You claimed my definition of female is incorrect by providing a paper of a male and pointing out he doesn't fit my definition of female.
Well duh he doesn't... That's the point.
It's like you are arguing with something I never said. You are arguing with someone else's definition apparently.
You claimed my definition of female is incorrect. It can only be incorrect in COMPARISON to a correct one. But now you even admit you have zero, let alone a correct one.
I provided a definition that correctly classifies all females regardless of karyotype or DSD. If you don't like my inclusive definition, then there is nothing I can tell you. You are free to disregard it.
Again, I am already aware of male OT-DSD cases with evidence of oocytes. But I have never seen any case report where the presence/release of actual OVA occured. Indicators of possible ovulation is not evidence that it has actually occured. This is especially important because we know there are various conditions that can mimic signs of ovulation without it having actually occured.
The authors also seem to acknowledge that nothing is truly confirmed:
"The generated LH peak MAY THEORITICALLY result in ovulation"
@RoseAnadyomene@dyingsolitude@wrensayschilll@AsherahP0le Yet my definition reaches the exact same conclusion as the authors, and also correctly classifies female DSDs (Turner syndrome, CAH, etc). It's extremely consistent.
Whereas you have provided zero definition so far.
No. A corpus luteum cyst CAN be evidence of ovulatory activity but it isn't definitive proof that an egg was released. There's a documented phenomenon called luteinized unruptured follicle syndrome (LUFS), in which a follicle undergoes luteinization without rupturing or releasing an oocyte. This distinction matters in OT-DSD as well. So, it can point towards something, but it does *not* conclusively demonstrate ovulation, mature egg release, or fertility. Those are separate claims requiring additional evidence
@RoseAnadyomene@dyingsolitude@wrensayschilll@AsherahP0le You claimed the patient can't be male because of the indication of possible oocytes.
But the paper also states the patient had spermatogonia. By your same logic, you should ALSO deny that he is female.
You are not being consistent here.
1- Again, oocytes and ova are not the same thing. There is no evidence of that patient being fertile as female.
2- The paper itself states he is a male. So you disagree with the authors.
-My definition classifies the patient as male
-The authors also do.
-You don't
Looks like the problem here is you.
1- The report does not state that the patient produced ova or was fertile. Possibility of *oocytes* is *not* the same as *ova*.
2- My definition made no mention of gametes, so I don't know why you thought this paper debunked my definition.
Still confused by how you thought this paper addressed anything I've said.
@RoseAnadyomene@dyingsolitude@wrensayschilll@AsherahP0le You have not yet provided any case report of a female with OT-DSD who lacked vulvar development. Again, I repeat, an enlarged CLITORIS (which yes, some females with OTS have) is still part of a vulva. Clitoromegaly affects the vulva.
"Im counter exampling his definition with a person that fulfills only 1 of his criteria and is still a female."
You're not though. Since, as explained, females with CAH and other types of virilization of the external genitalia still have a vulva. It's not true that they only fit 1 criterion.
They either meet all 3 or 2 (for OTS).
You are right that some females are sometimes mis-sexed due to clitoromegaly.
Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH) is a classic example. Their enlarged clitoris resembles a small penis, so some doctors might mistakenly register them as male at birth. But they are female. With ovaries, uterus, fallopian tubes, etc.
@RoseAnadyomene@dyingsolitude@wrensayschilll@AsherahP0le Even in cases of an enlarged clitoris, it is still considered a clitoris rather than a penis, and thus part of the vulva. So, even if you are describing a female with OT-DSD and clitoromegaly, that person would still fit A and B.
"Müllerian persistence" applies to males (with PMDS).
It's a diagonistic term that implies that Müllerian structures should not have developed but they did.
In a female, Müllerian development is expected. So no, "Persistent Müllerian Duct Syndrome" or anything similar does not apply.
@RoseAnadyomene@dyingsolitude@wrensayschilll@AsherahP0le A typical vulva is a vulva that is typical.
An atypical vulva is a vulva that is atypical. It doesn't cease being a vulva.
Since you used Google AI earlier, then maybe you'll listen to it instead of me, let's see...
(3 parts) -->