@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 sure, and germans still criticize their government every day and vote it out when they want. a dumb insult law isn't a gulag. this is getting ridiculous, you went from "capitalism doesn't work" to german insult laws. you're out of arguments and it shows
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 and you just called the president a demented fraudster in public with zero consequences. try that about kim jong un in pyongyang. every free democracy on earth runs on markets. not one runs on your system
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 every country that tried it became an autocracy. every single one, on every continent, for 100 years. at some point you have to ask why instead of just renaming them
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 no. funny you picked north korea though: no private profit, state runs everything, and in the 90s hundreds of thousands starved. you literally just named the best example of what i'm talking about. thanks AHAHAH
@mc_fingus@ghost2004dotcom@Claralkpz you came into a thread to call people dumb and the moment someone answered you ran out of words. i'll let that speak for itself
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 there it is, "that wasn't real socialism". every time it fails it gets renamed. the state owned the farms, the factories and the bakeries. that IS abolishing private profit. you're not debating history anymore, you're just rebranding it
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 so the fix for wealth concentration was elected politicians in capitalist countries, and europe ended up with the most spread out wealth in modern history. great, we agree. the countries that abolished profit got a handful of party bosses running everything instead
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 historically wrong. in 1910 the richest 10% in europe owned about 90% of the wealth. by 2010 it was around 64%, after a century of capitalism. in germany the top 1% went from 50% to 27%. if it "naturally" concentrates forever, it's doing a terrible job, can you stop lying pls?
@mc_fingus@ghost2004dotcom@Claralkpz no it makes me a person able to accept that we don’t know something, without crying and having to rely on invisible stuff at all costs
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 so capitalism works, you just don't like that some people get rich from it. no explanation, no alternative, no numbers, just "nobody needs that much" on repeat. that's not an argument.
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 sure, you don't need billionaires. you need profit, prices and people free to start companies. billionaires are just what happens when someone sells something billions of people want. abolish that and you're back to the soviet bread queue
@HaMeAlc@Ariszn12 haber made synthetic fertilizer in a lab in 1909. it fed nobody until BASF, a company chasing profit, figured out how to make it at industrial scale. today about half the world's food depends on it. science discovers, markets scale. you need both
@NA_Dellsey@antonchadekoek Cheers man, respect for actually opening it, it’s cool when people want to have a real conversation. The bit you’re looking for is p. 7928, section on bread production in the Natufian: likely a feasting food, only became a daily staple once farming took hold.
@soyozmino i defent billionares because they are people (maybe they are evil) that create something usefull for society, you are here, crying lik a little kid, having fun on socials, doing nothing, if were for you, humanity would still have sticks and stones, dying at 30
@MickaelDDR@TRONEK__@antonchadekoek West Germany got about 11% of Marshall money, around 3% of its GDP. The UK got more than double that and grew way slower. Meanwhile the Soviets were shipping East German factories to Russia. So yeah, foreign relationships mattered. Just not the way you think.
@MickaelDDR@TRONEK__@antonchadekoek Germany lost its colonies in 1919. Then you got the cleanest experiment in history: same people, same culture, split in two. West got the economic miracle, East got a 10-year wait for a Trabant and a wall to stop people leaving. Korea, same story. No colonies needed.
@TRONEK__@antonchadekoek They tried. The USSR starved Ukraine, Europe’s breadbasket, then bought grain from the capitalists it swore to bury. Mao’s China lost tens of millions to famine. “Without profit” always ended as “without bread.” But I guess you don’t like history when it proves you wrong.