Watching Shadow Work & Pensions Minister Joe Robertson lecture the public on welfare on #bbcqt last night was staggering.
For months, figures like Alan Milburn have attacked private ADHD assessments as "cash for diagnosis," painting people who seek private care as gaming the system. Yet Joe Robertson openly admitted he paid nearly £1,000 to the exact same private provider his local NHS uses—purely so he could bypass a massive waiting list—before using his privilege and platform to argue against cash disability benefits for people with ADHD.
It’s one rule for MPs who can afford to jump the queue, and another for the millions left languishing on NHS waitlists without support.
Worse still, politicians like Milburn are conveniently burying the government’s own landmark Fonagy Review. Professor Peter Fonagy’s independent review explicitly concluded that there is no evidence of widespread overdiagnosis—and actually found that cutting financial support worsens people's mental health.
Instead of acting on the full clinical evidence, MPs and advisors are cherry-picking isolated lines from the Fonagy report to suit their own benefit-cutting agendas while ignoring the parts that don't fit their narrative.
Using a £1,000 private diagnosis to pull the ladder up behind you on BBC Question Time isn't welfare reform—it’s pure hypocrisy. #ADHD #UKPolitics #QuestionTime
Watching Shadow Work & Pensions Minister Joe Robertson lecture the public on welfare on #bbcqt last night was staggering.
For months, figures like Alan Milburn have attacked private ADHD assessments as "cash for diagnosis," painting people who seek private care as gaming the system. Yet Joe Robertson openly admitted he paid nearly £1,000 to the exact same private provider his local NHS uses—purely so he could bypass a massive waiting list before using his privilege and platform to argue against cash disability benefits for people with ADHD.
It’s one rule for MPs who can afford to jump the queue, and another for the millions left languishing on NHS waitlists without support.
Worse still, politicians like Milburn are conveniently burying the government’s own landmark Fonagy Review. Professor Peter Fonagy’s independent review explicitly concluded that there is no evidence of widespread overdiagnosis—and actually found that cutting financial support worsens people's mental health.
Instead of acting on the full clinical evidence, MPs and advisors are cherry-picking isolated lines from the Fonagy report to suit their own benefit cutting agendas while ignoring the parts that don't fit their narrative.
Using a £1,000 private diagnosis to pull the ladder up behind you on BBC Question Time isn't welfare reform—it’s pure hypocrisy. #ADHD #UKPolitics #QuestionTime
@RITB_ I don't feel reassured at all, because there has been no transparency and no thought into how this will affect carers by removing PiP. And what about those who already hold SCC status?
Fact - Only two months ago, Labour scrapped the £7,400 earnings cap so every student in a household on Universal Credit gets Free School & College Meals.
Now, Alan Milburn’s welfare review wants to abolish Universal Credit for 16–24-year-olds and replace it with a "Youth Allowance."
Here is why that creates a massive problem for young people in education right now:
📌 Who is still eligible after 16? While holiday supermarket vouchers usually stop after Year 11 (age 16), term-time Free Meals continue up to age 18/19 in sixth form or college—and right up to age 25 for disabled students with an EHCP.
📌 The UC link: Every single one of those post-16 meals is legally unlocked by receiving Universal Credit.
📌 No safety net: Transitional protections ended in September 2026—meaning students no longer keep free meals automatically if benefit rules change.
If 16–24s are moved off UC onto a new Youth Allowance, estranged teens, young parents, and disabled students with EHCPs risk losing the daily college meals they only just gained.
Ministers must rewrite education law alongside the 2027 White Paper or one hand of government will quietly take away what the other hand just gave.
#UniversalCredit #FreeSchoolMeals #MilburnReview #EHCP #YouthAllowance #UKPolitics #CostOfLiving
Indeed and could have EHCP's or alternative forms of education such as EOTISc which those who have children/young people with SEND know how difficult it is to secure this without a vast amount of clinical evidence yet as we all know it is this age group also the LA like to target and cease EHCP's unlawfully. No one is talking about that Milburn's report barely mentioned the SEND crisis, unlawful LA's etc.
There are areas which actually accept self referrals to OT/SALT even physio, bypassing the GP, certainly in my area. However you are partly correct the GP is the person to refer people to specialities such as Dermatology, Rheumatology, Endocrinolgy those with medical specialities regardless of ages.
Actually I would state OT is the best clinician as they assess your daily ability to function with every day tasks, they also can assess for adaptive functioning and there are those who are actually specialised in neurodevelopmental conditions not only autism but also DCD and sensory processing difficulties, they are the ones who can assess what adjustments you would need in the workplace etc.
Gp's do not assess though, it is other professionals such as clinical psychiatrists, neurodelopmental specialists, Speech and Language Therapists, Psychiatrists, OT's etc who assess, young people under 18 will be under Paediatricians, those older could be under Adult Learning Disability Teams, Social Care Teams etc.
You are incorrect, DWP do indeed contact the GP to verify the conditions which you are claiming or stating you have, plus you provide diagnosis reports. GP's are not qualified to have an understanding of all conditions which have specialists. DWP just do not tell you if you have ticked the box to state that you consent to DWP contacting health professionals then they do.
@Gordy1967 They stopped giving levels in some areas back in 2013 onwards because not all clincians or nds services use the DSM V, there are some who use the ICD 11 or whichever is current at the moment. In America and Australia I do believe they use levels.
They can if they do not have the cognitive ability to live an independent life or if support needs are removed from them and there are varying degrees of autism, there are some who are able to work with adjustments and there are others who are unable to work especially if there are other complex conditions linked.
They obviously haven't thought about how certain benefits are tied such as Carer's Allowance. They have failed to recognise that if those who require support from social care and who has to fund a certain amount of social care because of PiP and LCWRA have they actually thought the social care bill will increase because carer's will no longer be able to afford caring, people who need the PA's to help them with personal care will also loose them.
@AnnieBeale1 And there are some children/adults who need apps and screens to help them communicate if they are non verbal, have speech difficulties, communication difficultes etc for example AAC devices, it can aid those also who have selective mutism, I mean seriously.
I thought you would know considering you are a retired CPN do you not remember the institutions back in the 60's, 70's 80's that is where those with Autism were placed because of the stigma attached and it was not just those with Autism, it was those born with intellectual disability, Down's Syndrome etc but back then they were called differently. As a former nurse I would have expected much more from you, you obviously did not keep up with the evidence base. Did you actually go around with your eyes shut. I actually grew up in a village where we had one such hospital called Bryn Y Neuadd and it still acts as an impatient facility for those with learning disabiliities et al.
@MartFromEngland It is if you have been diagnosed by an NHS Clinical Psychologist with clinically significant anxiety disorder following numerous assessments.