@BardofLagrandil A nation is its people. I can't replace every Egyptian with a Chinese person and have the same nation. There is no magic dirt and America was never meant to be a "melting pot for the 3rd world." George Washington signed this into law:
Checks China’s Immigration and Naturalization laws: YES! If China approves your naturalization, you become a Chinese citizen. That’s literally what China’s Nationality Law, Articles 7 and 8, establishes.
Furthermore, China officially recognizes 56 different ethnic groups, including Han, Mongols, Tibetans, Uyghurs, and Hui.
The Han are China’s largest ethnic group, comprising approximately 91% of its population. They share a historical, cultural, and linguistic heritage and are what most Westerners commonly think of when referring to ethnic Chinese people.
But here’s the important distinction: Being Chinese by nationality does NOT require being ethnically Han.
China’s 55 other officially recognized ethnic groups can all possess Chinese citizenship without being Han.
And if you became a naturalized Chinese citizen, you would be Chinese by nationality, even though your ethnicity and ancestry would remain unchanged.
The same principle applies in America. An American citizen does not have to be white or of European ancestry to be American.
Nationality and ethnicity are NOT the same thing.
Your hypothetical actually proves my point.
@piratechristian@corradofiore You are claiming that a nation has NOTHING to do with blood because Christians from different ethnic backgrounds are all included in God's holy nation.
@piratechristian@corradofiore Call her a parasite is a definition. Her and her people are locust and you facilitate the destruction of our country by allowing them to come here.
@piratechristian@corradofiore When we all stand before Jesus, men from every tribe, tongue and nation our inclusion in God's holy nation does not erase our earthly identity.
Bruh, did you even read your own screenshot?
Nobody is denying that ETHNOS can describe a people who share common ancestry.
But the word has a WIDER semantic range. One possible meaning does not eliminate the others. CONTEXT determines meaning.
And here’s something your Strong’s Concordance won’t explain.
In 1 Peter 2:9, Peter calls Christians a “HOLY NATION” (ἔθνος ἅγιον).
Are you seriously going to argue that Christians from different ethnic backgrounds all share the same biological ancestry?
Of course not!
Scripture itself uses ETHNOS to describe a people united by something OTHER than common ancestry, namely their identity in Christ.
Your lexical argument doesn’t establish that ethnicity and citizenship are identical, nor does it establish that every nation must consist of people sharing common ancestry.
You’re taking ONE legitimate meaning of a Greek word and insisting that it must govern EVERY context.
That’s not exegesis; it’s invincible ignorance.
@piratechristian@PhillipBarrCol1 And yet the word 'nation' derives from 'natus', i.e. "that which has been born": how can it not denote a breed / stock / race of people / tribe? Why does it exist as a separate word from 'empire' and 'state'? Honest question.
At present, Ilhan Omar is a Somali born AMERICAN CITIZEN. That is an established legal reality, regardless of what you or I think of her politics.
If evidence establishes that her citizenship was unlawfully obtained, our courts can adjudicate that question.
But YOU do not get to revoke someone’s citizenship because you dislike their ethnicity, ancestry, or political beliefs.
AMERICAN IS NOT A RACIAL CATEGORY.
Your personal definition of an American has no authority to supersede the United States Constitution.
@piratechristian@SomethingLatin It is a racial category and your personal liberal definition of an American has no authority to supersede the United States Constitution that was written by the founders for them and their posterity. Ilhan Omar is not their posterity.