On my way to the office this morning, I passed a group of young people protesting, a Palestinian flag draped over their shoulders.
And I asked myself a question I can't shake: why does this generation always fall into the same trap? No matter the history. No matter the context. Even the ones from wealthy families, who went to the best schools, who were dealt every good card. Always the same trap.
I don't think it's stupidity. I think it's a mechanism. And a mechanism can be taken apart, piece by piece.
A. The observation: everything the state touches becomes unaffordable.
Look at economist Mark Perry's famous chart, the one people call "the chart of the century." It tracks US prices since 2000.
At the top, what explodes: hospital services, college tuition, textbooks, childcare, housing. Increases of +100%, +150%, up to +250%, far above general inflation.
At the bottom, what collapses: TVs, software, phones, toys, clothing. A TV today costs a fraction of what it did in 2000, for an infinitely better product.
Look at what separates the two groups. It isn't technology. It isn't complexity. It's one variable: how much the state is involved.
At the top, sectors that are subsidized, regulated, shielded from competition, where the state funds demand and blocks supply. At the bottom, sectors where companies fight every single morning to serve you better and cheaper.
B. The mechanism: why it's systematic.
When the state subsidizes demand without freeing supply, prices rise. Every time. Guaranteed student loans, and universities raise tuition. Housing aid plus blocked building permits, and rents skyrocket. Administered healthcare, and bureaucracy eats the budget before it ever reaches the patient.
In France it's even more vicious, because the price doesn't disappear: it hides. You never see the hospital bill, you pay it through payroll contributions. You never see the cost of school, you pay it through taxes. Public spending at 57% of GDP, one of the heaviest tax burdens in the world, more than €3.4 trillion in debt. And the result? Overflowing ERs, falling PISA scores, young people who can't afford to live in the city where they work.
The market didn't fail in these sectors. It was never allowed in.
C. Suffering demands a culprit.
A 22-year-old lives all of this in their bones. They can't find a place to live. Their degree either buries them in debt or opens no doors. The future feels blocked. That suffering is real, and I don't deny it for a second.
But human beings can't stand suffering without a culprit. They need a face. A scapegoat.
And this is where everything is decided: who taught them how to read the world?
D. Whoever tells the story picks the villain.
Schools are public. Universities are public. Culture runs on grants. Film goes through funding committees. Public broadcasting shapes the narratives. The people handing down the interpretive framework are, overwhelmingly, paid by the very system that creates the problem.
Do you really think that system is going to name itself as the culprit?
No. It names the capitalist. The boss. The landlord. "The rich." The multinational. The commercial West. Same role, same casting, every time.
E. One lens, a thousand causes.
And this brings me back to that flag. A generation taught to read every situation through a single lens, oppressor on one side, rich, Western, capitalist, oppressed on the other, will apply that lens everywhere. To housing. To climate. To conflicts on the other side of the world. The cause changes, the lens stays. That's why the trap is always the same: it's not the cause that draws them in, it's the way of thinking that was installed in them.
F. The perfect inversion.
Here's the irony. Capitalism is the force that drove down the price of almost everything it touched. The state is the force that blew up the price of almost everything it captured. And young people blame the first for the crimes of the second.
It's like blaming the firefighter for the fire because you saw him at the scene.
G. The ballot box confirms it.
In the US, a few weeks out from the midterms, a large share of urban young voters is getting ready to vote Democrat for more state, more spending, more regulation. New York elected a self-described socialist mayor, carried by young voters, on promises of rent freezes and city-run grocery stores. Rent freezes, the policy that has made housing scarcer everywhere it's been tried. The cure that worsens the disease.
In France, it's the same play in two acts. Part of the youth votes for the radical left, which promises more state. Another part votes for the center, which promises to "manage" the state well, and has dug the debt deeper than ever. Two different ballots, one shared assumption: the problem is the market, the solution is the state.
H. The way out.
These young people aren't stupid. They're right to be angry. They're just aiming at the wrong target.
The day they understand that their rent, their tuition and their hospital are expensive precisely because the state runs them, their anger will change direction. They'll stop protesting against those who create. They'll start protesting against those who capture.
That day, the greatest intellectual scam of our time will be over.
This is the only tweet you need to read about SIR. Whether you support BJP or CJP, you must read this entire tweet to understand the facts.
SIR is NOT something BJP invented. Congress Govt also conducted voter list revisions multiple times. The purpose is simple, to remove dead, duplicate and ineligible voters, and update incorrect records.
But since 2002, no Govt has conducted an SIR, that means the last updated data of voter lists was of 2002, and all the dead, duplicate and illegal voters since 2002 are still in the Electoral records.
Which is why the numbers are high this time. The Govt literally has to remove 22 years of incorrect data from voter lists.
Around 220 million Indians died between 2002 - 2026. And around 62 million of them were registered voters.
So, out of the 65 million number you see online, 62 million are dead voters only.
The remaining 2 million are duplicate voters, and 1 million are illegal voters.
From a population of 150,000 million only 1 million illegal voters are removed.
Even after this, Govt has given you the option to fill out Form 6 and correct the mistake if your name was wrongly removed during SIR.
A legal citizen would never fear to fill Form 6. Because you just need your identity card and citizenship proofs for it.
SIR was never an issue. It has simply been turned into an agenda by Deep State and America for regime change in India.
And if, despite all these facts, you still support CJP baseless claims, then trust me, you have started blindly hating the Govt without thinking about the country growth.
We need to inform people that SIR is necessary, not just this time but periodically time to time.
Especially to people of Delhi, spread these facts, we can't let outside powers disturb the peace of Delhi and India.
Adding one point most people miss.
The law already gives anyone with doubts a remedy. Any candidate or voter can challenge the result of their constituency through an election petition in the High Court within 45 days of the result (Sections 80, 81 and 100, RP Act 1951). Sworn. Evidence on record. Open to cross examination. If the claim is theft across 50 seats, the law expects 50 petitions with proof.
That is the forum for vote theft. Not a press conference.
So ask a simple question. How many of these allegations have reached a courtroom with an affidavit attached .. ? The silence is the answer.
On EVMs, the Supreme Court has already heard the case. In ADR v. Election Commission (April 2024), it rejected the plea to return to paper ballots and refused 100% VVPAT matching. It also let the 2nd and 3rd placed candidates ask for the microcontrollers in 5% of machines per assembly segment to be checked by the manufacturer.
The tool to test the claim exists. Use it, or stop making the claim.
On the SIR, Article 324 puts the rolls with the Commission, not the government of the day. Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950 allows revision at any time. After two decades of migration, deaths and duplicate entries, cleaning the roll is housekeeping, not conspiracy.
Then there is the selective outrage test. The same machines gave opposition parties wins in Bengal 2021, Punjab 2022, Himachal 2022, Karnataka 2023 and Telangana 2023. Nobody called those rigged.
A batsman who disagrees with the umpire can ask for a review. He doesn't walk off the field calling the umpire a thief, and he certainly doesn't do it only on the days he gets out.
Criticise the ECI. Demand transparency. File petitions. Win in court. That is democracy working.
Abusing the umpire every time you lose the match is how institutions die.
We have seen the OHCHR’s remarks about today’s events in New Delhi.
India is the world’s largest democracy, where the right to peaceful assembly is guaranteed by our Constitution and safeguarded by robust institutions, an independent judiciary and a free media. As in every democracy, Indian citizens exercise this right subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of public order. The authorities, for their part, act in accordance with the law, and our courts remain available to all for redressal of any grievances.
The OHCHR’s concerns are therefore misplaced and constitute an unwarranted interference in the internal affairs of India.
In this context, OHCHR would also do well to devote comparable attention to large-scale protests elsewhere, consistent with its mandate of impartiality and non-selectivity.
@MEAIndia@IndianDiplomacy@PMOIndia@DrSJaishankar@abagchimea
124 Former IAS, IFS and allied services officers have issued an open letter to the citizens of India, strongly defending the #ElectionCommission and the Special Intensive Revision (#SIR) of electoral rolls, while questioning allegations of vote rigging without credible evidence.
Highlighting India's transformation from an era of booth capturing, ballot box stuffing and electoral violence, the officers said that today's electoral system has multiple layers of checks and safeguards, including polling agents, #EVM sealing, strong-room security and #VVPAT verification. They cited #Bihar's 2025 Assembly elections which recorded no re-polling and the highest voter turnout since 1951.
Scanned your entire timeline and not a single tweet on France riots! Doesn’t it warrant your attention?
215 teenagers, 85 school staff, 700 policemen injured in clashes. 6,100 people arrested since the protests began, the overwhelming majority of them minors. And detention in India is what bothers you.
•Indira didn't resign after the Emergency.
•Nehru didn't resign after the defeat by China.
•Manmohan didn't resign after 26/11.
But Modi must resign because few anti nationals were detained at Jantar Mantar?
Different leaders. Different standards. Same shameless hypocrisy.
Do you know why they want Gyanesh Kumar to 'resign'?
Why not 'remove' him - if he has done wrong.
That is the process driven and constitutional way.
Because it would require numbers in both houses of Parliament that they don't have.
Okay, so why don't they present evidence of 'vote chori' and 'EVM hacking' to the Supreme Court?
The Supreme Court has powers to invalidate election results in certain cases.
Because there is no such evidence.
All the 'evidence' and 'bombastic claims' are only for TV cameras and social media, to get people agitated.
Which is why they are mobilizing crowds as a gun to the head, and saying - resign or there will be anarchy and violence in the national capital.
There is a simple word to understand this - blackmail.
It should not be tolerated.
The country should respond to it in the harshest manner possible.
Do whatever it takes.
People who can't win elections through legitimate means don't get to enter through the backdoor with the use of violence.
Bruhhh, some Gen Z actually made a game on CJP, exposing them in the funniest way possible.
Creativity is insane and somehow this is way more entertaining than their cringe ahh posts on X. 😭
https://t.co/JzZOJOspmz
🚨No way someone has made an entire game exposing CJP. We all need to support this initiative
This game deserves to trend all over India
https://t.co/YZ7XHGFIHA
Dear Elon @elonmusk
You hv certainly stirred up plenty of reaction with ur posts. But this needs a response from me, as did ur “Electronic Voting machines can be hacked” post from some time ago.
As someone who knows a little bit abt Telecom as someone who played a decent-ish role in building Indias wireless sector as an Entrepreneur and then as a policy maker , let me share my thoughts.
It is true that Indias Telecom was a sector beset with opaqueness and corruption for several decades - where cronies ruled under the benevolent love and the politics of ur latest fan (name not withheld - @RahulGandhi )
But under PM @narendramodi , 3 principles govern the tech (including Telecom/Internet) sector.
Open, Safe & Trusted and Accountable.
#OSTA
✅ Open - Free from any monopoly-duopoly. Free and fair competition.
✅ #SafeAndTrusted - Infra, Network , Platforms must be safe and trusted.
✅ Accountable - Every participant should be legally accountable for safety and trust.
I was a MP first and then part of PM @narendramodi jis team when this framework was developed. I have more than a little experience of fighting years of political and bureaucratic opaqueness and corruption, which shaped these principles.
so todays India is not that old crony driven India.
I am not in govt anymore and certainly dont speak for it. But it seems to me that Govt has made it clear: all three satcom licensees are at broadly the same stage of ensuring security clearance by verifying its safety and trust first, then spectrum.
Satellite IP services have many security implications. More so in a country like India which has faced years of Terror and insurgency supported by inmical state actors in our neighbourhood. From 26/11 terror attacks to recent ones in Pahalgam, satcom has been preferred comm for Terrorists. Satellite VOIP and encryption creates more challenges security wise. Not insurmountable but new capabilities and capacity hv to be built to ensure Safety and Trust.
I hv used @Starlink and I think its awesome technology - and represents a new era in mobility innovation. No doubt.
But a country has to plan for itself and its interests before every new choice. Thats what India is doing. Patience is unavoidable and in this case is a necessity.
@elonmusk, dear, because I greatly respect you, let me say this. Cozying up to the likes of @RahulGandhi will not escalate a Starlink license. But further delay it.
Companies all over the world successfully do business with India. As you know, foreign partnership starts with respect for the country and its leadership. Rahul lacks respect for both his own country and PM Modi. He is bad company.
And “the other guy” is one of the greatest and most powerful leaders in the world today and will be governing India a long time. You want a license? I suggest shifting your public messages to the attention of PM @narendramodi and not wannabees like Rahul.
Congrats on your award today, BTW. Thank you for all your contributions to our great country. 🇺🇸
Deleted .. is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that headline.
Add up the ECI's own numbers. 3.01 + 6.30 + 2.80 + 1.02 + 0.26 = 13.39 crore. Every single name sits in a defined bucket. That's about 14% of the 95.4 crore reviewed. No mystery hole in the roll.
Dead voters first. India now registers 80 lakh+ deaths a year. Most states last did an intensive revision in 2002-04. Against two decades of deaths, 2.8 crore flagged as deceased looks conservative, not excessive.
Shifted voters next. Census 2011 counted 45 crore internal migrants. Many are women who moved after marriage, many are men who moved for work. Either way, a name stays behind on the old roll.
6.3 crore permanently shifted is no shock in a country that moves this much. And this didn't happen in a back room. 10 lakh BLOs prepared the lists. 22 lakh party BLAs got them booth by booth. Every party had eyes on every booth. A full month for claims. Form 6 open for anyone left out.
So here's the question for those shouting 13 crore deleted … how many of those names did your own BLAs object to, with evidence .. If the answer is a handful, the noise is political, not factual.
A clean roll protects every genuine voter. A bloated one is where fake votes hide.
Let me tell you the difference between Democracy under Congress Rule and Dictatorship under fascist Modi.
Under the Congress rule:
1. Majrooh Sultanpuri was jailed for a year because he wrote a poem criticising PM Jawaharlal Nehru and his government's policies.
2. Indira Gandhi jailed thousands of political leaders, activists and journalists during Emergency.
3. During Indira Gandhi's rule forcible compulsory mass sterilisation of males took place, with even young unmarried men forced to undergo vasectomies.
4. Rajiv Gandhi overturned the Supreme Court's Shah Bano judgment which had ordered that Muslim women too should be given maintenance after divorce.
5. Sitaram Kesri, in 1998 was locked inside his office bathroom when he had opposed Sonia Gandhis Presidentship election.
6. PM Manmohan Singh cleared an ordinance to nullify the Supreme Courts decision that any MP or MLA convicted of a crime with a sentence of two years or more would face immediate disqualification.
7. Rahul Gandhi tore that ordinance in full view of the cameras.
Mind you, these were all democratic governments.
Dictatorship descended on India only after Modi came to power.
1. When farmers were allowed to block highways around Delhi and Haryana for three years.
2. When Vinesh Phogat was allowed to protest for months and even slap PT Usha.
3. When Abhijeet Dipke and CJP followers are free to protest in BJP ruled states even abusing Modi and his late mother.
Hence proved Modi is a dictator.