@cassie_walker19@CarlaHartley13@GuntherEagleman Like in Matthew 25:31-46, many professing Christian will get an unpleasant surprise. You warn them, but they're stuck in the materialism of this world "just like in the days of Noah."
@CarlaHartley13@GuntherEagleman Ownership is a bundle of rights including right to disposition, which the stewards did not have.
America isn't Israel, which all the more meant God didn't grant anyone the right to ownership. But here you are a Christian declaring that there are kings to land.
@CarlaHartley13@GuntherEagleman Are you sure you know your Bible? See, the 11 tribes were stewards of their respective areas but never could sell the land. Land in Israel can only be had for lease. Jubilee made sure that land always returned to the stewards and never sold.
@ABujnicki@Ricardo_Venator@DanSull36510584@cassie_walker19@prolibertypod Well, equal participation is not the same thing as equal standing, is it?
A cage match gives everyone an equal chance to fight, but it does not treat people as moral equals. It treats physical strength, luck, or violence as morally decisive.
@ABujnicki@Ricardo_Venator@DanSull36510584@cassie_walker19@prolibertypod Who said voting? It means no one has a superior original claim to natural opportunities. Therefore allocation rules must be justifiable to persons regarded as equals. Auctions on rents are one possible implementation.
@ABujnicki@Ricardo_Venator@DanSull36510584@cassie_walker19@prolibertypod A moral claim means your interests cannot simply be ignored when determining the rules governing access to natural opportunities. It does not mean every resource is your property, or every use requires your permission. (1/3)
@ABujnicki@Ricardo_Venator@DanSull36510584@cassie_walker19@prolibertypod A moral claim means your interests cannot simply be ignored when determining the rules governing access to natural opportunities. It does not mean every resource is your property, or every use requires your permission. (1/3)
@ABujnicki@Ricardo_Venator@DanSull36510584@cassie_walker19@prolibertypod None of those require co-ownership of every resource.
If you answer why does "having a claim" necessarily mean "having an ownership claim", we'll have a better discussion. That's the premise you've been assuming throughout the debate and not demonstrating.
(3/3)
@ABujnicki@Ricardo_Venator@DanSull36510584@cassie_walker19@prolibertypod Thus a moral claim means no one may claim a superior original entitlement merely because they arrived first.
It may include a right to participate in the allocation process, to bid, to equal consideration, to compensation when excluded, to challenge arbitrary favoritism.
(2/3)