Two truths can coexist.
I have said before that one group controlling a large share of India’s airports and ports is not healthy for the country’s development.
The group is also spreading fast into other critical areas such as power, renewables, cement, copper and mining.
That needs to change.
Equally, Elon Musk has spent the last few days pressing India to clear Starlink.
Starlink is not just a technology, and Musk is not merely an entrepreneur.
In a national crisis, Starlink could be used in ways that threaten India’s security.
Musk is now one of the most influential private actors in America, not just the richest person or a leading tech entrepreneur.
He should not be treated as a neutral commercial partner. Elites in the US establishment do not want India to reach the kind of self sufficiency China has achieved.
In a major crisis, Musk and his companies could align with US policy in ways hostile to Indian interests.
In the latest move, the US has suspended green card sponsorship filings by Indian IT companies, including TCS, Infosys and Wipro, along with several other firms.
I would not be surprised if India faces tariffs as high as 100% for continuing to import oil from Russia.
The relationship between the US and India is under very serious strain.
America is becoming more and more hostile towards India.
The coming times are going to be very tough.
It is true that oligarchy exists in India.
It is equally true that Elon Musk cannot be relied on in a crisis and could become hostile to India.
Oligarchy is the internal problem that needs to be addressed.
Starlink is the external threat that should not be allowed in India.
We need to be extremely wary of Elon Musk.