No. It's fragmented because machining is a technology, not an industry.
You can only aggregate demand by being good at it, and you can't be good at everything. There isn't a magic process to "reliably" scale a business to absorb 10,000 product categories.
Machine shops are by far one of the last ultra-fragmented industries in the US. There are 17k machine shops, and nobody has more than 1% of the market.
Why? Nobody has built the technology or processes to reliably scale. It literally comes down to quality control at scale without a labor bottleneck.
Even solved that. We aren’t just repurposing a traditional machine shop. We are building self-improving manufacturing.
Featuring our CMM :)
@_baldtires Yeah. Anyone who wants a humanoid has never run an actual factory and paid the monthly repair bill to keep dozens of far more simple machines running.
@r14now I think it'll happen, but the devil is in the details. It's the edge cases that break automation and create pile-ups that are the biggest hurdle.
For us, it'd be possible by selectively choosing ideal parts for an automated line. Most would flow the normal way.
This is correct. OSH Cut also has little to no physical automation. Lots of software automation, but no physical.
It's not just hard to automate a high mix low volume factory, the economics also don't make sense. Most of the overheads are in the office, and automatable.
A top-level @anduriltech exec shared at dinner tonight that they use little to no automation in their manufacturing facilities because “automation today is incapable of adapting to low-volume and high complexity production lines”
There’s still such a gap between the automation dream and what is technically possible today.
@r14now At qty 50, the fixturing, setup, and automation programming time has to be ~0 for it to win over human labor. And that has to be true for the other 6000 SKUs made this week.
Very, very challenging.
@raghav2956 "High mix low volume" paints with a broad brush. Our factory would only benefit marginally from physical automation, and it'd be extremely hard, and extremely expensive. Usually, most of the overheads are in the office.
@c0nst i get that VC's need to toot their horns from time to time to stay relevant. but regular joe schmo's in a good niche need to stfu and keep their heads down, there's no benefit to bragging online other than stroking their ego. tons of downside tho