The answer is simple...
Your currency is becoming worthless because consumer credit is devaluing your currency...
Not government debt... consumer debt.
Every mortgage, credit card, personal loan, and consumer finance agreement expands the money supply, with the result being more currency chasing the same goods, services, and assets.
Meanwhile, you're encouraged to keep your savings in currency, where inflation quietly erodes your purchasing power year over year.
The government wants you to hold the devaluing currency.
Then you have the migration of inflation to CPI in the 90's. We changed how inflation is measured!!
Let that sink in...
Inflation *should be* tracked against a fixed basket of essential goods and services over long periods, allowing people to see how much purchasing power has actually been lost.
Now, baskets, weightings and methodologies are regularly adjusted based on what consumers are purchasing.
Fresh becomes processed.
Branded becomes generic.
Beef becomes frozen beef.
Frozen beef becomes chicken or pork.
Chicken becomes imported frozen alternatives.
This may accurately record changing consumer behaviour, but it no longer measures the cost of maintaining the same standard of living.
@Nancyshollow@robprogressive The NHS?
The state Pension?
Welfare and disability services?
Defence?
Education?
Those are the 5 biggest not including the debt obligations.
The problem will come when the investors turn to other instruments...
I guarantee you that gilts will eventually cease to be attractive relative to equities, corporate bonds, foreign sovereign debt, property, or other assets, and the UK will be required to offer higher yields to attract lenders.
Now, the £1 trillion that is going to be refinanced at current rates over the next 18 months will create a larger obligation, but no more than issuing £140+ billion per annum to service the current deficit.
Even if (or when) the obligation reaches £300-400 billion per annum, as long as the UK can attract sufficient capital to service this obligation alongside the settlements, there is nothing to worry about.
So, the debt must either be:
Refinanced on acceptable terms; repaid through future surpluses; or eroded through inflation and currency debasement...
The UK is choosing the first option.
Although the UK's national debt obligations are not currently serviceable, they are not at the point (yet) where they require additional inflationary expansion.
The obligations for the most part are serviced through additional gilts issuance, and this can continue for decades provided investors remain willing to purchase the debt.
So it's not a problem per se... since it's not the UK taxpayer servicing the obligations, it's insurance companies, central banks, and pensions providers purchasing gilts.
National debt is not the primary source of monetary debasement.
The much larger issue is private debt creation.
Every time a credit provider creates a mortgage, personal loan, car loan, business loan, BNPL contract, or approves a credit card transaction that is not settled at the end of the month, new credit enters the system.
When that credit finances productive investment, future output will for the most part offset its effects of expansion, however, when it finances consumption, the money supply expands without the corresponding increase in value being created.
e.g. If I borrow to build a factory, farm, mine, or productive business, society gains additional productive output that will offset the expansion.
You can debate to your heart's content how wealth should be distributed, but first it has to exist.
You cannot distribute what does not exist.
Distribution ultimately determines who gets the pie,
but it's production that determines how large the pie is.
It's an unfortunate truth, but when productive growth stagnates whilst debt, spending and currency expansion continue, then society inevitably becomes poorer regardless of how the wealth is distributed.
The reason the people in your country (and a majority of the west) face soaring bills, rents and prices is not simply because companies are greedy or because wages are too low.
It's quite simply because your currency supply has expanded far faster than the creation of real value within your economy.
More money is chasing the same quantity of goods, services and housing. That's basic economics.
So... what will you do about this? What's your solution?
Will you create more real value within society through productive investment, industry and infrastructure?
Or will you actively reduce monetary expansion and excess liquidity?
Now one of the big questions is what's going to happen when the bottom 70% can no longer afford the basics??
We're getting there.
There is no doubt that AI and automation can create enormous abundance...
The real question is who receives the benefits of that abundance, and what will occur, because historically, consumer economies depend on mass purchasing power.
Businesses, no matter their size ultimately require customers, and if a large enough majority cannot afford housing, food, energy, transport, healthcare, or family formation, several things tend to happen in order, because we have seen this happen at least 3 times in recorded history.
First we see falling birth rates followed by reduced consumption and higher household debt, this is then followed by political instability and the growth of populist movements, and ultimately the introduction of a totalitarian regime to quell the rise of populism.
If AI can create infinite entertainment in the form of games, videos, stories, companions, and virtual experiences, then this could could satisfy the desires of the vast majority, effectively turning them into a servile underclass.
@FreeAdviceGuy We are going to have more money because the system we are using is increasing the supply by ca. 20% per annum.
What we need to do in the west is increase productivity.
A nominal gain is not necessarily a real gain simply because you don't take into account debasement.
If an asset rises 10% while the currency's purchasing power falls 15%, the owner may be wealthier in nominal terms and poorer in real terms.
This is because money is not static in value, that stopped in the 70's with the repeal of Bretton Woods..
Additionally, you have not existed in a capitalist economic system for over a century.
There are different forms of socialism, however, most modern socialist movements have been heavily influenced by Marx regarding capital, labour, and ownership...
They may not have an end goal of the removal of money and government through perpetual surplus, but they are still Marxist.
You can put lipstick on a pig, but it's still a pig.
Also, there is a significant difference between describing a position, and advocating a position.
I can describe what the current system is...
So, in a liquid market, every seller requires a buyer and every buyer requires a seller, even if that is a trade liquidation.
When retail buys near the top of a move and we sell into that demand, the late entrants provide the liquidity that allows us to exit positions.
This is a description, pure and simple.
Now depending on your school of thought...
Is this simply price discovery?
Is this exploitation?
Is this an example of why markets require regulation?
I am heterodox, I have been for decades.
Both Socialism and Communism are the Marx version.
I don't support either...
What I want is Laissez Faire, I want there to be the possibility of failure, but I also can see the trajectory of a system.
IMHO, there will always be government intervention because people for the majority are unable to accept responsibility for their actions, nor lack thereof.
Additionally, how much intervention can an economy tolerate before the secondary effects become worse than failure? Because it's happening now.
You only need to look at the UK.
Marx's vision of socialism has never been attempted.
That being said, if your assertion is that the implementation of the command economy was an attempted implementation of socialism, then I would have to agree with you.
The issue is that it requires levels of trust that have not existed in centuries, since it assumes implicitly that people will accept collective outcomes by contributing according to their abilities and not exploit the system.
No, what I am saying is that it has never been tried.
The political elite stop at the command economy with supertotalitarianism.
I don't agree with socialism, nor the extension communism, since I don't personally believe that the economic theories can exist without a serf class because the economy still requires someone to perform undesirable or labour intensive work.
Societies have generally solved this problem historically through direction and coercion in command economies, or bonded servitude in feudal economies.
I believe that the west is currently heading toward a form of rentier mercantilism, where the government will be willing to support anyone willing to build value.
Some political theorists I have talked with are calling this coming system neo feudalism where a vast majority of people will become indentured servants, bonded to debt.
I realise that some believe technological productivity alongside broader asset ownership can prevent this from happening, I would say that ship sailed somewhere between 2007 and 2011.
It is a form of fascism called Corporatism.
It is a system that rewards organisational scale and compliance capacity more than productive efficiency, leading to increasing concentration of economic power.
Corporations are not products... you need to stop thinking of it as a brand.
They produce leverage by aggregating capital, absorbing regulatory costs, acquiring competitors, managing risk, and controlling distribution of established brands.
Consumer credit is increasingly used to maintain consumption because of the debasement caused by the reliance on consumer credit that weakens the purchasing power of the currency.
When you borrow, the money never disappears, and when you use those funds to consume, there is no value created within society.
Why do you think you can get a credit card with a $20 000 limit with no employment history, nor proof of income?
I digress... Corporations absorb the associated costs of their subsidiary brands.
Innovation is frequently developed by smaller companies and later acquired by or integrated into larger organisations because they cannot absorb the regulatory costs imposed.
So, since the end of the Cold War, the West has shifted from primary and secondary production towards services and tertiary production, because services and tertiary productivity can both expand without the same requirement for energy surplus, industrial capacity, or infrastructure development.
This makes it politically attractive.
This system is sustained through debt creation and financial expansion, both private and public.
Profits remain private, distributed across the investor classes, whilst many risks and costs are distributed across society through inflation, taxation and public liabilities because compliance functions generate employment in a service dominated economy, supporting political stability.
In order to ensure there is sufficient employment, the state creates additional compliance measures, because compliance and regulation creates jobs, and jobs create political stability.
The state must also adhere to these rules... creating a growing administrative and governance burden, which must be funded through additional taxation.
When taxation alone is insufficient, this is funded through a budget deficit with bond sales, rewarding those who fund their systems through the tax of residents and companies, or additional bond sales, which brings us to today...
Governments are currently issuing bonds to satisfy obligations in addition to the budget deficit.
Eventually, the investors (Insurance companies, Pensions, and Investment houses) will lose confidence, and when that happens, the system will collapse... but not just yet.