince the team." They ran the numbers, and steel won.
15/ Dec 30, 2020: he proposed catching Super Heavy with the tower arms, with no landing legs. Mechazilla has since caught boosters.
@davidellison@elonmusk@Skydance "Engineers would laugh at Musk" is from Alex Gibney: takedown filmmaker, open Musk feud, debunked Starlink claim. Record: SpaceX chief engineer since 2002. First private liquid rocket to orbit, 2008. Mueller on his call: "the lowest-cost, most reliable engines in the world."
16/ Gibney says "to think that he's an inventor is wrong." The patent record says otherwise. Musk is a named inventor on patents, and a patent is by definition an invention: Zip2 maps-and-directions patents (1999–2000), the Tesla charge inlet, Model S door and body design patents, and Smart Summon (co-inventor with Andrej Karpathy). He's also a listed author of Neuralink's 2019 paper, and he wrote Hyperloop Alpha.
17/ Raptor: Mueller started it. By 2019, Mueller said "Elon and the Propulsion department are leading development... particularly Raptor." It's a full-flow staged combustion engine.
18/ Hiring is an engineering skill too. He found Mueller in a rented warehouse, brought Straubel to Tesla, hired Karpathy for Autopilot vision, and made Shotwell his No. 2.
19/ Neuralink, founded 2016: first human implant in January 2024. Patients control computers and robotic arms by thought. Blindsight has an FDA breakthrough device designation.
20/ Blastar at 12 (1984), a Space Invaders-style game he sold to a magazine for $500, which published the code.
21/ At 17, a University of Pretoria aptitude test gave him A+ in Operating and Programming. His mother says they retested him because they'd never seen a score that high.
22/ He doesn't do it alone (Mueller, Straubel, Karpathy). He makes the hard calls, and they hold up. People call him the father of reusable rockets and of the modern EV industry. No one is laughing at Musk's engineering skills.
@elonmusk Grok Ai:
The Aventador SV matches the Cyberbeast at ~2.6 seconds, while the Aventador S is slower at ~2.8 seconds.
The Cyberbeast’s 2.6-second time is impressive for a ~6,900-lb truck, but the ~3,500-lb Aventador SVJ’s lightweight design gives it a marginal edge.
@IvankaNews_ Design or propose a system for full medical coverage for all U.S. citizens, regardless of age, using taxes to directly fund healthcare providers and treatments—bypassing insurance companies and their incentives to deny care or impose high copayments.
@alex_gayer Autopilot in my Tesla made our
1,100 mile round trip compelling instead of draining. My wife and I were not tired when we arrived at our vacation destination, as was true when we returned home from the trip.