@SteevesMrs @ShelfieTalk A5. I totally agree with you. Students don't always talk about how they are treated outside the classroom/school. These stories did a fantastic job of giving us a different perspective about our students' feelings/past experiences. #shelfietalk
@ShelfieTalk A6. I loved how some of the stories disguised the fact that the author was the one who didn't feel they belonged. Like in "The Memory Fish", the earthling was the one that didn't fit in among the aliens. That was a unique and interesting idea! #shelfietalk
@ShelfieTalk A4. I would let students choose which story they want to read and then have them get into groups and share a summary of the story. They could find common themes/ideas within those stories. And even after, get the students to write their own story of belonging/or not #shelfietalk
@ShelfieTalk A3. Maybe because we are so close the March Break. ;) : "In Jamaica, the sunlight calls for attention, the dust and dirt of country roads call for attention. The man calling out on the roadside asking you to buy from him sweet, slices of pineapple or the water ..." #shelfietalk
@ShelfieTalk Q2- I love how each story shows its point of view of how a person may not belong, yet each is written so differently. It's nice to read several short stories with a common theme. #shelfietalk
Q8. I had not read any other books in verse, but have written down recommendations from others. I really really enjoyed "The Name She Gave Me". #shelfietalk
@Lori_JonesClark Yes! I agree with you. When you take away the pressure of writing for marks, students can let themselves go and let the creativity flow! #shelfietalk
Q6. Also, the words are chosen carefully in verse. So it makes the shorter pages and paragraphs have a bigger impact, and remains meaningful. #shelfietalk
I had not read a story like this on, written in verse. I found it was easy and quick to read. Students who may not enjoying reading long novels, may appreciate a book such as this one. They can also quickly go back to find information they may have missed. #shelfietalk
Q5. It made me think about how much we just don't know about our students' lives. We often only get a glimpse of what they are willing to share at a surface level. Theymay have so much more they are willing to share when given the chance, and when they feel safe. #shelfietalk
@MrsCSoucy I agree with you. It took me a little while before I could understand how/why Rynn was analyzing words and syllables, and finding meaning of words.#shelfietalk
Yes! I loved this one too. Especially coming from a teenager/ Rynn's point of view. Many never feel like they truly belong at that age, even without being adopted.
#shelfietalk A3 pg 36 Because thereβs one thing we have in common - we both ended up places where no matter what we do, weβll never truly belong. #shelfietalk
A2. Rynn's special connection with her father vs the cold relationship she has with her mother. And also how she continues on to find answers, no matter what she faces. #shelfietalk