@wmata Train 7718 on inbound Orange Line approaching WFC front car has a loose panel near center door banging loudly and rattling. Please fix when possible. Thank you.
@Skibo4Hermitage @clmarohn Thanks for the assist Brian!
For the record, density is good IF PLANNED AND DESIGNED WELL. And a reasonable amount of it is required for a place to be active, walkable, and inclusive.
@clmarohn@k_shepherd@RazzberryYams Agreed. But that's an inapt comparison.
One housing unit should be compared to one housing unit. If it's one house vs many apartments, that changes the math. 1:1, apartment dwellers have smaller per unit budgetary impacts.
@clmarohn You said "who me where I have advocated for more density". The type of development that you - and I - want to see requires more density than typical suburban sprawl. By advocating for good, efficient development in a compact design, you're advocating for (modestly) more density.
@RidleyDM@cunningham1975 @ryanscottborman @dirkcgrunwald @arpitrage @PhilWalkable At some point we lose too much economically valuable land for agriculture, commerce, etc. to make it workable, all of which offsets the cost of infrastructure (and living in general). But sure? As a mathematical exercise we could all fit into Alaska at this density too.
@k_shepherd@RazzberryYams@clmarohn I agree Kevin. But there are thresholds/tipping points where you generate the need for another piece of horizontal or vertical infrastructure. But per unit, more apts are a MUCH better for budgets than more houses (fewer kids, fewer people, fewer trips, less park needs, etc.)
@RidleyDM@cunningham1975 @ryanscottborman @dirkcgrunwald @arpitrage @PhilWalkable Okay, I guess if you assume endless sprawl, multiple hour commutes...
Assume 2.5 people per hh and 3 units/ac., we need 44,000,000 acres. There are 72,000,000 acres of "urbanized" land in the US today. So that leaves only 28,000,000 acres for EVERYTHING else. Which isn't much.
@clmarohn You asked what I thought.
But okay: "70 years of unproductive growth...has buried our local communities in financial liabilities. We are now forced to grow lest it all fall apart"
Show me an example of "productive growth" at comp density of 1:4 or less
https://t.co/zs85tJzqKa
@cunningham1975@RidleyDM @ryanscottborman @dirkcgrunwald @arpitrage @PhilWalkable Redlining and covenants. Absolutely. And single use zoning that prevented housing options.
@clmarohn That a state that's been nothing but sprawl for several decades (Delaware) is in a better financial position than its neighbors (Maryland and New Jersey) which both have several major legacy cities and towns and much more progressive planning policies and higher average incomes.
@clmarohn He was a pretty brutal emperor at times๐ฌ
How do you make some number of 1/4 acre lots on a vacant parcel less dense exactly? If the answer is that they're 1/10th acre with a large park, great. I'm all for it. But most of the infrastructure needs remain comparable.
@Yimbymanatee@clmarohn Agreed! But the housing unit that tips the scale doesn't do that alone. So once you're about to tip that scale, you will need to add a lot more housing to make that $1,000,000 traffic signal pencil out.
@RidleyDM@cunningham1975 @ryanscottborman @dirkcgrunwald @arpitrage @PhilWalkable I think that's basic math, no? Maybe if the whole country was as dense with single family homes as LA...
@cunningham1975@RidleyDM @ryanscottborman @dirkcgrunwald @arpitrage @PhilWalkable I agree Chris. I think that's the rub. Wealthier suburbs do fine. Poorer suburbs suffer. Same as cities. That's the rub. It's not about density directly. Socioeconomic diversity is necessary to have a balanced budget AND quality social services.
@RazzberryYams@clmarohn Agreed. All I'm saying is the quantity of social services provided as a place grows tends to expand exponentially offsetting 1:1 cost savings.
@clmarohn Btw, I'm not advocating for sprawl. It's a mess and is highly inefficient. And it costs taxpayers in the long run. But that doesn't mean it's unsustainable. Just inefficient and wasteful. It's a bad choice, but nonetheless a viable one.
@clmarohn I think it might be a more accurate description to say that greater density results in the potential for more efficient use of infrastructure. Which is true. But even under the densest scenario, infrastructure utilization is not going to be perfect. There's always excess.
@clmarohn I really appreciate all your advocacy but I think there needs to be a more nuanced approach here. It's one thing to point out that a Walmart parking lot is land intensive and a poor use of space. But I think that economies of scale from greater housing density is complicated.