"A time will come when men will go mad, and when they see a man who is not mad, they will attack him and say, You are mad. You are not like us." ~ St Anthony The Great
The ongoing troubles in ODM provide for a good backdrop to discuss that matter we were supposed to respond to last week; the fake narrative of "sidelining of Luos within Linda Mwananchi".
The narrative has three faces;
1. The inability of many Luo leaders to acknowledge that they too can belong to a party led by someone who is not from their community. The Luo and the Kikuyu share the dubious distinction of always being restless in a party not led by one of their own. After Jaramogi died, Wamalwa Kijana took the reigns of Ford Kenya in 1994, but the Luo were gone by the very next election in 1997.
They stayed in NDP until it was folded in a merger with Kanu in 2000. They then stayed in New Kanu only until 2002, when they staged a mass walkout into NARC. But in NARC, the honeymoon lasted only a few months before they identified as LDP and shortly, ODM. The community then remained peaceful in ODM for two decades, as long as Raila was boss.
After Raila's death, Luo leadership has failed to acknowledge that many many communities followed Raila unconditionally for those twenty years, and these communities too expect that when the baton is passed on after Raila's death, Luo leaders will also line up behind other people. But now, many of these leaders would rather move around with envelope parties rather than join big parties led by others.
2. The vicious anti-Kikuyu politics now practiced by characters in the broad-based framework. The statement "Luos are sidelined in Linda Mwananchi" is not actually complete. Its complete form has many variations, including "in preference to Kikuyu girls" or "in preference to Rigathi Gachagua".
This part of the narrative, for months, was run in Luo Nyanza to paint Sifuna as a Kikuyu lover and therefore "not good for Luos". Elements loyal to some Luo leaders and to the broad-based framework were carefully placed in positions where they would remain purveyors of the "anything but Gachagua" message, and raise false alarms whenever Linda Mwanachi appeared to bridge the manufactured gap with the mountain.
Then that Berlin Wall constructed by Ruto and his broad-based partners was demolished on Mashujaa Day when Sifuna popped up at Wamunyoro. Those who had been singing that if he met Gachagua, he would have crossed the red line, were left with the option of doing their worst. But it turned out they had no worst to do. That narrative has now drowned in its own urine.
3. But if you are looking for the real sidelining and marginalisation of Luos, look no further than the UDA-ODM partnership. It is those ones who have publicly said that there is no Luo alive today who is fit enough to be President. It is they who have also surrendered the DP role. In their thinking, the highest seat a Luo will settle for is either county Governor or Senator. The party leader will run for Senate. The party chair will run for Governor. And they are crying for written guarantees and zoning to even survive those contests.
By reducing Raila's party to a tribal operation oscillating between Luanda Kotieno and Wath Ong'er, no one has sidelined the Luo community more than the people who took up ODM leadership after Raila. They practically removed the community from the national high table where Raila left it, to a tiny stool perched beside the Olare-Rangwe Road, where Ruto can deliver crumbs once in a while, as his fake wisdom is cheered by a panga-wielding Abdi Sebo.
There is no way any community, least of all the Luo, can be sidelined in Linda Mwananchi, because no one joined the movement by tribe. Neither is there a tribal register where marginalisation can be dished out by surname. Those who cite this narrative neatly fall into one of these three categories.
Which is why that story of Luos being sidelined in LMM must be returned to sender in a sealed yellow envelope.
🚨Paul Scholes on Manchester United’s humiliating 3-0 defeat to Bournemouth:
🗣️ Paul Scholes: “This is the lowest of the low. Honestly, this is one of the most embarrassing runs I have witnessed in Manchester United’s history. I’ve seen this club go through difficult periods, but what we’re watching under Michael Carrick is becoming impossible to defend.
“Of course, you don’t expect the board to come out and say this is just another day at the office, because a second heavy defeat on the bounce cannot be just another day in the office. Someone has to answer.”
“Carrick understands what Manchester United means to the supporters, which makes this even more frustrating. He knows the standards, he knows the expectations, yet he’s taking this club in the wrong direction. At this point, I genuinely believe he’s one step away from losing his job.
“His signings have been utterly disappointing, and his obsession with this midfield pivot is absolute nonsense. Santos and Baleba, with Tielemans playing as a number 10? What exactly are we trying to achieve here?
“When I saw Bruno Fernandes on the bench, I burst out laughing. Carrick thinks establishing control means dropping his most productive player! Bruno speaks up, he gets benched. Cunha shows his frustration, he gets benched. Martinez reportedly has fitness issues, yet the timing of his absence raises questions after he spoke about the ownership and the coach.
“This isn’t discipline. This is a manager who appears to be confusing authority with control. You cannot keep punishing players and expect the football to improve. Carrick is making decisions to show who’s in charge instead of making decisions that give Manchester United the best chance of winning.
“And Bournemouth came to Old Trafford and played United off the park! Evanilson kept finding pockets of space behind Maguire and Heaven, and our defenders looked completely lost. Heaven had an absolute disaster of a game. Yoro was having a decent afternoon until one crucial moment exposed him, and United were punished. That’s football at this level: one moment can tell you whether a player is ready for the responsibility.
“But where was the organisation? Where was the response? Where was the manager changing anything to stop the damage? We looked like a team waiting for somebody else to solve its problems.
“I don’t think Carrick should come out to apologise. An apology won’t fix this. I think he should seriously consider handing in his resignation because the supporters deserve better, the players deserve better, and this football club deserves better.
“Losing 4-1 to Como in the Champions League was already humiliating, but losing 3-0 to Bournemouth at Old Trafford is a different level of disgrace. You cannot keep embarrassing this club and expect the supporters to accept another speech about learning lessons. How many lessons does one manager need before we admit he may not be capable of doing the job?”
“Michael Carrick has to take responsibility. Not the players he has benched, not the referees, not bad luck. HIM. He picked the team, he made the decisions, and he watched Manchester United collapse at home.
“If he believes he can turn this around, then he needs to show us something immediately. Because right now, I’m struggling to see a plan, an identity, or a reason to believe things will improve.
“Manchester United is not a club where you learn how to manage at the expense of millions of supporters. If Carrick cannot handle the pressure, he should walk away before he causes any more damage. This club made him who he is in football, and the least he can do is recognise when his decisions are hurting it.”
🚨Peter Schmeichel on Michael Carrick��s starting XI against Bournemouth:
🗣️ Peter Schmeichel: “I’m looking at this lineup, and you feel like crying for Manchester United. Bruno Fernandes is arguably your best player, yet he’s on the bench. Cunha is there too, while Martinez, Mainoo and Sesko are unavailable. Honestly, it’s utter bollocks!
“After Bruno’s outburst, I expected Carrick to sit down with him and sort things out privately. Ask him what the problem is. If Bruno speaks, you have a player you can work with. But dropping your best player in a high-stakes game when United are struggling for consistency? That’s a massive risk.
“And Bournemouth can absolutely hurt this team. They can press aggressively, win second balls and attack the spaces United leave behind. If United lose control of midfield, who dictates the tempo? Who finds that killer pass? Bruno is usually the man who does those things, and he’s sitting on the bench!
“Cunha being there as well makes it even more questionable. He can carry the ball, trouble defenders and create something out of nothing. If United struggle to break Bournemouth down, Carrick may find himself turning to the very players he decided not to start.
“The biggest danger is Bournemouth scoring first. Imagine the atmosphere at Old Trafford if United go behind, the crowd starts asking for Bruno, and Carrick has to bring him on to rescue a game he could have started. Suddenly, this isn’t just a tactical decision anymore; it’s a decision that could come back to haunt the manager.
“I’m also looking at that defense and wondering how comfortable United will be if Bournemouth start running at them. If the midfield loses possession and the back line gets exposed, United could spend the afternoon defending instead of controlling the game. You cannot afford to give a confident Bournemouth side that much encouragement.
“Carrick has to remember that picking a starting XI isn’t about proving who’s in charge; it’s about giving your team the best chance to win. If this lineup struggles, the pressure will be enormous, and every minute Bruno spends on the bench will become another question directed at the manager.
“Nobody is bigger than Manchester United, not even Bruno Fernandes. But there is a difference between showing authority and weakening your own team to prove a point. Carrick has made his decision, and now he has to live with it.
“This could turn into a disaster afternoon for Michael Carrick. Bournemouth won’t care about the politics inside United. They’ll simply exploit every weakness they see and if Carrick gets this wrong, the questions after the game will be brutal.”
Arsenal finished 8th back to back, were struggling to even qualify for the Europe league & we’re the biggest laughing stock
Today, they are the defending PL champions, reached a champions league final & are a top 3 in the world
That’s why I still believe that Manchester United will rise again one day
The pain will make the success sweeter in the end.
Jordan Henderson is exactly who England needed on the pitch to hang onto the lead in the World Cup semi finals. Calm under pressure and picks the whole team up around him no matter who he’s playing for!
That's the start Xabi Alonso will have wished for after their last loss against Brentford, but it's not over yet that game because Chelsea do look leaky.