Once again, this is an Administrative Procedure Act complaint and changes to NEPA and NHRA are not relevant to the outcome.
BAAJA opponents keep making stuff up.
Jarrett Walker is a leading thinker on public transit and climate-friendly transportation
The divide on BAAJA is stark: on one side, progressives who recognize that for the world we want, we need to enable change in the physical world to build clean energy, transit, affordable housing
On the other, progressives who reject the tradeoffs that come with bipartisan legislation
The opposition keeps making stuff up because they know their actual position — “we will never consent to a natural gas pipeline no matter what we get in exchange” — sounds (and is) absurd.
We’re going to be a country that builds things again thanks to the work of @MartinHeinrich, @SenWhitehouse, and many many many staffers on both sides of the aisle who made BAAJA happen in the senate — an important bill on its own terms that lays the groundwork for more to come.
Wow. BAAJA passed the Senate. Congrats to @MartinHeinrich, @SenWhitehouse, @SenCapito and @SenMikeLee.
Heinrich and Whitehouse deserve special credit for understanding that decarbonization requires building things: wires, clean power, and new political coalitions. It has not been easy, but the effectiveness of our next climate laws depend on getting this right.
Let’s get this done in the House.
I think I'm engaging with your points! I just watched Kircher's explainer of his paper & methodology. He's clearly smart, honest, and earnest, and I agree with his call for think tanks to open source their data.
Re: emissions, it seems the difference comes down to whether BAAJA will increase energy demand and fossil fuel production relative to a world without BAAJA. Kircher thinks it will, and I honestly think that's possible. Would that mean higher emissions? Kircher also thinks so, but I'm not sure. Regardless, I'd say I'm no longer sure BAAJA will reduce emissions, so won't treat this as settled.
The thing about me is that reducing emissions isn't my only priority. I'm pro BAAJA because I believe it's too hard to build anything (e.g. California high-speed rail) and we need permitting reform.
On your last point, I think it's pretty straightforward why oil & gas and renewables both support this bill: they each expect to benefit. Oil & gas companies benefit from easier pipeline permitting, and renewables benefit from faster transmission and interconnection.
For data centers, faster and more predictable access to the grid is valuable even if they have to pay more for infrastructure. (While behind-the-meter gas generation is growing, that's not because data centers prefer to run mini power plans but mostly because they can't connect to the grid.) This doesn't necessarily mean ratepayers are fully protected but I think it explains why data centers support BAAJA. Sorry for the long reply and thanks for engaging!
Sorry, I don't want you to think I'm avoiding your rebuttals. I think in this thread you've written...
The bill is bad for the climate but non-partisan modeling shows it will reduce emissions. (What data do you have that's contrary?)
That the bill is a give-away to data centers but it forces them to pay full freight.
That the bill privileges oil & gas companies but it's largely supported by the renewable industry.
That the Trump administration will use the bill to do bad / illegal things but the bill doesn't give an 'ok' to do illegal things.
That this bill is horrible but it's currently looking like it will make it out of Senate because >60 Senators think it's good for Americans.
This is a super cynical, Senator Merkley needs to release his hold on new amendments so the Senate can vote and add bipartisan fixes that benefit tribes and housing!
- Without unanimous consent the Senate can’t vote on any more amendments. There are over a dozen amendments that would get votes
- If Merkley doesn’t agree to votes on amendments it doesn’t stop BAAJA — the bill will get a vote and pass the Senate on a simply majority (cloture was already passed)
- Merkley is cynically preventing a host of amendments from getting votes to hurt his colleagues and prevent the bill from including more bipartisan changes
- He’s blocking: $100M in funding for tribes, technical fixes to ensure small actions aren’t excluded from historic review, and a bipartisan change to support housing
The cynical game here seems to be that the Oregon senators are preventing Dem amendments from being adopted to a bill that’s going to pass the senate either way because they are hoping that it makes the bill marginally less likely to pass the House.
There has been a lot of analysis showing that this bill will make it easier to build all kinds of energy projects in addition to doing many other positive things for Americans -- see IFP's report.
You're right BAAJA isn't a climate bill but who's arguing it is? The point is permitting reform, which will make it more likely that if environmental groups do get a climate bill passed, it will actually get implemented.
BAAJA does not facilitate the building of data centers on public lands, nothing in the bill prevents illegally issued permits from being set aside or reversed, and the Federal Land Policy and Management Act does not authorize BLM to issue rights-of-way for data centers at all! People should read the bill.
They know the tribal issues are a more effective argument than their renewables fundamentalism (especially because the bill lowers emissions!) so they don’t want to address the tribal issues even though an opportunity to do so without scuttling the deal is on the table.
It’s infuriatingly cynical.
I think you’re right on the obsession with fossil fuels. The name calling in my mentions and accusations that I’m an oil shill for supporting BAAJA have risen as reasonable arguments fail. Outright bans of fossil fuels are nonsensical, but there’s a fringe of the environmental movement who can’t give up on the idea.
But I don’t think it’s environmentalists writ large opposing the bill. It’s the litigation focused NGOs specifically. The big groups have been silent because they support reform, but don’t want to be seen as such. IMO they’re shooting themselves in the foot by not being more vocally supportive; it cedes the narrative to the opposition. But in my conversations on the hill it’s clear many Congressional offices are beginning to understand that BAAJA is net win for nature. That’s messaging myself and others are sharing, and it’s a lot more successful than anti-fossil fuel rhetoric.
https://t.co/r9HcHiRiuz
@PeteSikora1@TheStalwart One thing I've noticed about your post, Pete (and please take this with all due respect), but you seem to have the position that if oil and gas, the tech industry, or Republicans support something, that obviously makes it bad. I just think that that's far too cynical.
This provision makes sense tho... There is a big difference between data centers that run accelerated computing systems and data centers those that are CPU based. The latter are traditional and enable the Internet while the former enable agents. I think it's fair for people to ask questions about it, but it's not a get-out-of-jail-free card for AI data centers.
As I understand this would fuck the Murkowski/Schatz amendment to address some of the enduring tribal concerns with NHPA/Section 106. Which is in keeping with the general theme of enviros being bad allies throughout this whole thing.
@PeteSikora1@TheStalwart What do you mean it's limited and there are loopholes? Like how is paying for all of their energy, paying high property taxes, etc. beating down the community?
@PeteSikora1@TheStalwart On the data center side, I'm also confused because this bill forces data centers to pay for all of the costs associated with their interconnection. That's not a handout.
@PeteSikora1@TheStalwart Pete, if this is an oil and gas bill, why do so many clean energy companies support it? Are they just idiots or something?
https://t.co/2RiIesiuWv
https://t.co/EDY13nZsHu